I’ve got…
DMR Vault
Spank Oozy
Specialized Boomslang
Hope F20
Xpedo Spry
Nukeproof Electon and Proton
So, can talk with some breadth 🙂
The Hope f20 are by far the most reliable, and durable. The Vaults are the grippiest and largest. The Boomslang have the best bearing configuration, so should be actually more durable than the Hopes, they’re small though, so bigger than a size 9 and you’ll find them a bit small.
The Boomslang and the Oozy have a smaller Q factor, so feel more efficient to pedal. The Oozy is larger though, so easier to stomp on
The Spanky Oozy are very big, and very grippy, but they don’t seem to last very long as I’ve had mine serviced three times in a few months.
Only the Boomslang and Vaults are concave. And once you go concave, its really hard to do back to a fully flat pedal.
So far, my favourite pedals would, if they all lasted forver.. Would be..
1. Boomslang
2. DMR Vault
3. Spank Oozy
4. Hope F20
5. Nukeproof
If I did take the longevity into account the Oozy would go to the bottom.