I’ve tended to stick with 143-145mm saddles as I’ve not like the rubbing the inside of the thighs that wider ones can cause. However, I got a bit overexcited during the Chiggle implosion sale and spotted a titanium WTB SL8 saddle in wide for silly money. I tried WTB’s saddle sizing calculator (based on wrist size) and I was surprised when it came up wide. My sit bone measurements just touched the lower end of the width range for wide saddles too.
I gave the SL8 a go and it’s be fantastic – no rubbing, more comfortable than the Fabric Scoop it replaces and I no longer have numb genitals when climbing.
However, there’s more to saddle design that just width & the SL8 is a much flatter saddle than I’ve used before, has a full cut out and has thin padding (which I thought might be a problem but isn’t) so it’s hard to say whether an extra 5mm or so width is what’s making the difference.
https://www.wtb.com/pages/fit-right-system