Forum search & shortcuts

Ukraine

Posts: 6940
Full Member
 

The Gepard twin-cannon system has been in service with the German army since the 1970s and is based on the chassis of the Leopard tank.

German media say there are also plans to deliver about 100 Marder infantry fighting vehicles to Ukraine and some old Leopard battle tanks.

Not dissimilar to my late 80's Tamiya-equipped bookshelf.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:21 pm
Posts: 34545
Full Member
 

Meanwhile recent Moldovan election swinging away from pro-russian parties amplified by what Russia has done in Ukraine has got Putin spooked he might lose his hold over Transnistria
FSB/Putin are mad if they think they can coordinate opening up another front in this war tho.

https://twitter.com/michaelh992/status/1518887491016830976


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:24 pm
Posts: 4593
Free Member
 

Victimhood is a pretty standard populist trick

Yes, it's the standard right wing playbook - equal pay for women is unfair on men, cycle lanes are 'war on the motorist,' refraining from using the N word is an attack on Great British Culture or whatever.

Pretend you're a poor hard-done-by victim, and then take revenge on the people you resent. It's what Hitler did, it's what the Hutus in Rwanda did, it's what Putin's doing, it's what Trump tried to do, and it's what right-wing commentators across the world enable every day. Whilst accusing everyone else of claiming victimhood, obviously.

It's the only way they can justify their violence.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:33 pm
Posts: 12392
Full Member
 

it’s what Trump tried to do did and is still doing

FTFY, but that belongs in the Trump thread.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:42 pm
Posts: 4593
Free Member
 

FTFY, but that belongs in the Trump thread.

funnily enough, I actually said 'did' initially, but I edited the post because I thought some pedant would try to argue the point 😆


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:45 pm
Posts: 62
Free Member
 

With Transnistria, how is Russia supplying their troops there? They obviously can't travel through Ukraine, Moldova and Transnistria are land locked, and the countries to the west of Moldova are in Nato. I have heard there are very large Soviet weapons dumps there, but from what has been shown of old soviet equipment, its not going to be great.

Would Putin's plan be to throw his soldiers in Transnistria to their deaths in the hope of diverting enough Ukrainians away from the Donbas?


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:50 pm
Posts: 5827
Full Member
 

One reason, why Russia is finding it so tough to take the Mariupol steel works.  That and the incredibly tenacious and courageous defenders.  Even if the Russians eventually take this place, the huge resources tied up by it will have been degraded massively and prevented from joining the fight elsewhere.  They will write about the Mariupol defenders in the history books.

https://twitter.com/militaryhistori/status/1518871141363949568?t=az-P_lq8kmmF2X84DtejnA&s=19


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 12:55 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

"They will write about the Mariupol defenders in the history books."

Hopefully for the right reasons. I've read some pretty disturbing stuff about the Azov Regiment.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:05 pm
Posts: 8029
Full Member
 

One reason, why Russia is finding it so tough to take the Mariupol steel works.

Must be really annoying for the Russians that that seems to be about the only bit of military infrastructure they built well.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:11 pm
Posts: 4593
Free Member
 

One reason, why Russia is finding it so tough to take the Mariupol steel works.

Here's what it looks like on the inside. Note how many flights of stairs they have to go down to get to the spot where the civilians and kids are hiding.

https://twitter.com/CanadianUkrain1/status/1517741197611220992


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:15 pm
Posts: 14485
Free Member
 

Hopefully for the right reasons. I’ve read some pretty disturbing stuff about the Azov Regiment.

The first thing to remember when reading anything about the Azov Regiment is that it’s a primary focal point in a hard fought propaganda war.

Short France24 article here https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20220325-azov-regiment-takes-centre-stage-in-ukraine-propaganda-war

Edit, actually AP but published across multiple outlets

"In 2014 this battalion had indeed a far-right background, these were far-right racists that founded the battalion," said Andreas Umland at the Stockholm Centre for Eastern European Studies.

But it had since become "de-ideologised" and a regular fighting unit, he told AFP./quote]

Overall, ultra-nationalist political forces have been on the decline in Ukraine since 2014, said Anna Colin Lebedev at France's Paris Nanterre University.

The same cannot be said for Russia.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:19 pm
Posts: 5827
Full Member
 

Thanks @piemonster, I was looking for something similar to post re Azov. However, I do think their likely treatment by the Russians if captured is another factor is their motivation to carry on.

To put things into perspective about the far right in Ukraine, they got around 2.5% of the vote last time around. In France, the far right just got 45% of the vote.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:30 pm
Posts: 5827
Full Member
 

Deleted, duplicate post.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:37 pm
Posts: 14485
Free Member
 

In France, the far right just got 45% of the vote.

I suspect they find it easier to get multi million pound loans from Russian “banks”


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 1:52 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

“In 2014 this battalion had indeed a far-right background, these were far-right racists that founded the battalion,” said Andreas Umland at the Stockholm Centre for Eastern European Studies.

But it had since become “de-ideologised” and a regular fighting unit, he told AFP./quote]"

Firstly I want to make it clear that I want Ukraine to win this war and I'm no Putin apologist, but I think it's very dangerous to just assume the above quote is entirely correct and blindly work on the premise that our enemy's enemy is our friend. Because that's always worked out really well in the past hasn't it? People who are holocaust deniers don't tend to just alter their views at the drop of a hat.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 4:05 pm
Posts: 35142
Full Member
 

I've read so many conflicting reports about the Azov I really don't know what to believe any more. There was a report in the Washington Post that essentially said "It was founded to be explicitly Neo-Nazi, but now while lots of folks are aware of it's history, it's not really Neo- Nazi any more. (turnover in the organisation, lack of recruitment, deaths etc)

The BBC a couple of years back were reporting that there are Jewish members (one of the founding members I think) and there's other stuff  I've read that has tried to say the while they identify as Far right, in the context of Ukraine that's not necessarily always anti Semitic.

Who knows? I think it's probably safer to assume that it's a far right movement than not. I'm certainly treating anything that says otherwise with suspicion/caution


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 4:23 pm
Posts: 14485
Free Member
 

but I think it’s very dangerous to just assume the above quote is entirely correct and blindly work on the premise that our enemy’s enemy is our friend.

Agree with that, but like Nick says, and as I’d hoped to imply.

Both sides are fighting a propaganda war so you shouldn’t just blindly work on anyones premise as being true.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 4:29 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I'm certainly not doing that piemonster. As I stated in a post earlier in this thread, propoganda is a tool of war used by both sides, always has been, always will be.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 4:40 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

It looks like events in Transnistria are worth watching over the next few days. Some speculation the Russians are trying to open a second front there. They don’t seem to be making a lot of progress in East Ukraine so it is hard to see how that would benefit them, but it is hard to know what is really happening on the ground so who knows…


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 4:53 pm
Posts: 12392
Full Member
 

It looks like events in Transnistria are worth watching over the next few days. Some speculation the Russians are trying to open a second front there.

They got thrashed in Kyiv. They are struggling in Donbas, quite likely about to see their army broken. Any talk of opening a new front is just propaganda aimed at building support within Russia, probably a hail-Mary for recruiting cannon fodder. Russia does not have any military resources capable of launching a new front.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:01 pm
Posts: 33269
Full Member
 

Russia does not have any military resources capable of launching a new front.

Do they have enough troops based there to force the Ukranians to pull troops back from the Donbas to deal with them? Just a thought.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:17 pm
Posts: 4333
Full Member
 

Russia's stuck advancing 5 battle groups in the east and south, adding a 6th in the west with even worse supply lines is madness.

So they'll do it.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:20 pm
Posts: 33269
Full Member
 

So they’ll do it.

Here's hoping


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:35 pm
Posts: 31154
Full Member
 

As I said a month ago, taking all the south coast was always a likely aim for Russia. Ukraine still existing, but cut off from the coast while Russia simultaneously complains about them trading more and more with the EU and makes them landbound by forming a "New Russia" to the South, is a likely next stage after this latest advance by Russia cools down for a while. When that temporary "end" to military operations does come... it's not just Ukraine that'll be holding its breath to see when and where the next advance comes. Moldova, Romania, Slovakia, Poland, Lithuania, Latvia... they won't feel safe.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:37 pm
Posts: 2320
Free Member
 

I think i read there are 1500 russian troops posted to transnistria

Reading around I get the impression Tranistrians are/were pretty happy with their lot


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:38 pm
Posts: 46139
Full Member
 

It looks like events in Transnistria are worth watching over the next few days. Some speculation the Russians are trying to open a second front there

Don't underestimate the need for a victory at the May 9th parade.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:41 pm
Posts: 31154
Full Member
 

Reading around I get the impression Tranistrians are/were pretty happy with their lot

You've read that they "pretty happy" to get drawn into the Ukraine war? Or just "pretty happy" with Russian, er, support for independence from Moldova?


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:44 pm
Posts: 28593
Free Member
 

And Moldova, I suspect are/were pretty happy to let them get on with it.

I very much doubt that the troops in Transnistria are capable of more than offering a brief distraction and maybe make Ukraine have to send some reserves in that direction. So it remains to be seen whether this is a false flag to give the pretext for this, or Ukraine acting pre-emptively to make such a move less likely.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:46 pm
Posts: 31154
Full Member
 

If they really want to take and keep Odesa, rather than just flatten it, then troops and supplies from Transnistria come into play.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:50 pm
Posts: 46139
Full Member
 

Reading around I get the impression Tranistrians are/were pretty happy with their lot

Worth watching bald's YouTube video:


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:50 pm
Posts: 28593
Free Member
 

If they really want to take and keep Odesa

Whether this remains a realistic aim is another matter. They won't be able to take it without flattening pretty much the most historically significant city in Eastern Europe.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:54 pm
Posts: 105
Free Member
 

If Russia took control of the South of Ukraine and cut off access to the black sea, the remaining country would be crippled economically.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:55 pm
Posts: 31154
Full Member
 

Worth watching bald’s YouTube video:

That's as intense as a rural North Wales pub. Great video.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:57 pm
Posts: 31154
Full Member
 

the remaining country would be crippled economically

Is that not the aim? To deny a neighbour economic success?


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 5:59 pm
Posts: 46139
Full Member
 

That’s as intense as a rural North Wales pub.

That takes me back to a day in Llwyngwril pub. Wales were playing England. I and the soon to be mrs_oab were the only English in the pub. 😨


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 6:17 pm
Posts: 46139
Full Member
 

If Russia took control of the South of Ukraine and cut off access to the black sea, the remaining country would be crippled economically.

For the Ukranian's losing any land now means living with the ogres that caused all this. And the threat of more war on the whim of that ogre.
It is literally life and death.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 6:19 pm
Posts: 31154
Full Member
 

And the threat of more war on the whim of that ogre.

There is now no way to avoid that now though, is there? Short of other countries getting involved to protect Ukraine, nothing will keep them safe from future Russian attacks.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 6:23 pm
Posts: 14485
Free Member
 

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-26/russia-halted-gas-supplies-to-poland-onet-pl-reports-l2gapmmd

I think they've got this from a Polish news source here https://www.onet.pl/

The comments section is probably colourful

Hours after a Polish news outlet reported that Russia had cut off the gas to Poland, Gazprom PJSC said payment was due today. It didn’t say what would happen if payment wasn’t made but President Vladimir Putin has previously warned that supplies would be halted if his terms weren’t met.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 6:59 pm
Posts: 18043
Full Member
Posts: 14485
Free Member
 

Transnistria is a distraction, I think

By which I mean wildly guess

Pretty sure it's already been called a distraction by a senior Ukrainian Army member.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 7:04 pm
Posts: 13643
Free Member
Topic starter
 

So Germany is sending 'tanks' (see journalist definition of tanks above) to Ukraine. Does anyone else feel like there is going to be a slow escalation until we are actively engaging with Russian troops?


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 7:04 pm
Posts: 2938
Free Member
 

Nope


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 7:14 pm
Posts: 2459
Free Member
 

"Don’t underestimate the need for a victory at the May 9th parade."

Given that Putin has told us this would be the case there could be a chance that the new iron curtain will be drawn pretty much where respective forces are positioned on May 8th.

I imagine that the positions won't change much from where they are now, given the Russians performance thus far, potentially a bit more territory in the East gained but the Russians don't seem to be making enormous progress there thus far.

Always thought that most of the Ukranian capability would be kept in the South West in order to preserve Black Sea access at all costs.


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 7:50 pm
Posts: 6924
Full Member
 

The current Russian positions are going to leave them very exposed with a long and porous "border" which will be difficult to defend and much of the land behind the border accessible to short range weapons of which the West will continue to pour into Ukraine..


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 7:55 pm
Posts: 18043
Full Member
 

Given that Putin has told us this would be the case there could be a chance that the new iron curtain will be drawn pretty much where respective forces are positioned on May 8th.

Well he can draw it across Ukraine if he likes but don't expect Ukraine to say "OK".


 
Posted : 26/04/2022 8:38 pm
Page 189 / 496