Forum search & shortcuts

Rugby Thread 2018/1...
 

[Closed] Rugby Thread 2018/19

Posts: 8424
Free Member
 

When English players celebrate a try which means a draw with a second-string Scottish side as if they’ve won the championship...


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 8:50 pm
Posts: 7766
Full Member
 

Kryton; ok when you do it though eh?


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 8:57 pm
Posts: 27603
Free Member
 

Kryton; ok when you do it though eh?

No. Where have I been insulting and racist?  Please feel free to point it out. And before you do, I’m not retorting to you or AA and having an argument in here for which you both have form. I would like to read about and have discussion about rugby, not have an internet argument.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:00 pm
Posts: 58
Free Member
 

WTF are you talking about?

This ??????????? kryton explain.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:01 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

No. Where have I been insulting and racist?

WTF are you on about?


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:01 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

When English players celebrate a try which means a draw with a second-string Scottish side as if they’ve won the championship…

Did you see May when he tackled Parkes into touch v Wales 😀😀😀


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:05 pm
Posts: 2591
Free Member
 

Geez Kryton! This is rugby. A bit of piss taking is what's meant to happen.

The Welsh are entitled to be over the moon. Everyone else except the English is entitled to laugh at England's dramatic collapse and general inability to do anything other than play by numbers.

The Scots don't know whether to laugh at their amazing escape or cry at their failure to hold on for the win.

Nobody is derogatory, racist or whatever. Get over it.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:07 pm
Posts: 7766
Full Member
 

I have form? You seem to forget your wee anti Welsh rant that even the unmissed teamhurtmore told you to edit.Oh,I forgot; "that isn't you anymore." Now why not quote where AA made racist remarks as that is quite a claim, I hope you reported it!


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:08 pm
Posts: 52609
Free Member
 

What the biggest shame of the afternoon is that England played last in the dead rubber game, I think it would have been different if they had played first and I think they did loose some focus after half time. Taking nothing away from Scotland for coming back into that and taking their chances, interceptions are good for the underdog and a stroke of luck both ways 🙂


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:11 pm
Posts: 28593
Free Member
 

Everyone else except the English is entitled to laugh at England’s dramatic collapse

That's a bit discriminatory. As an Englishman, I'm entitled to have a laugh as well. 🙂

Well done Wales, BTW.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:14 pm
Posts: 7766
Full Member
 

Getting away from the puddingless one. As a Scot, to see my team come back; to ram that bellend Jones words back down his throat while short of 9 first choice players was just amazing. And FINALLY Russell showed for a decent period time what a player he is, he dragged Scotland forward by the scrff of the neck. Scotland; reigning Calcutta cup holders.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:24 pm
Posts: 739
Full Member
 

😁😁👍👍


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:28 pm
Posts: 739
Full Member
 

Let's hope our girls have a second half like the boys 👍


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:37 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

And FINALLY Russell showed for a decent period time what a player he is, he dragged Scotland forward by the scrff of the neck.

I thought he was mad in the first half with his plays and tgen he was a mad genius second half.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 9:52 pm
Posts: 7279
Free Member
 

I would be interested to see the penalty count for the whole tournament, my guess is Wales's is a fraction of anyone else's. England's defence looked more impressive at times, but the discipline Wales showed throughout was at a level I don't recall seeing before, knock backs for show, discipline for dough.

Didn't see the second half of Eng Sco today, apart from the last few minutes, as a Huddersfield Town fan I was quite relieved to see the final try.


 
Posted : 16/03/2019 11:17 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

ok


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 8:28 am
Posts: 44823
Full Member
 

I am still a little shellshocked from yesterday. I actually gave up watching in the first half but saw all the second. I think Russell was right to be gutted not to have won that game at the end but overall a draw is fair and retaining the Calcutta cup no mean achievement.

Russell - that was a display out of the top drawer and he had Farrell and co chasing phantoms. I can't wait for the squidge report! Now do you understand what we see in him? Russell showed good control and a good kicking game as well bar the obligatory missed penalties to touch. Normally the FB would be taking them but you buggers have broken all our fullbacks!!

Over all 6N - well done to Wales for a grand slam. No mean achievement and a tribute to Gatland as a coach that he has got the best out of these guys. Boring to watch as a neutral tho. 😉 Ireland - just looked spent. England - in patches unbeatable but in patches very beatable indeed. France - glimpses of potential as with Italy
Scotland - disappointing with only one win. The sheer amount of injuries was just too much. Missing half a dozen first choice forwards and loads of backs including in some places being down to 3rd or 4th choice! However that last half brings a little hope and many of those players should be back for the WC.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 9:55 am
Posts: 5689
Free Member
 

Pretty good summary there TJ.....Gatland has to now be considered as an all time great I think. The amount of injuries and changes that have happened to Wales over the last few years and yet they're grand slam winners. Ireland have almost done an England of last year, although not quite as bad.....they look knackered and Sexton looks a shadow of the world player of the year. England.....we've got to sort this second half problem out. We were comfortable against Wales and having Scotlands pants down big style at half time and folded big style both times. Scotland, hard to say, so many injuries....Finn Russell when good is great, when bad must be very frustrating to be around! France just looked like France, I doubt Morgan Parra will play for them again. Italy havled their -points difference of the last two years I think, looked vaguely competitive against Wales and probably should have beaten France yesterday, it's a worry that they just don't seem to have a clue how to win or control a game (why would you when you lose that often I guess)

Overall a great tournament, even my girlfriend was gutted when she realised that that was the final weekend. She's gotliterally no clue about rugby, but there's always such a great atmosphere in the pubs around here when they show the games. I hate the day after it's all over, it's as far away as ever now!

Gats for 2021 Lions coach?


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 10:59 am
Posts: 5689
Free Member
 

Ooh also.....player of the tournament.

AWJ I reckon.

Honourable mentions to Tom Curry and Josh Navidi.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 11:17 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I have watched every single England test since 2002 live and yesterdays was the single most useless game I have ever seen and that includes some total cack.the moment I saw Dan Cole lumbering around a ruck I knew we were in trouble. Almost looked like match fixing.
Fairplay to Scotland who should be furious with themselves for not winning and well done to Wales who got better throughout the tournament. I see Ireland going well at the world cup with expectations lowered, Wales doing well and Engkand to play some great first halves.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 11:26 am
Posts: 293
Free Member
 

Am I right in thinking the england women’s 15 is professional team, whilst the rest of the 6 Nations are amateurs? They put 80 points on Scotland to nil and smashed Wales. It is hardly a level playing field if they are.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 12:09 pm
Posts: 7862
Full Member
 

I think a couple of the Scotland team are semi/professional.
Lisa Thomson, another hawick player, is a "supported player". But yes your going to get pumped by a pro team if your amateurs.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 12:22 pm
Posts: 52609
Free Member
 

It is hardly a level playing field if they are.

No but you can't ask England to take a step back, it should help raise the profile given the coverage which should get more funds into the game which can help the other 5 to invest and develop


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 12:25 pm
Posts: 293
Free Member
 

Jeez the men’s game in Wales is a shambles, can’t see the girls going pro for a long time, how long are sponsors going to put up with such one sided games. How long are people going to be interested when the outcome is preordained and how long are women going to want to play when they have no chance of getting a result?


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 12:42 pm
Posts: 52609
Free Member
 

and how long are women going to want to play when they have no chance of getting a result?

About as long as Italy's Mens side?

https://www.sixnationsrugby.com/women/womens-table/
https://www.sixnationsrugby.com/women/womens-fixtures-results/

The games below the England ones are more competitive, it's not all about winning the overall here.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 12:50 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

You have to wonder if England need to look at their conditioning.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 1:15 pm
Posts: 5689
Free Member
 

I know it's daft coming up with 'faults' when they've won the Slam, but is it just me that thinks Anscombe at 15 Liam on a wing and Biggar at 10 is the best Welsh formation? Add Webb at 9 Scott Williams back at centre, Falatau back at 8 and it's a very threatening team.

Add Mako and Maro back to the English team and ditto. I reckon Mako was a huge loss for us.

Once Ireland have got all first team players back fit.....man I can't wait for the RWC.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 2:16 pm
Posts: 24870
Free Member
 

Maybe, but I think it's more tactical and mental. Against Wales they had no plan b, lost faith in being able to win, and consequently lost. Yesterday.... there's no way you should lose a game from 31-0 (I know they drew but tell me it wasn't a loss really). Conceding to 31-7 gave a glimmer but even so, it's still 4 scores and three tries in what, 15 mins.....that is purely in the head, that feeling of '****, we're going to blow this' and then everyone loses their heads, belief, focus, misses tackles, tries to chase the game to get control.

And then inevitably you start to get tired, because being ****ed like that makes you feel sorry for yourself and when that happens, you do feel it physically too.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 2:21 pm
Posts: 2591
Free Member
 

Now do you understand what we see in him?

I've always understood.

Anyone who thinks Farrell is a better fly half is a neep.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 2:22 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

I know it’s daft coming up with ‘faults’ when they’ve won the Slam, but is it just me that thinks Anscombe at 15 Liam on a wing and Biggar at 10 is the best Welsh formation? Add Webb at 9 Scott Williams back at centre, Falatau back at 8 and it’s a very threatening team.

I think Anscombe at 10 with Loopy at 15 and North 14 is Wales best bet. Having said that Biggar at ten in a monsoon like yesterday doesnt weaken us. Scott Williams legs have gone, he's slower than Parkes now. Parkes stays. Web b at 9 would be nice and Faletau back at 8 means Moriarty, Navidi or Tips are dropped, we could also have McShingler in the mix for 6 which will help the lineout. One of Navidi or Moriarty might not make the World cup squad if they are all fit!

but I think it’s more tactical and mental

Not sure, having all the heavy runners on from the start sees them blowing out their arse after 50 mins and then Dank Hole lumbers on to add impetus!!


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 3:34 pm
Posts: 5689
Free Member
 

I can't quite believe Dan Cole is back playing.

Last day of the prem season last year Leicester hammered Sale at home....my only memory though is every time Dan Cole was a guard at a breakdown Far dr Klerk literally ran around him and made a break..... honestly it was like watching a pro v a binman! We're ****ed if he's playing against SA in the world cup!

No way at all that Navidi isn't going to the RWC.... throughout the Autumn and 6n's you can make the case for him being the best player!! Moriarty looks out of form, didn't he have an injury lay off?


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 3:44 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

Moriarty looks out of form

Really you need to open your eyes, true he's no 8, he's a 6 but he was fantastic. You have to remember he's at least 10-20kg lighter than Billy V, Picamoles, Parisse and Stander.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 3:53 pm
Posts: 5689
Free Member
 

Agreed he's not an 8. I'd have Navidi at 6 over him any day of the week. As for him being 'fantastic' I'll have to take your word for that then. I'd didn't see the Wales Scotland game, but didn't see much from him in the other games.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 4:12 pm
Posts: 5672
Full Member
 

but didn’t see much from him in the other games.

But he wasn't doing the normal no8 work. He was playing as another 6. All of the hard nasty work at the breakdown. Navidi is a better allround back row player, he's deceivingly strong and a powerful ball carrier. And NotToby is a proper footballing 8.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 4:54 pm
Posts: 2591
Free Member
 

Conceding to 31-7 gave a glimmer but even so, it’s still 4 scores and three tries in what, 15 mins…..that is purely in the head, that feeling of ‘****, we’re going to blow this’ and then everyone loses their heads, belief, focus, misses tackles, tries to chase the game to get control.

Indeed but can you imagine an England side containing Martin Johnson, Jonny Wilkinson or, dare I say it, Dylan Hartley doing that?

England needed a bit of leadership but there was none.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 5:05 pm
Posts: 5689
Free Member
 

As you may be able to tell, I'm a bit of a Navidi fanboi.....work rate, strength, carrying ability, breakdown work.....I rate him right up there. I could actually see him at 8 if NotToby was out injured.

Did a Warburton Navidi Falatau back row ever happen?


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 5:11 pm
Posts: 5
Free Member
 

a_a, that clip up there ^^^
My lip reading's not brilliant but is that...

"Hello.
Nice to meet you.
I love you
"

?

(",)


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 6:01 pm
Posts: 50252
Free Member
 

Anyone else have an embarrassing trip to the bottle bank today?

🍻


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 6:08 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

“Hello.
Nice to meet you.
I love you”

I thought "thank you mate" "I love you". You could be right though.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 6:41 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

Did a Warburton Navidi Falatau back row ever happen?

Not sure, dont recall it. Problem for Navidi is that he's still not the best flanker for Cardiff even now Warburton has retired. Ellis Jenkins is a better player.

Moriarty was ****ing immense though, all six nations. England spent so much time smashing him behind the gainline and trying to run him over and it was them who got knackered. Having Faletau back would be great though. Keep Moriarty on the bench.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 6:46 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

Oh and post World Cup I back Wainwright to displace them all at 6.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 6:48 pm
Posts: 26900
Full Member
 

http://www.espn.co.uk/rugby/playerstats?gameId=294259&league=180659

Navidi 20+ tackles
Wainwright 12 in 9 mins

POM 1 in what 60 mins!!!!!!!


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 7:05 pm
 DanW
Posts: 1062
Free Member
 

It is easy to look at the shiny things these players get up to and forget what they bring to a team. I think Wales have a formula which can be adapted to Japan so it's a case of "if" there are injuries then who fills the same roll and in the more likely case, how do you adapt overall with who is available?

For me, you want Williams or 1/2p at 15 with the former the preference for x-factor attack. Both need to cover a lot of ground and read the game exceptionally well. I'd probably have Patchell as the third option. It was a good call to keep Anscombe kicking to try and get rid of up the perceived inability of him to kick points under pressure. Some of those kicks were immense. You now have 3+ guys with the mentality of being class goalkickers which is a strong position to be in with a lot of rugby to be played.

As a_a says, Biggar isn't a weakness coming on but isn't necessarily the guy you want for what will probably be hard fast pitches. Anscombe is the long term direction and does exactly what the team needs. Patchell is the next most similar but needs a run of games. Biggar comes in if anything happens to Anscombe but it would be interesting to see what that means for the overall shape.

Tomos Williams or Aled Davies are the style Wales need at 9. One is injured, one has been searching for form after a good season for the Scarlets which feels like an age ago, though I thought he was good yesterday. G.Davies is the one with the most work to do IMO and Webb while wouldn't be awful is a bit like Biggar in taking the team shape/ play back a tiny backwards step, despite all their abilities.

I don't know what others think but Scott Williams is more similar to Jon Davies, or at least he was before injuries. Wales don't really have anyone in the tough, grafter mold of Parkes. Parkes would be a big loss for the structure of the team and got through a ton of work. Backup options in the centres are a little lacking (what a novelty for Wales)

I don't see it as simple as the big names come back when fit. Wales have (thankfully) moved past that attitude and the team is bigger. If Jenkins and Faletau make it back in time then those two plus Navidi/ Moriarty/ Shingler/ Tips would give loads of options but they'll do well to make it back in time. It is really good to see the locks coming on well too and if a few more like Ball come good then happy days. Front row is probably the one to work on with more backup and the starters have been immense.... as well as finding the very best cotton wool/ bubble wrap for AWJ 😀

The most important thing is Wales look like they know what they are trying to do which hasn't always been the case!


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 7:36 pm
Posts: 5
Free Member
 

The stature of Alun Wyn was confirmed for me before the start of yesterday's game when he took off his tracksuit top to wrap around the shivering lad (mascot) while they were lined up in the pouring rain for the anthems.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 8:51 pm
Posts: 50252
Free Member
 

Psling, another grand moment was the sight of AWJ leaving the pitch chatting to Best like a couple of old mates.

Good people, good sport.


 
Posted : 17/03/2019 10:18 pm
Page 63 / 68