I have the old style mechanical plummet post. Had it just over a year now I think. In terms of maintenance I’ve not had to do anything. The post hasn’t been stripped, I haven’t adjusted the tension and haven’t done any maintenance on the remote cable either.
It still works exactly the same as it did when new. I don’t have another dropper to compare it to as it’s the only one I’ve had. My mates ks lev has had to be rebuilt in the same time and it’s more temperamental.
Obv the mechanical one isn’t infinitely adjustable – it’s either up, down or halfway up. I mostly use it halfway down – it only gets fully down on a steep dh or if loaf’s of dropoffs. Like at flyup 417 on the red run or boneville at BPW.
There is some slop on the saddle from new – but this isn’t something you notice when riding and hasn’t got worse that I’ve noticed.
Main upside vs a lot of other cheap posts (externally routed ones) is that the cable goes into the front of the postnear where it goes into the frame. So it stays mud free.
Main downside is how ugly the rubber boot is – but it’s essential to leave this on.