If your Staffy did have a hissy fit, would you be able to stop him / her if it decided to attack another dog / kid etc? The rhetoric would suggest nothing can be done apart from shooting them – what’s the reality?
This is the crux of the argument, isn’t it? But also what would put her in a hissy fit too?
The simple answer is that as far as I could control her it wouldn’t be an issue. She was always on a lead where I knew there were going to be people or other dogs. If she was on a lead and another dog provoked, I would then have had to make the decision as to whether the lead was restricting her abiliity to defend herself.
If she was off the lead and I saw either another dog or people, she would go straight back on it.
I can only recall 4 situations over a four year period where there were problems, 3 of those provoked by others and the fourth was only a rabbit. I none of the situations did I lose control of my dog, she was on a lead and yes, I could pull her off.
On the other side, we were out for a walk and a little boy, 3 or 4 yrs, came over to give her some crisp. She took them in such a gentle manner, so unlike our old collies that would have snapped the hand that fed.
The secret is not letting them be out of control in the first place.
EDIT: She was 34kg and a good portion of that was muscle, strong she was, I’m only 67kg. 😕
curiosity led rather than antagonistic…
Ask a sensible question… 😀