Best tyres I’ve had were in the OP’s size 195/55/15. Vredestein Sportrac 3, on the front of an old MR2. Never let go once and it’s hardly a car reknowned for it’s front grip (or any grip for that matter).
Vredesteins on the front, Toyo Proxes T1-R on the back, and I had a good 10,000 miles out of all of them with very minimal wear.
Avon ZV5 on a mondeo, don’t last long, but nothing goes much beyond 12k on the front of it. They have performed better than a lot of other stuff, especially when the tread depth is getting marginal they still hold out on the wet.
Got some Toyo T1R on the girlfriends MX5, cheap and require a fair bit more to get sideways than the previous Admirals it came with.
stay away from Wanli tyres no matter how cheap you are
noisy as f***!
and I don’t want to get anywhere near the limits on these. thankfully I drive like an old fart so probably never will
! I took the car (2006 Citroen C4 1.6 petrol) in to the garage for emergency oil diagnostics recently. After changing the oil & oil filter, they did a test drive & thought the wheel bearings were well & truly fubarred, so they checked – no problem with wheel bearings, just noisy tyres
After all the “it’s your only contact with the road”, “it could be a child’s face next time”, etc etc scaremongering I bought uniroyal rain-experts. Then this happened within 500 miles.
Track use by any chance? If so did you remember to increase pressures to support the sidewall (it’s only stiff sidewall R rated tyres that have pressure reduced as they heat up).
Otherwise I’d go with the tyre compound being/going off for some reason (storage conditions, manufacturing issue).
Remember tyre performance is weight and drive specific, what works well on a heavy RWD may not suit a light FWD (chooose your own comparions). As a decent middle of the road (hee, hee) tyre I’ve used Yokohama A-Drive’s before with great results on light-medium weight FWD cars.