Home Forums Chat Forum Diesel Turbo whistle question

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
  • Diesel Turbo whistle question
  • unfitgeezer
    Free Member

    As I have never owned a diesel car before is it normal to hear the turbo whistle ?

    Its not loud but I can hear it if I rev up !??! Mate of mine says his Citroen is like that.

    Putting out to the masses !

    legend
    Free Member

    Yes it’s normal

    chrisdiesel
    Free Member

    Turbo diesels will always make a whistle noise BUT if the noise has got louder all of a sudden it’s poss an intercooler leak , or a split it an air pipe , this will def be the case if the car had lost power at the same time I.e turbo boost pressure is leaking out of the system .

    unfitgeezer
    Free Member

    no power loss that I know of how could I tell if there was power loss?

    its prob always done it I have just never noticed (only had it a week )

    only does it if I rev or apply more gas and its not loud at all

    Cougar
    Full Member

    only does it if I rev or apply more gas

    That’s generally how turbos work. (-:

    v8ninety
    Full Member

    I shouldn’t worry.

    bedmaker
    Full Member

    Some do it more than others – my Octavia vrs tdi sounds like it has an ambulance under the bonnet when pootling through 30 zones at low revs.
    My Scudo van makes more of a hiss than a whistle.

    stew1982
    Free Member

    it’s probably the dump valve – is it more of a “wish/woosh” sound? and happens when you depress the clutch/change gear?

    unfitgeezer
    Free Member

    its an auto diesel

    stumpy01
    Full Member

    stew1982 – Member
    it’s probably the dump valve – is it more of a “wish/woosh” sound? and happens when you depress the clutch/change gear?

    erm – don’t think that diesels have dump valves…something to do with not having a throttle valve, but can’t remember exactly. Molgrips’ll explain if he’s about….

    edit – oh and it’s normal unless it’s getting louder or you are losing power or noticing loads of blue smoke in the exhaust.
    A boost leak is fairly obvious as you’ll normally be chucking out a lot of soot when accelerating.

    ski
    Free Member

    My VAG whistles too,( 😯 ) but you can only hear it if you have the window open, think its quite normal.

    oldnick
    Full Member

    ski, you need to see a gynaecologist pronto.

    If there is a boost leak the car will drive so slowly for so much right foot you will think it has begun to die. Listen to the engine with the bonnet up whilst a trusted mate (who won’t accidentally run you over)does big blips on the gas, it can be as simple as a hose clip that needs tightening up.

    tonyd
    Full Member

    Old bimmer here, whistles all the time.

    bigyinn
    Free Member

    I’m pretty sure all turbo engines need to have dump valves otherwise the turbo would stop spinning straight away when you took your foot off the gas.

    tonyg2003
    Full Member

    I’ve had a variety of diesels with almost no turbo whistle to quite loud whistling. Never an issue. Plus some older diesels that sounded like a bag of spanners rattling to a now a quite quiet diesel.

    glenh
    Free Member

    I’m pretty sure all turbo engines need to have dump valves otherwise the turbo would stop spinning straight away when you took your foot off the gas.

    No, since a) diesels don’t have throttles, so keep pumping air through without any fuel, and b) most modern turbos have variable vanes so they can keep spinning without pumping much air (and thus don’t need to spin up much again when you put your foot back down, reducing turbo lag).

    donsimon
    Free Member

    Start worrying when it stops whistling.

    steve0pd
    Free Member

    IF it still runs and doesn’t smoke don’t worry about anything.

    If it was a boost leak there would be loads of black smoke out the exhaust.

    Some diesels whistle when you let off the throttle but that is the exhaust resonating due the drop in pressure more so if they got a de-cat fitted.

    unfitgeezer
    Free Member

    Many thanks for all your help

    de-cat fitted no idea ? its a Merc 270 cdi (2002 52 plate) if that helps

    coffeeking
    Free Member

    Dont worry about all the intermediate answers, the first one was correct.

    As a general rule Turbo D’s dont have dump valves and with almost all standard cars you won’t have a dump valve anyway, you MAY have a recirc valve but you won’t normally be able to hear it.

    It’s normal to whistle, if it whines or screeches, or hisses, it’s a potential problem, any other time just ignore it.

    IHN
    Full Member

    On the subject of turbo diesels, if I’ve got my foot on the gas and the engines at, say 3k RPM, the turbo will obviously be working/spinning pretty hard.

    If however the engine’s in an over-run situation, i.e. foot off the gas but at 3krpm whilst engine braking down a hill for instance, is the turbo spinning/working?

    Just wondering. I think not, but I’m not sure.

    hrcmonty
    Free Member

    Turbo Diesels don’t have Dump Valves like Petrol. They have recirculating valves that force the unused air back into the system, they do have a waste gate so if the Turbo is being fed more air than needed it will divert through the waste gate.

    The hissing you can hear is perfectly normal. The type and level of the noise differs from make to make, depending on type of Valve or how much Boost the Manufacturers run the engine at. Vauxalls for EG have a lot of Turbo Lag and are pretty placid on the power, My Golf GT TDI has a right kick on it.

    dave_rudabar
    Free Member

    A recirc valve is just a dump valve that puts the gas back into the engine intake rather than vents to atmosphere. They can still make a bit of a hiss when you lift off, certainly Golfs & Astras i’ve driven in the past did.

    xiphon
    Free Member

    My Turbo (1.9TDi VAG ’96 reg) used to kick in around 3k rpm. Pretty bad mpg below the turbo, but damn good on the motorway!

    geordiemick00
    Free Member

    I had a 53 plate 270 CDi and it did the same, it did have a new turbo fitted at 9K though but they assured me it was normal and it was coming from the air box, with it’s post contract lease owner now it’s up to about 160K and still runs fine and still does nearly 40mpg too.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

The topic ‘Diesel Turbo whistle question’ is closed to new replies.