[Closed] France and the Burka Ban-should they ban it?

I wouldn't mind everyone being equal, if that equality could actually be realised.

Burkas? Fine, but could we go to a predominately Muslim country and wear mini-skirts?

Mosques? Fine, but could we go to a Muslim country and build a Church?

On the subject of Mosques - could we get planning permission from Sheffield City Council for an eyesore such as the monstrosity that adorns the streets of Heeley Bridge?

Whilst we're talking about Heeley Bridge - there seem to be dozens of taxi's and people carriers illegally parked unquestioned on a Saturday afternoon at prayer time, yet if I park half a wheel at the football ground around the corner in the wrong place I get a ticket?

Everyone's welcome in my eyes, but equality shouldn't mean bending over backwards to accomodate.

Apologies if I'm way off the mark, just an opinion.

Alpin isnt smoking , being British and riding a bike a minority thing in Germany lets hope they respect your choices abit more eh?

i know of more people here that smoke ciggies than i did in the UK. i know more people in the UK that smoke weed then here in germany, myself included.

every ****er has at least one bike here and i know of lots of people who don't have a car, myself included (including my 5 other housemates). in the UK almost everyone has a car and hardly anyone has, let alone uses a bike.

i am one of only a handful of brits here in town and most of them are scotch.

my choices are accepted as they aren't ****ing choices that make people uneasy when talking to me and don't close me off from the rest of society.

Turkey is a secular country.

Nuns don't cover their faces Junkyard so I don't get upset. I don't get upset about seeing women in burkas, I feel offended and insulted that the woman won't let me see her face and the messages her expressions convey.

I have to vote for a ban on health & safety.

😈

Interestingly, the burka is banned in Tunisia - a Muslim country.

"In my humble opinion the wearing of the Burka is totally offensive and not the woman's choice at all in any realistic way,"

Sometimes it is, is the problem. If it genuinely never was, then I'd be for banning it but there are many women who choose the burka. I have no idea why but I'd defend their right to choose to do it, just as I'd defend their right to choose not to.

[i]So in order to protect women and ensure that they are free to choose what they should wear, certain items of clothing should be banned?

I'm surely not alone in detecting a slight trace of irony here.
[/i]

"Slight" is putting it mildly!

Ban the burka...? No way! I'd rather not see their mustachioed mugs anyway.

Ban the 'hoody'...? wash your mouth out, it's saved me from the cold and rain, slush, sludge, wind many a time after a long ride in a isolated exposed car-park!

There is no real reason to wear it.
Only if you want to escape the country !!

TheArtistFormerlyKnownAsSTR - Member

I wouldn't mind everyone being equal, if that equality could actually be realised.

Burkas? Fine, but could we go to a predominately Muslim country and wear mini-skirts?

Mosques? Fine, but could we go to a Muslim country and build a Church?

On the subject of Mosques - could we get planning permission from Sheffield City Council for an eyesore such as the monstrosity that adorns the streets of Heeley Bridge?

Whilst we're talking about Heeley Bridge - there seem to be dozens of taxi's and people carriers illegally parked unquestioned on a Saturday afternoon at prayer time, yet if I park half a wheel at the football ground around the corner in the wrong place I get a ticket?

Everyone's welcome in my eyes, but equality shouldn't mean bending over backwards to accomodate.

Apologies if I'm way off the mark, just an opinion.

Not off the mark, pretty much my view too. There was an interesting debate on the radio yesterday where a medical bod said that the incidence of rickets was quite common amongst women who do the full cover up thing. The burka and niqaab have no basis in religion whatsoever. If you bother to look at the Koran it states modesty for women *[b]and[/b]* men. The interpretation is cultural.

There was an interesting debate on the radio yesterday where a medical bod said that the incidence of rickets was quite common amongst women who do the full cover up thing.

a lack of viatmin D is also a problem (and a cause of rickets in later life because the breast feeding mother didn't get enough of it (viatim D) during the birth and whilst breast feeding)

slighty unrelated, but....

i remember something similar where a MP stood up in parliment to talk about the higher than average number of incidents in their constituency where children were born with defects related to inbreeding. the cause was the number of arranged marriages amongst family members - marrying cousins or uncles and so on.

Alpin nice link of piccy made me chuckle - so you approve of Burkhas for fat mingers?

Burkas? Fine, but could we go to a predominately Muslim country and wear mini-skirts?

Mosques? Fine, but could we go to a Muslim country and build a Church?

depends on the country you could in Turkey, Egypt, Indonesia and I assume others. Out of interest I never knew cross dressing meant that much to you .. I am sure you have the legs for it 😉
You think there are no churches in Muslim countries- there are if there are Christians - Mohammed from Koran iirc says they have to show respect to all followers of the book iirc - forget the exact quote but they respect Christians again Churches in Egypt, Turkey 600 + in Iran etc.
So the answer would be yes to both your questions depending on the Muslim country.

If you go to a meal at a veggies house and dont eat meat do they have to eat meat at yours?. You dont smoke in a non smokers house do they have to smoke in yours? Essentially we dont have rules about what women wear - the wearing of the Burkha or the bikini does not violate liberalism as the clothes are their choice. If western liberal tolerance is a better way of life then perhaps we sould practcie it when people excercise choices we would not want to excercise or agree with or we look like hypoctits?

I am sure Muslim women are touched that predominately middle ages white men are telling them what they can and cannot wear in an attempt to free them from the oppression of men ...makes a lot of sense that does.

based on the rationale that the burka is to prevent men having impure thoughts about women, shouldn't muslim men wear one to stop the women have impure thoughts?

fackit - you're either a poor troll or a great ****tard

Alpin nice link of piccy made me chuckle - so you approve of Burkhas for fat mingers?

perhaps capital punishment would be more appropriate.

That is a tough one. The french government is clearly a rascist one. Not a shadow of a doubt about that (after all le grand nicola has been elected stealing the voices from the far right wing). However I am not sure how many women freely choose to wear a burka, may they be brain washed, bullyed or forced into it. Then burka is already banned in school and administration. I can't see if banning the burka will help or not. Since the last election it's getting even harder to be a muslim or to have a darker shade of skin in France. At the moment I am not for the ban. The actual law works just fine (no religious sign in school/administrations).

'tribal chief' yer just a pathetic ****

So what happened to choice?

If a woman wants to wear a burka then that's fine by me. I wouldn't condemn a nun for wearing a headscarf, nor would I judge a bloke in a skullcap.

The reasons why a woman might elect to wear a burka however is a different issue. Some women do it as an expression of faith, others do so because their or their family background demands it.

How does one tell the difference between someone wearing a burka willingly, or whether they're doing so under intimidation?

How does one tell the difference between someone wearing a burka willingly, or whether they're doing so under intimidation

[i]So what happened to choice?

If a woman wants to wear a burka then that's fine by me. I wouldn't condemn a nun for wearing a headscarf, nor would I judge a bloke in a skullcap.[/i]

+1. The only exception to this should be a grown man wearing a football shirt, if they're not actually playing a game.

AndyP, +1.

You've obviously been to Newcastle Airport during holiday season!

So in order to protect women and ensure that they are free to choose what they should wear, certain items of clothing should be banned?

I'm surely not alone in detecting a slight trace of irony here.

+1

Ban them they are provocative and they know it, it always amuses me how you see women with Islamic face veils shopping in M&S as I have never seen Burka for sale in there and as its a Jewish owned store I thought muslims are banned from shopping there or against its against islam.

I am with TJ on this one.
Junkyard's argument is pretty good, but there IS pressure put on women to wear one.If they are banned,then that is gone.I don't mind Burka wearing as a nod to somebodies culture, I do mind it when it is used to judge a woman's morality by her peers...Or escape the clutches of the law having just attempted to blow up loads of innocent people.The point made about France being secular is correct, but it is more about forcing people to dress like a French woman (1950's dress,string of onions)by removing a symbol of religious identity.

[i]The french government is clearly a rascist one. Not a shadow of a doubt about that (after all le grand nicola has been elected stealing the voices from the far right wing)[/i]

Nicola Sarkozy came to power because bourgeoise Ségolène Royal didn't pay her ISF and lost credibility with her socialist supporters, and more importantly with those UDF voters that might otherwise have voted for her in the second round. The communist vote collapsed with the fall of the wall so there was only 4% to pick up there. For most people it was a case of damage limitation and choosing the candidate least likely to damage an already fragile economy with an ever more tentacular state strangling the private sector and tax payer. For the record I voted for Sarkozy and have no regrets.

Accusations of racism will backfire on the accusers. We are intelligent enough to know the difference between describing behaviour/dress as socially unacceptable and racisme. A person in a burkka could be anyone, male, female, outlaw... .

I wouldn't ban them, will cause more problems than it is worth, and then those poor cows that have to wear them will be banned from leaving their husband/fathers house. Not progress...

Think about the Taxi films. Whether the baddies are Ninjas or Father Christmasses they have their faces covered. You can't go into a French supermarket or bank with motorcycle helmet on (they even take my bike helmet in Leclerc). Covering your face says "up to no good" to many including me.

In Germany covering your face in demonstrations has be illegal since 1985.