Have and use both
Saguaro is a fast cheap, tough all rounder. I don’t mind them on the front either, but I’m very much cross country. Good on road, good enough in mud (I’m in the south, there is plenty of that – they work on the lethal chalk mix round here too) and don’t cut up on the flint like other way more expensive treads. I think there may be slight weight penalty, but not noticed. TNT went on OK with track pump, second season fit needed the compressor but very few don’t.
Barro Mountain are on at the moment. Basically the same but one louder – more grip, less speed, bit tougher. Could throw one on the front and Sag on the back.
Of the two I’d go for Saguaro front and back for your use case. Run tubeless for best effect, and if it’s grimy drop 5 psi out