[Closed] Long and thin or Short and Fat? - Roofboxes

Mrs Eye said she'd like a roofbox as a Focus estate isn't enough to cart around a Baby (plus his 'equipment'), a dog and her bits, her stuff and my stuff which includes a bike, bike stuff and general day to day stuff.

That's quite a bit of stuff really. I've got roof bars with 2 carriers on at the moment but will take one off.

OR I could stick the bike in the boot and get a bigger box on top, I'm thinking this may be more fuel efficient.

Anyway, what boxes/brands do you recommend?

Thanks as always.