[Closed] Golf vs Focus

We have a Focus TDCI at work, we use it 24/7 (at an international airport) and TBH considering the amount of abuse it takes it's still going strong, it's done over 110k miles in 3 years, it's had all the usual consumables replaced (to be expected with any car)Would I buy one over a Golf.... No!

The build quality of the VW is just so much better (I have had various Golfs in the past and now own a B7 Audi A4) Yes you don't get as much for your money (equipment levels)but you will find that consumables (clutches, bushes, exhausts etc etc) all last much longer

I only went the leasing route as I was stuck what to buy and 300 upfront+100 a month for 15k on two years seemed a good deal. Anything more than 150@month and you'd be better off looking at other options IMO.

I'd rather my neighbours see a Golf on my drive but I'd rather own a Focus. Hands down.

We've have a new 2012 shape Focus in work now for a good few months as a patrol car and whilst it looks a much nicer car than the previous model, many of us prefer our older shape (2011) car.

Both are 1.6 tdci's its easy to do a direct comparison.

The new shape feels a lot smaller inside, the pedals are really close together and the seats are really firm if you’re in the car for a number of hours.

There is also an annoying corner piece of the dashboard that everyone bangs their knee on as they get in and the dashboard is just a mess of buttons.

The new model certainly handles and grips much better than the previous model, but as an A to B car; I’d personally rather buy a low mileage 2011 shape Focus if you want a Ford. Maybe on Ford Direct to get a 2 year warranty?

Also looks a lot smaller in the back? How do your taller non-paying passengers fair??

hora - Member
Also looks a lot? smaller in the back? How do your taller non-paying passengers fair??

There is much less leg room in the back and the new model also feels much more enclosed.

We have a very roomy Transit van for any passengers.

😆

I don't really worry too much about cars. We have 1.8tdci focus estate. It starts, stops, goes round corners, has been cheap to run and trouble free. Oh, and we got 40% off list price from new so with the trade in from my old berlingo it cost about the same to buy as my road bike.
In the end, all it comes down to is buy what suits your budget and your label aspirations.

Compared to what Peter.

Well, any other modern diesel I've ever driven, and ANY petrol engine. Probably the most lacklustre thing I've ever felt connected to a throttle pedal, TBH. And my first car was an Austin Maxi!

Isn't the 1.6 the same engine that Peugeot and a few other companied use? I know my brother had a 307(? I think?) as a courtesy car for a few weeks and hated it, I think that was the same lump

I'd rather my neighbours see a Golf on my drive but I'd rather own a Focus. Hands down.

This. If you're a badge snob pay extra for the VW qudos, otherwise get the Focus, more for your money on a better handling car. That said I've no experience of the newest Focus.

Ahh yes, the 1.6cdti is the same engine as used in
Suzuki
Citroen
mini
ford
mazda
peugeot
and volvo

And apparently made by PSA (Peugeot/Citroen) which alone is enough to warrant avoiding it.

I've not driven the previous incarnations of the engine but I know there were some turbo and fuel injector issues but for what its worth these have both been redesigned in 2012 Econetic engines that's in my Focus and 20000 miles in all is good.

There's a guy in my company who has done over 50000 miles this year on the same engine (in a Volvo) with no problems and no complaints about performance.

Yeah cause peter peugeot have never made some of the most reliable diesels ....., old 306 tds were always blowing up at 60k miles 😉 xuds & dw8 dont have a reputation for being bullet proof. The engines the one part i like in my van

Gearboxes and clutch provide me with more worrys than a psa diesel engine, although if you run shite supermarket fuel they have a tendancy to lunch fuel pumps - an intank job so can be spendy

Fwiw ill never have another vw. Any little issue always became expensive quickly - only had 80k on the clock. - verified by the mots and service history.

Lunched its steering rack - 500 quid plus labour as no one makes a reliable pattern part. Then did its water pump in and the door electrics were going.

Also rear wind screen washer leaked into rear high level brake light and needed swapping . Had to have the headlights swapped as vw supplied it with hid upgrade but this did not meet criteria for the mot of having washers and projectors...... Ok the lights could have been any brand but the other issues are issues ive never had with any car in the past and ive run some of blue ovals finest well into 200k

Gave it away in the end( needing a new engine) was just a money pit. Id much rather have a fordie....even a bad ford is at least reasonable for parts to repair it.

Althouh on a lease the golf probably has better residuals so may be cheaper in long run and if they will maintain it then great.- but id still prefer the focus.

If you're not bothered about the badge, a Kia Ceed - making a real name for themselves recently.
3 months ago we bought a 59 plate 1.6 with less than 12k miles, still with 4 years warranty for £7k.
Looks perfectly acceptable (LS comes with some nice extras), excellent interior and drives really nicely.

As you know, most 3 year old + cars will have no manufacturer warranty left so that was the clincher.
Agree that the leasing thing seems like you're chucking your hard-earned away...

And apparently made by PSA (Peugeot/Citroen) which alone is enough to warrant avoiding it.

Yeah that's just rubbish, PSA diesels are generally regarded as some of the best in the business. The DV6 engine (the 1.6 tdci, hdi, or whatever) is a very highly developed engine and the current 'C' version is one of the best out there. Would be my choice for the Focus. That or the 1.0 ecoboost if you want petrol.

Regarding Astons and Ferraris where do you stand?

Normally close enough to Apply the Wax and then far enough away to hand over the Invoice 😉

(Occasionally close enough to collect and deliver)

hora - Member

I'd rather my neighbours see a Golf on my drive but I'd rather own a Focus.

Sums it up really.

Would be my choice for the Focus. That or the 1.0 ecoboost if you want petrol.

Funnily enough I had a drive in the 998 cc petrol a couple of days ago & I was astounded at how good it was. On the open road you couldn't tell it was such a small engine, & the handling was simply unbelievable. It was like a go kart, no body roll, well damped, pinpoint steering. However, this one only had 600 miles on it and the computer hasn't been reset throughout its short life, and disappointingly it was only managing 32mpg. The average speed was something like 22mph so is clearly used in a mainly urban setting, but we get that from the wife's 1.8 04 plate C-Max.

All Ford official figures tell huge porkies.

I'd still rather have one over a VW though. Driving dynamics first, plastics/appeal second.

All [s]Ford[/s] official figures tell huge porkies.

Ftfy

😀

FOCUS over the golf any day and if you get an estate you can get your bike in the back with the wheels out. Golfs are just Boring. I drive a Focus estate 142000 miles goes from service to service with no issues, cheep to run its a TDCI 1600cc and its averaging 51 mpg and its loaded with tools as its my workshop on the road.id have another anyday. 😀

The new Focus is a lovely car, had a couple on hire when working in the states, they were Autos aswell, still lovely

The other thing that struck me about the focus was the interior build. I think the Mk1 was a class leader, in fact I'd say it was a huge wake up call to VW. Then the mk2 came along was as big a step back as the original was forward. Cheap plasticky feel with easy to wear out faux chrome. This latest one was loverly; easily as good as a mate's 56 plate golf Gti.

`The build quality of the VW is just so much better (I have had various Golfs in the past and now own a B7 Audi A4) Yes you don't get as much for your money (equipment levels)but you will find that consumables (clutches, bushes, exhausts etc etc) all last much longer

That's not borne out in the reliability index:

[url= http://www.reliabilityindex.com/reliability/search/61 ]http://www.reliabilityindex.com/reliability/search/61[/url]

[url= http://www.reliabilityindex.com/reliability/search/247 ]http://www.reliabilityindex.com/reliability/search/247[/url]

mildred - Member

The other thing that struck me about the focus was the interior build. I think the Mk1 was a class leader, in fact I'd say it was a huge wake up call to VW. Then the mk2 came along was as big a step back as the original was forward. Cheap plasticky feel with easy to wear out faux chrome.

Aye, absolutely right... And not just the solidity and feel of the Mk1, but just how well it was thought out. Little niches and nooks everywhere, gigantic loadspace with every mm used up. Whereas the Mk2 just didn't seem bothered. First time I got in my dad's, I was getting annoyed at things like the tiny useless door pockets, or the lack of space around the handbrake, and the way the arm rest's never in the right place to rest my arm on, but often in the way. And it's noisy, too.

I've got a focus. I tried out an octavia and a golf before buying and I preferred driving the Ford. The plastics might be more scratchy but I don't tend to stroke my dashboard when I'm driving.

I used to own a Golf mk6 1.4 GT, and it was great. Really nice to drive, well put together, pretty economical, and quick. Amazing engine. Having driven Focuses in the past, and always thought they were nice to drive, the Golf was better. Having said that, not sure what your basic spec would get you, might be better with the Focus.

Prefer my Mk6 Golf to the countless number of Foci I've driven (hire cars/work pool cars etc.). Not driven a mk7 Golf or brand new Focus though so can't comment. I recommend the OP goes for a test drive of both (back to back if possible, just ring up and book and say you're interested in buying) probably far more useful/valid than asking a load of strangers on a forum. 😉

Have owned both, although older models than your after. The golf had the best interior by a country mile but the focus has the best driving dynamics of any standard car I've ever driven. To give you an example of why fords are so very good in this department you need to read Sir Jackie Stewart's Autobiography. He had to sign off every models driving dynamics and if he wasn't happy it was back to the drawing board. If it's good enough for him it'll do for me. The feedback of the steering, the controls, the feel of the brakes they are just spot on.

g) probably far more useful/valid than asking a load of strangers on a forum.

Not really, owners opinions could point you in a better long term direction than a test drive alone.

Not really, owners opinions could point you in a better long term direction than a test drive alone.

I had an old '02 focus 1.8, loved it, had it up to 88k miles with no major issues. Sister-in-law has the last variant (not the new global one) and doesn't say much either way about it, which is as good as you're realistically going to get - unless you're looking at the top end stuff people don't go around shouting about their cars.

We've now got a pair of golfs, one hatch and an estate. Same scenario really, they won't set your world alight but they are solid and reliable. Both are around the 100k mile mark and I've replaced a temp sensor and a turbo, I was even surprised how cheap the turbo was.

In terms of what you want to do, you'll be just fine with either. You'd be better off buying used than leasing, but that's a different thread all together.

I'd personally go for the Golf as I think they look and feel a classier car than the Focus; although I don't really think they're any better made.

The focus we have in work has buttons all over the place and looks a bit of a mess. The Golfs I've seen look far more plain and simple; which I prefer.

The new 2013 model Golf appears to be getting great reviews, although I know it's early days and the models given to the mags seem to be high spec models.

I always drive like I've got Miss Daisy in the car and get nowhere near the limit of a cars handling, so it wouldn't be high on my list when buying. I'd be more concerned with the specification and crash test results.

There both just run of the mill family hatchbacks and I'd imagine that any handling improvement the Focus has is probably small in the real world.

Or maybe I should just buy a 500 quid banger and deal with the consequnces.

That's what I did 12 months ago. So far the only "consequence" has been new tyres, wiper blades and a new headlight bulb.

Looked at estate versions of both, amongst other things recently as we have downsized from a Mondeo estate.

Firstly, neither are as well put together as the Mondeo.
But most noticeably, I was very underwhelmed by the Golf. Nothing of interest about driving it, didn't feel any better put together or logical.
Focus was of equal build, drove much more directly and involving and had a bigger boot.

Didn't get either in the end, went for a Volvo V50.
Only other thing that size we'd have gone for is probably a BMW 320d.
If the wife wasn't so keen for something smaller, would have stuck with the Mondeo for another 200k. Drove very well for something of its size,

I've owned an '07 plate Golf 1.9tdi (Mk v, from memory) and a mk1.5 (The cosmetic facelift job) 54 plate Focus - the 1.8 TDCI.

The Focus was a lot cheaper, more fun to drive and was pretty cheap to maintain. I bought it for £2,800, spent £150 getting a new timing belt fitted, and ran it as was for a year. I then sold it within a week for £2,100. Friends who have a petrol '09 plate are very happy with theirs - more boot space, and a bigger car on the outside at least. I'd never owned a Ford before, and was very impressed. Would buy again.

The Golf was pretty faultless - at one point, it was dropping oil, but that was because the ****less dealership (Drift Bridge near Epsom) we bought from and had the first service at didn't replace the sump plug properly. They also tried to get us to pay for a new set of tyres and new pads at the first service - both lots were still going strong and had life left when we finally replaced them 8,000 miles later. Hugely disappointed with Drift Bridge.

Given the choice, I'd go for another Focus - we were hugely impressed with ours. The Mk1 was a better drive than the Golf. At the time, we were putting 15k a year on each car - most of it motorway stuff. Thankfully those days are over.

We traded the Golf in for a Skoda Octavia estate (the 1.4tsi) as neither of us drive to work any more, and there are now two Udderlets

My suggestions?

* Work out how many miles you're going to do (do the diesel vs petrol calculation - we've been seriously impressed with the 1.4 petrol in our estate so far), where they'll be (motorway commute, school run etc) and how important the badge and a new plate is to you.

* Also do the calculation on costs over the three years of the lease period. We looked at leasing, and after totting up how much it would cost, it seemed insane. If you have the cash, or can borrow the money, a good second hand car could well save you a fair amount.

* I got an AA inspection on the Focus when we bought, for peace of mind, and it's worth considering if you are concerned about buying a second hand car.

* Look at other makes. Do a bit of web research to see what the common platforms are (ie, some Ford and Volvo models have the same engine and chassis underneath) and how they're rated.

I hope all this helps - and best of luck with the nipper.

Sorry, I forgot - the Golf was Match trim, Focus was Ghia, so had all the bells and whistles - not necessarily what I was looking for, but the heated leather seats were a godsend in the winter.

Last focus I drove, was a 54plate and understeered like sh*t off a shovel anytime you asked anything of it. Didn't like the way it delivered power either, thought it was cheap and tacky inside with not great head room in the rear. The focus does say I just don't care anymore, I'm going from a to b, this will suffice. Second hand value is poor too.

Last golf I owned was a mkII gti and sold it after a year for a profit. 195k miles on the clock too 😆 Solid consistant power delivery through the revs and go kart handling. Rubbish in town, rubbish on the motorway, it leaked and vag parts are a rip off. Get it on a b road though 😀 ❗

The newer golfs I have driven have been comfortable and un spectacular. Well finished inside with a decent use of space.

Get something with character, like an Alfa 😉

So a rebadged Fiat Punto is now called 'something with character', most of these cars are almost the same underneath, all this stuff about VW's being aspiration all and Ford's being for people who've given up is just advertising and what you think that other people would like think about you. Don't try dressing up choices about handling dynamics its almost always about how your neighbours treat you.
It all comes down to price, badge and how badly the dealer for servicing treats you in the end as far as I can see.

Last focus I drove, was a 54plate and understeered like sh*t off a shovel anytime you asked anything of it.

I found the Golf I owned had far less involved handling than the Focus I owned.

I also don't really care that much about cars; I owned and thoroughly enjoyed an F reg Peugeot 205 GTI, which must have been about the same age as your VW, MechMan - so you're looking at a car over 20 years old, likely with plenty of miles on the clock and a number of previous owners. Hardly what the original poster is asking for. The non-GTI mk2 also drove lack a sack of spuds, if my memories of driving my brothers' are anything to go by.

YMMV.

We had shite autogrip tyres on our 10 plate focus, under steered if it looked at a damp corner never mind tried to negotiate it! Stuck on some decent tyres and its been transformed- I am often surprised by how well the car grips when going round the same bends!

most of these cars are almost the same underneath

Well not quite, Focuses have independent suspension at the back and Golfs have torsion beam. Independent suspension significantly improves handling but it takes up more space in the boot.

Well the Guy who went for the Volvo V50 went for the Focus in Volvo clothes, ( its a Focus floorpan) 8)

Volvo V50 2.0 D = Focus floor plan, Mondeo engine - was quite aware of that when I got it 🙂
Focus handles, as does the Volvo and has a better engine than commonly on offer in the Focus (hard to find a Focus with 2.0 diesel s/h)