Forum menu
Can't decide which one to crack the seal of.
Votes?
Pulteney tonight and superstition tomorrow?
Jura
Superstition 😀
Superstition ftw.
Jura
The Pulteney has been winking at me for too long.
I similarly have just five minutes ago opened the Superstition 😀
Pulteney definitely!
Jura.
Love both! Find O.P. to be a bit Dalwhinnie-ish, smooth, steady & easy to drink, Superstition a bit more complicated but just as nice. (IMO)
Ardbeg is where its at 😉 neat mind none of your ice/water pish mind you southern poofs, cheers!
Jura, of course.
neat mind none of your ice/water pish mind you southern poofs
Nonsense, a teardrop can transform the flavour, the trick is putting in the bare minimum.
Jura is the Famous Grouse of single malts IMO, on the other hand Old Pulteney is a work of art. You now know which one i would choose :-).
And to prove i am not a complete whisky nobber i recently bought a bottle of Glen Moray and it was excellent 🙂
Ardbeg is where its at
Yes, we know. Except Ardbeg wasn't mentioned in the OP was it?
Stick to the script!!
Old pultney
Just finished a bottle of Teachers and cracked open a bottle of Jura, washed down with ginger ale, bloody lovely, up to 2 months ago I wasn't a whisky drinker, I am now!
Got a bottle of Jura Superstition the other day, it's bloody lovely.
Just finished a bottle of Teachers
Doh! Still not part of the OP is it?
Superstition is nice.
Origin is meh.
Elixir is evil. Must come from the same barrels as Innis and Gunn as it gives me the same hideous hangovers from the same ridiculously small quantities.
Old Pulteney, Jura is rubbish, with added colouring.
Old Pulteney really is a wonderful drop.
Old Pulteney, Jura is rubbish, with added colouring
Superstition's alright but when Talisker's knocking about for £2 more it's not really worth it (still a good value step up from grain-heavy blends).
Old Pulteney is a cracker though, maybe not as many flavours but much more refined. I tried it again last night after trying Jura Turas-Mara and it just seemed much more "full-bodied".
My tip for cheap peaty business is The Ileach, think it's just watered down (40% vs 56%) - though they do a cask strength- young Lagavulin.
NOT OP: My best deals this Christmas were Ardbeg 10 from Booths for £32 and A'bunadh for £35 from Tesco.
My mother in law has just given me a bottle of Jura Superstition.
Hasn't got a clue about whisky, but bought it for me because it was expensive.
Just about to open it now, I'm sure she won't like the slightly peated taste, there's a pity.......