I’ve not had experience with any of the above mentioned, but recently replaced a Polaris Jacket (lining fell apart) with an Endura Flyte which I’ve been impressed with so far, that Mayhem looks nice though… depends if you want a hood or not I guess?
I find with clothing the best thing to do is read the reviews, take with pinch of salt, then find places with them in stock, try them on and buy the one that fits best/feels most comfortable.
Due to the cost of decent jackets shops will rarely stock ones that they haven’t had good experiences with due to hassle of returns etc.