Forum menu
no relegation so no worries about planning for the future (investment etc) and could possibly mean teams start to play to win As opposed to trying not to loose ([b]Leicester for example[/b])
Yeah, they always seem to be too concerned with not getting relegated 😉
I hope it doesn't go down the pro 12 route though where teams only seem to care about winning to keep a European place alive and fans don't seem to care at all!
You English by any chance?
Relegation and promotion is important for the english game, specifically a professional 2nd tier.
I'm against complete ringfencing, however would be prepared to see an overhaul of the current system (top plays bottom/every other year/whatever). The stupid play offs need to go.
I'd happily see two up two down, with the winner of the championship gaining automatic promotion and 2-5 having a play-off. I think that comes from seeing Bristol choke the play-offs all the time. 😀
The trouble is darcy; with an expanded prem there aren't two more teams in the champ who could compete in the AP. Nobody wants to see another pathetic effort a la LW.
Oh right, yeah...don't see any reason for an expanded premiership myself...but I don't pay a lot of attention to it to be fair. I suppose it might lead to more broken players for the internationals though. 🙂
Only really Bristol and Wuss who have experience of the Prem, although the newly branded Yorkshire Carnegie (Leeds) may remember something.
Its been touted that 'basil' will be leaving Sale to join Carnegie as DoR next season so perhaps they intend to mount a premiership challenge.
It's not just the experience, it's the facilities, infrastructure, fan base, academy and the finances to mount a decent challenge. Clubs will need to bring something to the prem, which is something that seems to have escaped LW.
I don't follow the blooding young English talent pish either,end to LV and relegation and the salary cap removal will surely see a situation similar to the French league,where local players are playing second fiddle to highly paid furry-ners.I think LW are a special case,they abandoned the model that made then fairly competitive last time with disastrous results. And as somebody who played for the side currently sitting third in the Championship,what is the point of them or any other ambitious/semi pro team bothering any more?
I don't follow the blooding young English talent pish either
Absolutely. It would mean less opportunities for english players as the champ would go semi pro/amateur, meaning less talent reaches the prem and less opportunities for players to go out on loan. Essentially it would keep the 2nd tier in the second tier, no sugar daddy is going to want to have his ego stroked in the championship.
Two division british league with a properly organised season with international breaks.
With a quota system to keep the Welsh involved in European competition? 😉
No need for that loum,Shite floats.
Would be happy to see no quota. Wont happen though back to watching ospreys play leinster a game no one gives a **** about. Or maybe away at glasgow with a a crowd of six men two dogs and a haggis.
So Duckman was it your dog that attacked Castro?
If so hope you made sure its vaccinations were up to date first!!
Why would Welsh supporters come to Glasgow when it is a long trip and they can just see their team pumped at home and save on horseshoes and turnpike road fees!
Nowt to do with my mutt A-A, however if he was ever left alone with Ashton...
Thats it fella you come out fighting 😉
Who is this Horne fella. Shame the McShingler poach didnt work out.
Scots on a huge whingefest already, get over it ffs. YOU ATE NOT WELSH!!!
Two division british league with a properly organised season with international breaks.
WITH promotion and relegation.
Promotion between the two or from below? The later would be almost impossible to set up but with a strictly enforced wage cap it could be good I suppose.
At least between the two, probably the one below too.
Good game this
Clancy is making the scrum a farce. I thought the point was bring the front rows closer to eliminate the "hit".
FFS.
One of my mates is on the bench for Scotland today. Hope he gets on.
I hate the Clancy Clown.
Why can't McLean reproduce this form for Sale?
Here we go. Let's see how the lad plays.
Hamish has to be better than Beattie who has been rubbish.
He's certainly not been afraid of getting in about the play.
Classic hometown ref decision.
Awful reffing.
Too late clown.
HOLY SHIT!
Fantastic!
Go Italy!
I take it all back, he grew a pair in the end.
why is colin charvis the scotland water boy.
Oh dear, can see a large woods stirring implement in Scotland's near future!
McLean gets man of the match yet can't get a start for Sale!
Well done Italy. Good decision by the ref at the end there.
All this talk of Italy needing to be kicked out of the 6N as they are a bit of a joke, eh? 😀 Scotland had some good moments but on balance I think Italy deserved the win. Scotland were nearly let off with Italy have no one capable of kicking a penalty or conversion but at the end of the day they make life impossible for themselves 9 times out of 10 like the missed touch at the end
reffing improved at the end.
Having just passed my level 2 last week, I try and concentrate and learn from the international refs, but I found it difficult not to disagree with a lot of today's decisions.
That Italian pack is superb though, and they deserved their win.
The thread needs more refs to be honest. There are nowhere near enough experts on it.
All this talk of Italy needing to be kicked out of the 6N as they are a bit of a joke, eh?
Exactly. Shame for scotland but glad that the italians have popped a couple of fingers up to the snobs.
Italy aren't all that far of beating the bigger teams really. A little more savvy and better kicking, & who knows ?
but I found it difficult not to disagree with a lot of today's decisions.
I am justvan arm chair ref but its hard to disagree with Clancy based on individual decisions but he seems to me to lack feel for the game. He needed to ping the props off the park early and scotland wete lucky not to be yellowed 5 mins earlier.
Expect Wales to be shoved off the park in scrums today and Baldwin to be even worse at lineout chucking....
Not looking forward to Wales defending that Italy maul but thats a fear for another day!
Duckman I feel your pain, been there.
Ironic to do a piece on Roberts and how settled he is in France just days after the news he is looking to end his contract early and come home 😉