I PERSONALLY have found Ilkley really unfriendly and so has my partner who is doing the whole mum group thing.
Probably best to whisper that. I implied it on another forum and got jumped on…safe to say that the two towns are pretty different in character IMO. Still like some aspects of Ilkley though.
I’ve lived in Skipton for five years or so now. Really like the place – not too big but all the services you need, traffic not too bad, decent access to most places either by train or road.
The only thing I think it lacks are a couple of decent family friendly pubs in town.
School choice – there are a number of decent primaries. Ofsted reports aren’t terribly helpful. I’d suggest visiting them if possible, before you decide which bit of town you’re interested in living in. Two very good grammar schools, and one good and one OK comprehensive within range.
MTBing wise obviously there are plenty of excellent rides you can start from the door, and easy access to a stack more if you’re driving. Gisburn is 25 minutes away by car. It’s easy enough to get back along to the Baildon/Bingley riding if you fancy that.
Happy to provide more specific info if you need it. I’ll stick my email on my profile.