Home Forums Bike Forum 2×9 to 2×10 is there any advantage

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • 2×9 to 2×10 is there any advantage
  • naffa
    Free Member

    I’m currently running Deore 2×9, 22&36 upfront and 11-34 rear.
    I’m thinking of going 2×10 as people seem to be banging on about it.
    Is there really much advantage?
    If so what is it?
    And what will I need to convert my setup. I already have some bits which I’ve picked up such as chain and 2×10 shifters.

    Thanks Nathan

    VanHalen
    Full Member

    2*10 is heavier

    i cant see the point in 10 speed.

    i cant see the point in 9 speed either really.

    ruscle
    Free Member

    I found that switching to 2×10 with a 11-36 cassette gave me nearly the same spread of gears with less over lap o the gear inches, so more gears in practice. Also the difference between each gear is less of a jump so making the transition easier, which I found to be more beneficial when climbing. You can go onto Sheldon browns web site and use the gear inches calculator to find out any differences and overlaps. There are quite a few over laps when running a 9 speed system.

    Gear inches calculator[/url]

    Superficial
    Free Member

    Shadow plus (or SRAM type 2, I guess?) is a good reason to upgrade if you’re half thinking about it. It’s lovely.

    Other than that, the only real advantage is a (slightly) wider spread of gears if you go for an 11-36 cassette, this wider spread *might* enable you to go 1*10 which is significantly lighter, and neater IMO.

    Standard 2×9 vs 2×10, both with the same spread cassette and without Shadow Plus, I wouldn’t bother.

    VanHalen
    Full Member

    1×10 being significantly lighter is wrong.

    its a bit lighter but not alot. the cassettes are heavy. there was a thread a few days ago where there was suprise at how little it saved.

    and 1×9 will be even lighter still.

    the clutch mechs do look very good though

    shortcut
    Full Member

    It’s just down to range of gears really and clutch mechs.

    What you need: according to Shimano at least – shifters, mechs, chain, cassette, chain set!

    naffa
    Free Member

    But would I need everything Shimano says?
    Is there any compatability between 9&10 speed gear?
    I have already got mega 9 front rings, slx rear and xt front mechs and x7 2×10 shifters and a 10 speed chain.

    emac65
    Free Member

    My Anthem came with 3×10 gearing,it feels exactly the same as a 3×9 set up.. IMO it’s nothing but a gimmick….
    Also run a bike with 1×9,I won’t be bothering to change it to 1×10…

    racingsnail
    Free Member

    If you go to Shimano 10 speed the pull ratio on the cable is supposed to work better than 9 speed when your cable gets grimey.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

The topic ‘2×9 to 2×10 is there any advantage’ is closed to new replies.