[Closed] Biggest band who have never reformed/regrouped etc?

Abba?

creme brulee
[img] [/img]

The Smiths, but it'll never happen

much like the Stone Roses

creme brulee

That's cos it's a sh1t business innit... 😉

Nah Muggo, it's a shit business.

Of course Flash, it's got to be Adler drumming not Matt Sorum

*Hijacks own thread a little*
Ay up, Kato! You well?

The Beatles.

The Beatles.

As above...

This of course rules out anyone with a dead band member,

Hawkwind, don't think any of them have yet succumbed to the reaper

Oasis although abba are by far the biggest of those named so far.

Ay up, Kato! You well?

aye I'm dandy fella. You good?

Abba are indeed the biggest name there, much though it pains me to say it!

Not too shabby, Kato, thanks. Change of work is ongoing, but am having a little fun in between! Get to the other side when you get a moment, if you can!

Hawkwind, don't think any of them have yet succumbed to the reaper

Most of them are dead. They just don't realise it yet. 8)

T-rex

This of course rules out anyone with a dead band member, or a band that's still touring.

there has been a scientific survey carried out into how to get the Beatles to regroup

Answer another two bullets

ok I will get my coat

T-rex

Think their singer passed a good while back now

Most of them are dead. They just don't realise it yet

But not actually six foot under, even Stasia is still about somewhere

the beatles
manic street preachers
the charlatans
buddy holly and the crickets
beach boys

any band with someone dead really...

edit, no i didn't read the op either, but wheres the fun in that

jam

smiths

stone roses

specials (with Jerry Dammers)

quite happy that none of them have reformed as it'd probably be shit, if most of the other reformed bands are anything to go by.

Stasia's living on a farm somewhere, very happily too I believe.

T-rex

Think their singer passed a good while back now

Yes but the good news is Marc Bolans mini is back on the road 😉

Electric Light Orchestra
Orchestral Manoeuvers In The Dark

The fun is thinking of bands that were really big where there's an actual chance of them reforming. Still, there are plenty of bands that record and tour after personel changes, like Faith No More did. And there's nothing wrong with the Pixies at the moment, or Gang Of Four, for that matter. Glad FTM and Soundgarden are both back together.

Stone Roses

NWA

steps

+1 for steps
S club 7

Muggomagic- weller's been recording and playing with Bruce!

CountZero - Member
The fun is thinking of bands that [b]were really big[/b] where there's an actual chance of them reforming. Still, there are plenty of bands that record and tour after personel changes, like Faith No More did. And there's nothing wrong with the Pixies at the moment, or Gang Of Four, for that matter. Glad FTM and Soundgarden are both back together.

And which of those you mention were "really big"?

The Smiths

(I'd love to see Talking Heads together)

ooh....was going to add Pink Floyd (waters/gilmore/mason/wright line-up) and then had a nagging feeling (confirmed) that Richard Wright died (n 2008)....and they already did get back together for live-aid.

Smiths

Stone Roses

Dead Kennedys 😀

Husker Du

Neds Atomic Dustbin 😉

I was gonna say Bad Brains, but then checked their website and they are back in their original lineup. Awesome.
[img] [/img]
and Jawbreaker, I can't see them ever getting back together, but if they did it would be HUGE.

Charlatans very much together AFAIK, i saw them live about 18 months ago.

Thing is most of these have been money making schemes. I'd love a NEW stones roses album but a tour of old stuff... No thanks. Smiths? Now don't get me wrong. No one is more miserable than me but Ive heard how soon is now enough thanks...

Black Flag and the original Misfits with Glen Danzig!

Oh, huge you said? 😆

Slade with Noddy Holder .Nuthin' without !

Well ignoring the fact that one of their strictly original members has died, and they have toured, in some form, since they broke up... Pink Floyd could be there.

Oldfart,did Slade not just break up about 5 years ago when Noddy got enough radio work to hang up his sideburns?

duckman yeah now touring without him !

anyone actually mentioning ABBA as a F************** BAND should be SHOT... unceremoniously...

they were a POP Group... and therefore SE

I don't think Mark Radcliffe ever rejoined Skrewdriver.

Up to a few years ago I would have said without any doubt The Clash but Joe isnt with us anymore.. 😥

talking heads , end of story

Talking of Talking Heads, anyone read Byrne's book The Bicycle Diaries?

Bands that have never reformed: original line up of The Supremes. Think they're all still with us...

The Jam is a good call. I mean "From the Jam"? What a joke!

Stranglers?

Dave, Dee, Dozey, Mick & Titch?

Reformed bands are always shit anyway [size=1]except Gang of Four[/size]

i have read the bicycle diaries but was dissapointed by it , got quite bored quite quickly .he's written other books like the new temptations and to be honest he's the wrong side of quirky and heading into obsession for my tastes.

The Jam would be brilliant right up until the point at which you saw them all gathered on stage - it just couldn't be the same, Weller's too big & moved on too far & the other 2 would know it.

Charlatans very much together AFAIK, i saw them live about 18 months ago.

pretty sure that it wasn't the original line-up, didn't their guitarist die in a car crash?

Squeeze.

Five Star

bros

millie vanilli

Queen -well without Freddy Mecury.

john_l - Member

The Jam would be brilliant right up until the point at which you saw them all gathered on stage - it just couldn't be the same, Weller's too big & moved on too far & the other 2 would know it.

... and they'd probably want to employ another bunch of thuggish morons as their road crew to piss everybody off who had anything to do with them...

Warning: Shameless self-promotion content follows

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sound

You were in The Sound, Mr Woppit? You must be Mike Dudley then. Not much chance of them reforming thats for certain.

DezB - Member

You were in The Sound, Mr Woppit? You must be Mike Dudley then. Not much chance of them reforming thats for certain.

Well, we could dig Ade and Max up and have them on stage, but it wouldn't be the same... 😯

I think the only reformed band I'd go to see is BowWowWow.
Just cos I used to fancy Annabella and Leigh Gorman is one of the best bass players ever. 🙂

Well, at least she's legal now...

I don't mind 😉

Peter Green rejoining Fleetwood Mac?

The Jam, The Stone Roses, original Guns and Roses, The Smiths. I doubt any of those will happen though. I went to see the reformed magazine recently and even though John McGeoch is dead they were one of the best bands I've ever seen.

Husker Du and fIREHOSE would be good to see.

Mr Woppit - had a very quick scan of that link, it must have been an amazing time. Lots to read later. Tell me - has life ever been the same since? Do you miss it? Do you still have drums?

Saw a few of my old stomping grounds mentioned - The Greyhound in Fulham Palace Road from my hippie days. 8) Was a very regular visitor there. 🙄 The Marquee too.

Dunno answer to the original question though, people keep dying.

Neds Atomic Dustbin

I'm pretty sure that Neds get together every Christmas for a gig or two round here.

CRASS

soulrider - Member

anyone actually mentioning ABBA as a F************** BAND should be SHOT... unceremoniously...

they were a POP Group... and therefore SE

Nowt wrong with unpretentious pop. Try to define whats pop and whats rock is hard anyway.

Top POP bands
Slade Bananarama Human league, Smiths, Blondie for starters

New Fast Automatic Daffodils

Deep Purple with Gillan (so the 2nd line up)

KLF

Deep Purple with Gillan (so the 2nd line up)

Pity we can't get Cozy back and reform Rainbow to the Rising period

And one more to get back together,Wishbone Ash

DP has got to have Gillan!

Another vote for Wishbone Ash, saw them many a time and still play their albums. 8)

I see that Wishbone Ash are down to play the High Voltage gig at Victoria Park in East London around July time
Apparently going to play the "Argus" set, so could be good, they are now known as Martin Turner's Wishbone Ash

Looking like a goodie especially if Mr Dio is well enough for Heaven and Hell to play along with UFO, ELP, ZZ Top, Gary Moore and a fair few others from my younger days too
Suppose Iron Maiden would have been the logical choice being the home band as it were, but they are busy at Knebworth

Used to live very near Vicky Park and can't wait for this one 😀

OK folks, I think we're going off the rails here. The question was about the "biggest", not the one you like!

As such, I think we have to agree that the top three (Based on potential/actual album sales and potential/actual touring revenue of a reformation) are Abba, GNR and Dire Straits.

Ah yes, Talking Heads. There's a band I'd love to see again. Saw them touring the '77 album, their first. Supported by Dire Straits, as it happens. Tina Weymouth's mad as a box of frogs, but a great bass player, and brilliant rhythm section. Love them.

T-rex

Think their singer passed a good while back now

For more info on Marc Bolan see Mackem's headset thread. Also pics of Jimmy Page and TJ making a fool of himself 😆 (although I may have started that by not recognising Jimmy Page either...)

Sleeper!

Ah, Louise.... Sigh!

Minor Threat? Didn't get to see them first time around.
Or one of my fav's the Minutemen

Jailcell recipes .
nearly reformed back end of last year , but it didnt quite happen .
Yea , they were huge in Wigan .
And Japan .

Sssshhhh now, but I really really wish Dire Straits would reform for one last tour...

They're all still around and it might make Knopfler stop writing MOTR country...

[i]Abba, GNR and Dire Straits.[/i]

Surely The Jam sold more records than Dire Straits? Surely? Please tell me for the sake of all that is good and decent in the world of music that Dire Shitting Straits are not more popular than The Jam?

Sleeper!
Ah, Louise.... Sigh

I recall going to see them in Newcastle (quite) a few years ago...Louise was on stage in a vest top and was quite literally STEAMING 😀

New Fast Automatic Daffodils

Anyway, I'd like to see the Monkees reform.