I generally find the slimmer harder saddles are more comfy as I think they give you more support (I hate the big padded sofa like things).
I had a Charge Ladle for a while and found it ok, but a bit wide for me and not as nice as my WTB Deva saddle. I now have WTB Deva saddles on both my bikes. The more expensive racey one is the nicest but the slightly more padded gel ones are still really great and I recently bought one for a friend for £20, so they're a real bargain in my opinion. They're a bit narrower than the ladle and easier to get off the back, but obviously saddles are a pretty personal thing.
(All I would say is steer clear of the WTB She saddle – its the most horrible thing I've ever ridden!)