Did anyone else find the photo of Gaddafi in death quite disturbing?
It makes me think of the days when executed people's heads were put on pikes for all to see.
It would be nice if the human race could move beyond turning corpses into trophies.
Chat Forum
Gaddafi's death
-
Posted 7 months ago #
-
Im told that you have to imagine being repressed and persecuted and tortured for a lifetime before you can understand why the reactions are always so barbaric.
Im also told that as a comfy westerner ill never understand.
Apparently, this is the wrong forum too..Posted 7 months ago # -
No.
However, I was disturbed to see the pictures of the victims his troops burned alive in warehouses a couple of weeks ago.
I was disturbed to see pictures of the civilians he has tortured and murdered.
I was disturbed to see the crying faces of the children whose mother and fathers he murdered.
Posted 7 months ago # -
I agree.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Can't say I 'like' seeing photos of dead people, no matter if they were evil bastards.
Must admit I did check out the video of Saddam's trapdoor exit shortly after though. Never felt compelled to see it before. Was pretty weird. And not sure it should be available on t' interspace.
Posted 7 months ago # -
its the video of him alive before hand that i found more disturbing
whatever his crimes, it wouldve been better for him to face a trial and potential execution rather than being shot, stripped, dragged behind a truck and then killed (which is i gather what happened)
edit i think he was stripped after death
Posted 7 months ago # -
Have watched the BBC News and Channel 4 and have to say the images broadcast were gruesome and IMO really not necessary. Yes, there were warnings and yes there is an off button but how have we got to the point where this is somehow acceptable for broadcast at 6 or 7pm and furthermore, can the story not be told without using such images?
Posted 7 months ago # -
An inglorious and brutal end to an inglorious and brutal man
You usually get what's coming to you, don't you?
Posted 7 months ago # -
Is the Hague the war crimes/genocide court?
Posted 7 months ago # -
He treated people like they were animals and as such is it surprising he also was treated like an animal in the end?.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Enjoy a good lynching do you digger?
Posted 7 months ago # -
I thought it perhaps shouldn't have been splashed on the front page of the news sites I saw it on (including the BBC, who really should know better). Prompted some rapid window-shutting when my 3 year old was around, that did. I know we've made ourselves a rather nasty little world to live in, but I'm doing my damndest to keep that from him for as long as possible.
Posted 7 months ago # -
bigbloke - Member
He treated people like they were animals
Really? a country with a low mortality rate, good food security, good medical care etc - perhaps one of the most prosperous and stable counties in Africa until we backed one side in a civil war and **** over another country to go with our sucess in Afghanistand an Iraq
Try looking to charles taylors Liberia or amins uganda...............
Posted 7 months ago # -
Now if only they'd do this to the war criminals of Iraq and Afghanistan... George Bush and Tony Blair
Posted 7 months ago # -
No.
However, I was disturbed to see the pictures of the victims his troops burned alive in warehouses a couple of weeks ago.
I was disturbed to see pictures of the civilians he has tortured and murdered.
I was disturbed to see the crying faces of the children whose mother and fathers he murdered.
Are you equally disturbed to see the pictures of civilians killed by western troops in Iraq and Afghanistan? Etc...
Whilst I can understand the delight of millions who hated Gaddafi, who was undoubtedly a nasty bastard, what do you think of Iraqis who parade with the dead bodies of US soldiers, who they see as murderous scum in just the same way?
And what if any British people were to want to see the same happen to David Cameron, or Tony Blair, etc?
Not directed to you personally btw, simply general questions.
I don't really think that dragging a battered corpse around screaming like madmen lends anyone any dignity. And as for those shouting 'Allah hu Akbar', well, treating the dead body of a fellow Muslim in such a manner isn't going to mark you out as a respectable follower of Islam.
Posted 7 months ago # -
jivehoneyjive - Member
Now if only they'd do this to the war criminals of Iraq and Afghanistan... George Bush and Tony Blair
Even that evil prick Donald Rumsfeld should have the benefit of trial and jail. I've never fancied myself a bleeding heart, but the notion of killing someone, then plastering their image all over the public domain, is just terrible.
Posted 7 months ago # -
I'd be happy to put Gordon Browns head on a stake and parade it around a bit if you'd like me to and can arrange an opportunity..
If you could chuck Mandelson and Blair in for good measure I might even do it for free..
Posted 7 months ago # -
perhaps one of the most prosperous and stable counties in Africa
How many of those less prosperous have huge oil reserves? How many of those less stable have autocratic repressive regimes?Posted 7 months ago # -
There were warnings given on the news before the images were broadcast, you could have chosen not to look.
Posted 7 months ago # -
aracer - Member
perhaps one of the most prosperous and stable counties in Africa
How many of those less prosperous have huge oil reserves?
Nigeria?
Posted 7 months ago # -
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Nigeria
yeah - it's a real basket case
Posted 7 months ago # -
Elfinsafety - Member
And what if any British people were to want to see the same happen to David Cameron, or Tony Blair, etc?
Aren't you one of those polishing up your dancing shoes in anticipation of a certain ex PMs death ??
To glorify or rejoice in the death of another human being is (IMO) never a justifiable position
Posted 7 months ago # -
allthepies - Member
There were warnings given on the news before the images were broadcast, you could have chosen not to look.
Nonsense. First of all, I don't have a tv, so there were no warnings. I saw the still pictures on Google News, which - as you know - trawls the world's news sources and simply indexes the headlines.
As it was, I simply went to GN, and was faced with a half-dozen images staring back at me, from such sources as the BBC and the Independent.
Posted 7 months ago # -
I hope I'm wrong, but it looks like the new Libyan regime doesn't care much more about justice than the old one.
In which case any democracy they might hope to create will be built on foundations of sand.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Really? a country with a low mortality rate, good food security, good medical care etc - perhaps one of the most prosperous and stable counties in Africa until we backed one side in a civil war and **** over another country to go with our sucess in Afghanistand an Iraq
Stability backed up by ruthless crushing of all dissent, though. A fair trial would have been nicer, but I can't say I'm particularly concerned that he's dead.
Posted 7 months ago # -
To think hell never be called to account for farting while John Simpson interviewed him. **** outrageous.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Advanced civilization seems to mean we have to be nice to everyone no matter what they've done. You know, human rights.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Enjoy a good lynching do you digger?
Think you should re-read my post as you've clearly missed the point.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Not that I can see. You seem think its acceptable that he was lynched. any violent death is wrong.
Posted 7 months ago # -
Well TJ, if I enjoyed a "good lynching" as you have suggested I would hardly be disturbed by pictures of the remains of people having been burned alive, other victims who had tortured/murdered or by their children who have lost their fathers & mothers would I?
Useful to apply logic before posting sometimes.
Posted 7 months ago # -
ut you are not disturbed by seeing a man killed by a mob? OK a bit OTT from me but so was your post. You certainly seemed to be relishing his violent death
Posted 7 months ago # -
any trial would have been a farce and would have turned him into a cartoon rather than the evil tyrant that he is/ was.
in the circumstances, I think he had a fair trial.Posted 7 months ago # -
Do you know, given all the available options I'd rather be dictated to by the Americans, Blair, Cameron or even Thatcher as to what my life might be like rather than Gadaffi or Hussein quite honestly? So while I share some qualms about what has gone on I'm not going to be so hypocritical as to feign indignation whilst continuing to enjoy a way of life that is a function of it.
Posted 7 months ago # -
If we were talking about this happening to a nice bloke it might be different...
BUT THIS GEEZER WAS NOT A NICE BLOKE
It isn't often in this poxy world that something approaching justice happens....the fact that it happened in a poxy way lends it symmetry...
go with the flow people
Posted 7 months ago # -
That is not gruesome at all.
They should put him to trial then ... hang, drawn and quarter (live TV or pay per view).
The gruesome thing to watch is the little girl in China that got ran over by two vans. That's gruesome considering 18 people walked passed her without giving any concern. A land with no heart. That 18 people should be hang,drawn and quarter to free up space.
Posted 7 months ago #
Reply »
You must log in to post.
