[Closed] Q1: Will you be fitting Winter tyres on your car?

I'm umming about buying some [url= http://www.roofbox.co.uk/car-snow-socks/ ]car socks[/url]...

Big thread on this the other day - lots of good arguments for it.

I may wait until my normal tyres wear and then replace with winter tyres permanently - the extra grip on wet and gritty roads is useful year round in the Peak District and some of the comments on the other thread indicated the effect on fuel consumption was fairly low - ie would be only 3-4 mpg which I can save by using my right foot a little more carefully anyway.

yes - done both cars today but i live in Stockholm 🙂

Fitted some last year and they were great, previous years I faffed around with chains, which are fine but tyres are fit and forget.
Had them years ago and after much pi55 taking it was discovered that I was the only person able to get out of the valley we lived in... 😆
Not that much more expensive than normal tyres and it's offset by not wearing out your normal road tyres...

i hope loads do, and then it won't snow this winter and I won't have to bother.

Winter tyres are NOT only for snow, also when it's cold (3-7 degs Centigrade and lower according to a mate who knows about card, my local Surf_Mat 😉 ).

Couldn't afford to buy a second set of Tyres for winter but I wouldn't if I could anyway.

Nope.

I'm not, I didn't last year, I don't see the point....but I know how to drive properly in most conditions 😀 😉

Couldn't afford to buy a second set of Tyres for winter but I wouldn't if I could anyway.

Careful driving negates the need anyway...

Q1: Will you be fitting Winter tyres on your car?

Nope - I don't have a cvar 🙂

I will be fitting winter tyres to my mtb tho - in fact I already have

Considered it in previous years but given I live in London, rarely go too far out of the way and have a diesel FWD car (plenty of weight over the wheels so OK traction), it didn't seem worthwhile. Plus I have a set of snowchains in the boot if it got really bad. And, if it came to it, I can work from home anyway.

If I was out in the sticks and roads I normally used wouldn't get gritted much (and I wouldn't expect any improvement at all over previous winters) and/or I had to stay mobile, I'd find the space for a spare set of steel wheels with winter tyres, just like our European neighbours do.

Do people seriously do this?

Er ...No. We only get a few frosts a year here and only 1 days worth of snow last winter.

No because I mostly managed without them last winter. I got some auto socks for the one or two days when the snow and ice might defeat me. One of the funniest incidents last winter was two weeks after the big snow when roads were mostly clear. I decided to take a minor drove road to go find some to play in. U fortunately a landy had been through making quite deep ruts in the snow and I grounded my Civic! I had to get the shovel out and dig under the car to get the tyres gripping again. Good slippery fun and I'm surprised I got through the winter without ending up in the hedge.

Given that the only time I got stuck in the snow last year was when the front bumper started acting as a snowplough, I don't see the point.

loddrik - Member
Couldn't afford to buy a second set of Tyres for winter but I wouldn't if I could anyway.

Careful driving negates the need anyway...

I disagree - I'm a careful driver but when stopping distances and grip are significantly reduced (when using summer tyres below 7 degrees C), your driving ability is irrelevant IMO. I see a need to fit cold weather tyres - so I have bought some to be fitted soon.

I don't understand why the majority are using summer tyres all year round, why not get proper all weather tyres which sit between the two? Surely it is the equivalent of MTBing in mud using semi-slicks?

I may wait until my normal tyres wear and then replace with winter tyres permanently

They aren't meant for when the tarmac is warm - they are very crap then. Winter tyres all year is a bad idea.

Btw, are you talking about winter tyres or snow specific tyres? Difference, I think (but not sure).

Given that the only time I got stuck in the snow last year was when the front bumper started acting as a snowplough, I don't see the point.

When you reach a hill with packed snow - that's when you need them 🙂

I don't understand why the majority are using summer tyres all year round, why not get proper all weather tyres which sit between the two?

Cos they are a compromise 95% of the time. It's so mild in this country (most of it at least) that tyres designated for summer on the continent work almost all the time here anyway.

No, can't be arsed and never had any problems with normal tyres.

molgrips - fair enough, but I'd say winter tyres are a poor choice for 85% of the year depending on area, but all-season tyres would be at least be decent all year round. Summer tyres in certain places / at certain times just don't work - if I can't get up a 1 in 5 hill near my house then they are useless.

If everybody fitted cold weather tyres between say, November and March there would be less accidents, and long term costs shouldn't be much/any different

When you reach a hill with packed snow - that's when you need them

I survived going up hills with packed snow last winter, so why should this winter be any different?
Majority of places, provided you anticipate the road/terrain and keep your car moving, you won't have any problems. The problem is the amount of idiots who have a total inability to anticipate, or think past the end of their bonnet.

But while we're on the subject of winter, I loved watching all the smashed up Audi Quatros getting recovered into the dealer just up from my work last year. Just because the four wheel drive gives you better traction for pulling away, doesn't mean it gives you extra traction for stopping 😆

And all the unfortunate BMW drivers squirreling around

I survived going up hills with packed snow last winter, so why should this winter be any different?

Then if you meet steeper hills than you did with slippier snow 🙂

Our road was almost impassable last year.

The problem is the amount of idiots who have a total inability to anticipate, or think past the end of their bonnet.

It's not always stupid people's fault you know. Sometimes, there just isn't enough traction. Yes, lots of people are stupid, but that's not always the reason 🙂

provided you anticipate the road/terrain and keep your car moving

Again, not always possible. Last year my colleage who is an intelligent bloke and a good driver came within a gnat's of getting stuck because his drive home is a very busy single carriageway road with hills. It only takes one person to make a mistake for everyone to have to stop, and not be able to start again on a hill.

Nope, I will just just drop the pressure a nats and stop driving like a nob.

Given I coped just fine last year when everybody else was fannying about - several times avoiding the jams on the (fairly clear and easy to drive on) main roads by taking the (covered with snow) back roads - I don't think I'll bother. They'd only do me any good if the numpties were using them.

I will be chucking the winter tyres on again this year. Only got three left after that blow out so going to just put them on the front axle. Oooo whats oversteer?

Energy savers on the front, Alpins on the back, then swap round when it gets cold. Best of both worlds - I was astonished by the difference winter tyres made last year, so as long as the weather looks threatening, I'll keep using them.
🙂

Given the continual discussion about different mountain bike tyres for different conditions, i'm surprised so few think winter tyres would make a difference. But from the looks of it most posts are from awesome drivers.

I remember listening to a discusion on the radio last year. So many people said they were gonna buy a 4x4. Idiots.

I'm so awesome i'm getting some slicks, you lot are all pansies 🙂

I drive a Defender. No need.

BFGoodrich A/T all year round, tis on a Discovery though, so no need...oh, and I live in the Lake so they came into their own last winter. This winter promises to be the same.

Hmm I guess in Mainland Europe they do and the tyres are cheaper.

I just bought Potenza 255x40 x 17 and I'm focussing on rain weather.

If it snows heavy then I'll be using the train or drive the long way via motorways early.

Not looking forward to driving but on the mtb sure!

a shitty little car with winter tyres is going to go farther than a big 4x4 with summer tyres.
regardless of driver superdooperness

Winter tyres going on tomorrow 🙂

No brainer. The right compound for the temperature and no issues when it snows.

Winter tyres are brilliant, no question.

When I've got room and money for a spare set of wheels, I'll probably do it. And probably get socks for this year too.

Would you fit them onto the front wheels of a FWD car if the current tyres needed replacing?

Grabber AT2's, 4WD and diff lock

mwahahahahaha! bring on the snow!

Would you fit them onto the front wheels of a FWD car if the current tyres needed replacing?

I wouldn't have them as my only tyres. I'd have energy savers. However I'd consider a second set of wheels Scandinavian style that I'd swap myself when it got cold.

In snow tho I'd rather have actual snow tyres than general off-road ones.

Ideally, these.. for the 30m or so of road outside my house that iced over for a week 🙂

[img] [/img]

Sorry, I meant would you fit Winter tyres if you needed to replace front tyres on a FWD car now (it's 0 deg. Centigrade now).

This is what our road looked like on the better days for three months this year. Mostly it was covered in ice, sometimes it was 18 inces deep. There are a series of 12% climbs on it. Snow tyres made little difference. I used my 4x4 with a difflock, I only realised how good it was when I tried the same thing in the car. It go no grip whatsoever.

[img] [/img]

Umm.. again I wouldn't unless I was gonna change them back in the spring.

Winter tyres aren't just for snow, they have better grip on colder tarmac and also work well with lots of rain as you might find in winter.

I think that specific snow tyres aren't the same thing as general winter tyres actually.. not sure tho.

I'll change them but have heard the back of the car will be swinging around corners badly. Strangely tempting entertainment 😉