I don't think the question should be has anyone test driven an Alfa but has anyone driven 50k miles in one….
I find them beautifully styled & great when new but longevity concerns particularly squeek & rattle resistance. Loved my 147 to look at but damn pleased it was a company car.
But is that really much different from any other manufacturer?? I don't see a preponderance of Fiats / Alfas sat on the hard shoulder…
Alfa's reputation may have been deserved at one stage (fixing that date would be a debate in itself…) but how many of the recent Alfa's peers have been significantly better?? – don't forget 147 is a 10 year old model…
We've currently got a Ford S Max – great car & concept, but build quality is poor.
Previously had Renault Scenic – truly awful in every respect, Merc C Class – well built, but certainly not perfect, BMW 3 Series – nicely balanced drive but very ordinary in every other respect.
Three cars that stand out in my "car history" are
Golf Gti Mk 5 – excellent in most respects, but so competent it wasn't fun at normal road speeds,
Alfa 156 Sportwagon – beautiful, reliable and sounded gorgeous, would just look out of the office window to look at the damn thing,
and my best ever car…
a bright red 309 GTi