Interesting, always found the Fountaine great but have heard mixed reviews.
I stayed there and was very disappointed. The rooms were tiny, the ‘secure bike storage’ they promised was a wheel rack in the courtyard and I sent the same meal back twice. Chef seemed to have totally lost interest in anything to do with food. The beer and breakfast were great though.
Had a fantastic meal at Grassington House and the service was great.
If you want something a bit different you could try the Hark to Bounty at Slaidburn (not in the Dales but fairly near to Settle). Gastro pub rather than restaurant food, but the rooms are upstairs in the old assizes, a bit like staying in a 17th century prison. If you’ve got a partner who believes in ghosts this provides some excellent wind-up opportunities 🙂