just claimed for rail fares
i pay for my own commute to work.
To be fair, MPs are supposed to have two “work sites”: Westminster and their home constituency office. I think it’s fair that he claims for travel from home to one of those offices (but not both simultaneously). I think that would be the practice in most private companies.
I also would say that I don’t mind if non-Home Counties MPs rent a 1-bedroom apt in Zone 1/2 at market rates. Again, most private companies that needed their employees at a remote location for an extended period would do the same thing. There are hundreds of serviced/executive apartment companies in London filled with businesspeople. But this whole “live with my parents, pay rent to my sister, dredge my moat” bullsh1t is just taking the pish.
“…quite apart from money spent by tourists who come here because we have a Monarchy. FWIW, several years ago I read somewhere that the cost to the German people for running a Federal system was at least twice what our Monarchy costs us.”
This makes no sense whatsoever.
1) People don’t visit the UK because it has a monarchy today. Some of them come to gawp at the old castles, absolutely true. But if the monarchy were abolished, they would still come. People still visit Versailles, the Kremlin, the Taj Mahal, Neuschwanstein Castle and whatever the castle in Prague is called even though their royal families have been shot/dissolved/expropriated/whatever.
In fact, if the monarchy were abolished, the tourists would be able to wander around more of the palaces because the dole scum would have been evicted.
2) The German Federal government has actual, operational/executive responsibility for external relations, federal law, enviromental regulation, standards etc for a population of 82 million people. The cost of the monarchy just has to manage the affairs of a small number of people in the household. If what you say is accurate, then the fact that they need half the German federal budget to do it is a searing indictment of their ineptitude and inefficiency.
In practice I think your figure just doesn’t make sense or is missing some vital information. Perhaps you can dig up the relevant info.