Forum menu
Skills compensator....
 

[Closed] Skills compensator.... What to think of and buy.... 160-170mm, trail bike

Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

In fact I’d be tempted, before splashing loads of cash if you only have space for one bike, would be to increase fork travel by 10mm, and also fit a -1deg slackset too. Should get you around or just under 66deg head angle whilst retaining BB height and Seat angle, and improve the attitude of the bike somewhat. This is pretty much what they did for the 2019 T-130 range anyway, they all have slacker HA and 140mm fork fitted now anyway.

Not sure how viable it is on the forks i have ?


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:49 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Why is skill improving frowned upon

Not saying it is, not saying that at all. But me spending a day at BPW riding as many trails as possible and pushing myself is very different than going there and doing 1 section of 1 trail for hours. Along with the fact that i'm going to these places with my lad and that's not on his agenda either.

We're starting at the Swinley skills area in Jan every other Saturday, which will actually give us that completely focused type of riding you describe... But hoping it's fun for both of us at the same time too


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:51 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

’m sure given your Zwifting obsession, you can appreciate the irony in that statement

Zwift racing is a completely different thing to MTBing for me, it's a totally different mindset and activity, the only thing that they have in common is a set of pedals. But that said, each and every Zwift race is different, tactically, mentally, physically, all different but based upon a theme of course.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:54 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

@weeksy it s a light hearted quip as it seems you are constantly on the look ut for the next thing 🙂 #emporersnewclothes and all that


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:56 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

it s a light hearted quip as it seems you are constantly on the look ut for the next thing 🙂 #emporersnewclothes and all that

You rekon ? I'm not getting that at all... well, in my perception anyway.

I wasn't taking offence though, i just don't see it in myself at all.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:58 pm
Posts: 3317
Free Member
 

You seem certain you don't want to change forks yet seem to be happy to swap out or buy an entirely new bike just for 5% of your riding?


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:59 pm
Posts: 2579
Full Member
 

That’s then all sounding a bit like training and homework rather than fun and riding… I struggle with that as a concept… Sure, i get the idea of it… but doing say 200m then going back up, doing it again, and repeat, i’m not feeling the love as a riding day.

Its all bike riding, we've got some trails locally which are around a minute long, all loamy. Spent yesterday sessioning the same tracks over and over, slapping turns, a bit of falling off, great fun and you build up skill/confidence. Back there next weekend and over Christmas.

Bike riding isn't all about distance or height gained.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 1:59 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

You seem certain you don’t want to change forks yet seem to be happy to swap out or buy an entirely new bike just for 5% of your riding?

My fork issues are that 1, i'm not convinced 10mm will make enough of a difference and 2, i only bought them 3-4 months ago so would be upset to swap them this early on...
3, it would cost me loads as i'd end up putting them on my lads bike and then need a new boost wheel for him too 😀


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:01 pm
Posts: 2579
Full Member
 

Dont need a new wheel, spacer kit off ebay, or proper adapters if they do them.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:07 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I had A similar thing earlier this year. My prefered riding is steep off piste techy stuff so I was tempted to go for a bigger bike. The more I thought about it though I came to the conclusion that I didn't want to be the older guy in his mid forties trying to pretend to be "sending it" but actually the being far from that in reality.

In the end I went for a slack / long 130mm trail bike with 150mm forks as a compromise, and accepting that in reality the bike is never going to be the thing to hold me back, but would suit most of my riding better.

Ymmv may vary of course and you may indeed get the most out of a bigger bike but that was the conclusion I came to fir me. Worked out for me as I've done every trail / feature / drop on my new bike that I did on my old dh bike without any problems and I'm loving it.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:26 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

So reading behind the initial post and the follow up replies, basically what you asking is what enduro bike with screw fit bb do people recommend under £2k??? Because it sounds like you have made your mind up already


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:28 pm
 Yak
Posts: 6941
Full Member
 

The more I thought about it though I came to the conclusion that I didn’t want to be the older guy in his mid forties trying to pretend to be “sending it” but actually the being far from that in reality.

Dammit - shot most of us down there... 😉

weeksy - come over to Rogate sometime on the new mega-sled when you get whatever this ends up being and we'll catch up. Or I will try and make one of your BPW days at some point.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:35 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

So reading behind the initial post and the follow up replies, basically what you asking is what enduro bike with screw fit bb do people recommend under £2k??? Because it sounds like you have made your mind up already

Well, if i had made up my mind already then yes, that would be the question.

However, i've not... 🙂 I'm still sitting here contemplating.

As said earlier, until we go to BPW in 2 weeks time and then also Swinley Skills area the weekends after that, i won't know the answer to my own question. When i see if my lads reality is different to his perception and my riding is fine and we stay together, then this doesn't even need to come up in disucssion. But just weighing things up. The answer may be that for this year i'm happy on the T-130 and maybe next year after he's had more training and experience then I buy something bigger, but by the same count, i may come to terms with the fact that he's outgrown me and i have to accept my place in the world.
It may be that i'm still brilliant and i can beat the little bugger anyway 😉

Granted, my T-130 is better than i'll ever be, granted if you stick an Atherton on it, it would do things i can't dream of... but i'm just me, I'm not them.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:37 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

can't your son teach you some skills. Once you have those following a better rider down a trail can help too.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:39 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

come over to Rogate sometime on the new mega-sled when you get whatever this ends up being and we’ll catch up

I have no idea where Rogate is mate, but if you can get to it, so can I.... If you're heading there over the Xmas weeks, then shout on here or Email and me and my lad will come 🙂 We've both got 2 weeks off to play.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:39 pm
 Yak
Posts: 6941
Full Member
 

It's a push up bike park near QECP. But it's on greensand not chalk-clay so is ok after rain.
Yeah - will do!


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:42 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

can’t your son teach you some skills. Once you have those following a better rider down a trail can help too.

LOL he can barely tie his own shoelaces.... but he's a decent rider "Just get on with it Daddy" isn't quite cutting it as teaching 😉

I know this is coming over like i'm some sort of incompetent who can't get down a trail, but that's not quite the reality, i'm not a bad rider as such, but as a 'jumper' he's a skilled little lad.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:42 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I’m not really sure what the Question is then Weeksy.  As you have had some great responses.

Hob Nob is right in what he says session if a trail that isn’t just riding a purpose bike trail centre is the beat way to learn, it’s training and is needed to improve skills in different formats at every sport. Riding somewhere you ride all the time is great but you are only going to improve riding that trail. Dropping BPW even a few times a year is unlikely to really sharpen your skills, just highlight your shortcomings.

It has been suggested that you upgrade your fork travel to modernise your bike to somewhere near current trail bikes by a former whyte dealer (10mm extra fork travel and an Angleset to slacken) but it seems you don’t want to do that.

so like I say it seems like you want to be convinced which bike to buy, which in itself is absolutely fine...I enjoy those threads as much as anyone.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:46 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

I’m not really sure what the Question is then Weeksy. As you have had some great responses.

I've not said i've not had great responsese, i've not said there's not plenty of food for thought in here... I'm perfectly happy with the responses, what makes you think i'm not ?


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 2:48 pm
Posts: 3335
Full Member
 

You won't need more than the 130 at Swinley Skills area. There's nothing which has not been built for a smooth landing and 20mm extra travel won't make a difference.

I'm looking at new bikes at the moment, on a 150R/160F Bronson V2 and looking for a do-it-all for anything from trail to a week in the Alps. The most 'trail' friendly big bike I've ridden so far is the new Rallon which is currently out of your price range (at least for a new MY20 with the updated rear linkage). That's a 160R 170F 29er which is pretty light with decent geo. I have also ridden a transition smuggler - 120R / 140F (or thereabouts), this felt really nice and capable (as other have said I feel the geo really helped here), though I feel I'd want a bit more. The Rallon was quicker though (although it felt slower at times it wasn't). May also try a Sentinal, but concerned it may be a bit porky for everyday riding.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 3:27 pm
Posts: 3605
Free Member
 

Rogate is a good call.. some good scope for progression in manageable sized chunks - just sessioning Bottlerocket alone will help with improving key skills.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 3:35 pm
Posts: 3382
Full Member
 

i’m not a bad rider as such, but as a ‘jumper’ he’s a skilled little lad.

Longer travel bikes are harder to jump IMO, unless the jumps and massive.
Are you consistently using all the travel on your current bike? Are you bottoming it out on harsh drops, or hitting rocky sections fast?
A longer travel bike won't help you land a drop or jump smoothly, and it's not going to help if you mess up a drop by landing heavy.

What it *might* do is give you the feeling of confidence, which in turn will make you more confident and commit more, thus actually managing to ride better. 95% of that will be in your head though. Which is why new bike syndrome exists.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 3:36 pm
Posts: 14172
Full Member
 

Can’t you just change the air shaft in the fork when it’s being serviced to take it to 140mm?

And if the Whyte has a sensible head tube design, swap the headset for a Works one, I’d go for -1.5 deg.

Total cost about £100 if you do all the work yourself, and not that much more for your LBS to do if you needed a fork service anyway.

That’ll give you a head angle of just over 65 deg and about 20mm more front centre, whilst everything else will stay the same. My old Spitfire which had similar geometry and only 10mm more travel at the back was awesome at BPW etc.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 4:37 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Can’t you just change the air shaft in the fork when it’s being serviced to take it to 140mm?

At this stage I have no idea. They're only 3-4 months old.

Works headset I'll look into tonight.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 5:20 pm
Posts: 1670
Full Member
 

I ran my T130 with Fox 34’s at 140mm then changed them to 150mm, it’s a 20 minute and £35 air spring job.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 5:38 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Thanks Jimmy.

I'll go in search

https://www.tftuned.com/air-shaft-assembly-34mm-float-lc-na-2-1214/p3465


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 5:49 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

i’m already wondering if i’d be better buying him something bigger instead of myself

Wouldn't want to do that... scares me silly following Ollie when I'm on a bigger travel bike.

My current bike is great – it’s an Aeris 145LT with 170mm lyriks / codes etc and on uplift days it’s amazing. Capable of far more than I can do and when you’re on it it’s fantastic. I’ve done all day rides on it like the big loop at Brechfa / Brecon Gap plus pedalled it up Snowdon etc as well as uplift days. I’ve been riding it coming up 3 years in a couple of months time. No plans to change it at the moment.

I do hanker for something inbetween the Aeris and my hardtail though – but don’t have the justification to add a middle bike! I wonder if one of the 130/140 29ers might be that bike – would it do the big stuff nearly as well as what I’ve got but be more lively in more vanilla / mundane trails?

Obvious answer is get the shorter travel linkage for £100 and new airshaft for the lyrics ?? (Umm.... unless N+1 is REALLY strong)


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 6:02 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Top video Steve, your lad has clearly come on massively! Nice one


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 6:09 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Top video Steve, your lad has clearly come on massively! Nice one

It's age mate, we're doomed! They just pick everything up faster, bounce better ...
Yeah he's riding insane (to me) stuff.... and the Stuff in Dyfi/Antur and Rev's is a step up from that.

I quite honestly made a conscious choice Saturday to take a bigger travel bike than he's riding (my Bird is identical except he's on XS and I'm on a M so I took the mega with 170/160) which was nice since I cased that drop/jump on one of the runs.. and when I follow him now I just rely on the extra travel as a skills adjuster but he still drops me like a bad smell.. but it does help a lot if he can smash through knowing I got another 10mm both ends... (though its seen me OTB a few times its saved me lots more)

Ideally though I'd get one of the newer Bird's with the change-able linkage... but currently both bikes take same shocks and wheels so I've effectively got a 160/140, 160/150 (on the Bird) and 170/160 (On the Mega)


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 6:39 pm
Posts: 0
Full Member
 

in my experience as a totally average rider, what you need is LENGTH and lots of it!

I moved from a large zesty, which isn't really a particularly small bike, to an XL mondraker dune, and it's amazing, simply because the "Middle of the bike" is such a wide zone now. Previously, i felt that i had to have my weight in just the right place, especially on drops, now, there is just more leeway for error, which is amazing, because error is how i ride!

Taking that massive bike to the Alps was actually eye opening, as i got round tight Les Arcs hairpins of certain death that i'd never got round on the much shorter zesty, simply because of stability and the confidence that gave me!

So whilst travel is useful, to try to swallow your mistakes, length is ime, actually far more important!

(and yes, it takes more effort to manual and bunny hop, but because of the stability and wider "centre" window, i can actually flat land manual this bike, which i could never quite manage previously! The only iussue is now when i get back on my HT, every time i manual or wheely i pretty much end up sat on my ass on the floor behind having forgoten i'm riding a much shorter bike........)


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 8:35 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Would a Calibre Sentry fit the bill? Currently £1699 at Go Outdoors. Even the Pro model with coil shock I think is about £2100.

So a new N+1...


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 9:09 pm
Posts: 10283
Full Member
 

My current bike is great – it’s an Aeris 145LT with 170mm lyriks / codes etc and on uplift days it’s amazing. Capable of far more than I can do and when you’re on it it’s fantastic. I’ve done all day rides on it like the big loop at Brechfa / Brecon Gap plus pedalled it up Snowdon etc as well as uplift days. I’ve been riding it coming up 3 years in a couple of months time. No plans to change it at the moment.

I do hanker for something inbetween the Aeris and my hardtail though – but don’t have the justification to add a middle bike! I wonder if one of the 130/140 29ers might be that bike – would it do the big stuff nearly as well as what I’ve got but be more lively in more vanilla / mundane trails?

Obvious answer is get the shorter travel linkage for £100 and new airshaft for the lyrics ?? (Umm…. unless N+1 is REALLY strong)

I had the shorter linkage and 160mm fork and the bike rides better with the longer linkage on it (more poppy) and higher front end.


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 10:22 pm
Posts: 10283
Full Member
 

Member
Would a Calibre Sentry fit the bill? Currently £1699 at Go Outdoors. Even the Pro model with coil shock I think is about £2100.

So a new N+1…

This is probably a good shout


 
Posted : 16/12/2019 10:28 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Having spannered on a Bossnut, that goes down as a terrible idea... If it's built with the same crap componentry, bearings, parts and setup... I'd rather walk.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 7:10 am
Posts: 5164
Free Member
 

I went from a T130 to a patrol and it was a huge change in ride feel and skills required, not helped with a huge crash first time out.

I do sometimes think about going back to 130, but the patrol is fun when finally set up, the loss of speed on trail centres and so on doesn’t bother me either, I’m not a racer, but as others say, slow speeds on this one takes adjusting too, not helped by me using a short travel hardtail most of the time!

If I was to look at getting something now, a giant reign would be one of the first I’d check, looks good and by all accounts just as good as any of the enduros out there.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 8:30 am
Posts: 46090
Free Member
 

Eldest_oab went from 130/150 Radon Slide to 170/170 Radon Swoop.
(That has threaded BB and is £1950 in sale new... Just don't expect much warranty backup).

It's an absolute monster truck. It took a few months for him to really work the thing out. Between the move to 29er and longer travel, he really noticed a lack of playfulness. I still would say that for half his riding it just flattens everything. You can just point and ignore surprisingly big lumps/bumps/roots/rocks and just go...

When he finally gets it on terrain that challenges, or speed that challenges, then it's an impressive tool. Again it just allows line choices and speed that my brain struggles to comprehend. When it gets rough, he just accelerates away, still pedalling and aiming for some huge Huck... I could not make use of the travel fully, I'm too scaredy and lacking in skills. And I'm not that slow a rider down hill.

Watching him race at the enduro's is interesting, as is seeing how at that speed he can wear out tyres quickly, and without both DH tyre, insert and 170mm of travel he can destroy a rear wheel. Not through poor line, just it's a race tool.

If you have the skills and bottle, as big bike is amazing fun, but only where ultimate speed is your goal.

If you don't have the skills and bottle, then I would get them over a big bike.

A T130 is a thing of fun - and fun is my goal.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:09 am
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Yeah i'm leaning towards keeping the T-130 as my day to day bike and accepting if and when the time comes for him to give me a kicking, then i'm afraid that's how it's going to be.
In some ways it would be nice to go for a 1-2deg headset difference, but if it doesn't feel 'nice' on the local stuff i'd be likely swapping it back. (However i have emailed them to see which one i needed).
Having ridden it everywhere and having sat and thought about things, could i actually attack things on a G-160 that i can't on a T-130... The answer is probably no... As someone famous once said "it's not the bike"

It's all fair anyway as he's only on a 130mm bike too at the moment so any riding is fair game 🙂

Although i almost talked myself into buying him this

[img] [/img]

But that would be crazy talk unless we could keep his trail bike as well and that's really not viable.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:19 am
Posts: 8527
Free Member
 

Na, get a big bike. 😊

I've had allsorts, and my Bronson with 160 up front pedals as well or better than any other bike I've had, including my 130 29er spectral. I planned on keeping that as my day to day bike until I got the Bronson - no need.

It wasn't cheap mind, and mibbe that's the difference in RnD etc coming through, it's not hard work to pedal on flat stuff at all, accelerates brilliantly on climbs, even with the 2.6 soft Mary up front.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:32 am
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Well watching some reviews on the G-160 and G-170 this morning put me off a bit with the low BB height, it's got to pedal and has to pedal in ruts due to where i live.

The S-150 really looks like it would be the logical purchase if i were to go 'bigger'. But today, i'm leaning towards not.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:36 am
Posts: 1670
Full Member
 

IMO if you want to go faster/harder over rough technical stuff, the best modification you could make to your T130 is put a 35/40mm stem on it and use the dropper.

Fancy a ride around QE off piste over the Xmas break, you can try out my Geometron.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:42 am
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

I do use the dropper, when i'm at places that need it. Even Swinley i use the dropper, but locally i certainly don't use it. But FoD, Afa, BPW etc it gets fitted and used.

Stem is 50mm i think from looking at the spec sheets. Along with a 67deg head angle.

QE though sounds ace mate yes.... shout me either here or over on PB when you're free, after Boxing day we're about all the time with nothing to do 🙂


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:49 am
Posts: 1670
Full Member
 

Will do.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 9:55 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I have an orange 4 and when I recently slackened the head angle by 2 degrees, it transformed the bike. It still climbs well as its short travel and light weight, but down hill it flies now.
I've had to fit rimpact and add a bit more pressure to the shocks as it was getting a bit lairy and I destroyed the back wheel. But if I pick my lines and pop over the nasty bits, rather than through them, it's all the bike I'll ever need.


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 10:40 am
Posts: 46090
Free Member
 

accepting if and when the time comes for him to give me a kicking, then i’m afraid that’s how it’s going to be

Same here.

However, I'm not sure a big bike will take me from:
Dad riding
null

To

Son riding - and that's on his old bike a year plus back. New bike = Nico Vink jump line at Chatel this summer.

null


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 12:12 pm
Posts: 28712
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Oh god, i better not show my lad this video or we'll be going from Morzine to Chatel !!!!

I don' consider riding like that no matter what bike i own 🙂


 
Posted : 17/12/2019 12:24 pm
Page 2 / 3