Forum search & shortcuts

Formula 1 2024 - WI...
 

Formula 1 2024 - WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS

Posts: 14179
Full Member
 

Looks like Andretti/GM are finally getting the green light too for 2026...

https://www.motorsport.com/f1/news/gm-closing-in-on-2026-f1-entry-after-andretti-exit/10675255/


 
Posted : 22/11/2024 11:56 am
pondo and pondo reacted
Posts: 12428
Full Member
 

Looks like Andretti/GM are finally getting the green light too for 2026…

Two things:
Michael Andretti seems to have annoyed the other teams so badly that him leaving was a non-negotiable demand. Sad because you would imagine that the Andretti name would be very attractive for marketing the sport in the U.S.

Donald Trump has just been reelected as President. The DOJ was drawn into investigating F1 for limiting competition by excluding Andretti. It was bogus IMO but a Trump led DOJ could harass F1 into leaving North America. Much cheaper to just agree to let a GM team in. My feeling is that they will be lucky to equal Toyota's results, fools and their money...


 
Posted : 22/11/2024 3:04 pm
Posts: 14179
Full Member
 

I think Audi will be a bigger embarrassment - they just don’t seem committed at all. So many flip-flops in direction and they own the ruddy team already!

Andretti is like a dog with a bone though, really going for it.


 
Posted : 22/11/2024 6:54 pm
chrismac and chrismac reacted
Posts: 13607
Full Member
 

Both GM and Ford have had amazing racing results over the years when they commit to it. However they are both companies who's business is shifting tin boxes to the masses and if the numbers don't add up, or they think they have achieved the key measures of success, they have no romantic, philosophical or any other type of commitment and will close the whole thing down.

I suspect that GM will be extremely committed for the first year or so and then be totally results and reward driven. The Andretti team are far more racers and race driven so committed to the racing. If they get in, they will stay in. Even if this means switching engine suppliers later.


 
Posted : 22/11/2024 11:25 pm
Posts: 12428
Full Member
 

Oh dear, Lawson knocks Perez out in Q1.


 
Posted : 23/11/2024 7:28 am
Posts: 13647
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Oh dear, Lawson knocks Perez out in Q1

i know, it’s getting quite painful to watch. Tsunoda way up in the top ten too, I can’t imagine Perez will be there next but I wonder who will replace him


 
Posted : 23/11/2024 12:59 pm
Posts: 1257
Free Member
 

Reporting that buying Perez out of his seat will cost RB $20M.

He has a big incentive to keep being crap.


 
Posted : 23/11/2024 6:02 pm
Posts: 1752
Full Member
 

Have just been listening to the race commentary on BBC website, and for some reason it's gone over to adverts for drum n' bass!!! FFS


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 8:05 am
Posts: 35298
Full Member
 

Good race, congrats to Max.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 9:22 am
thols2, bruneep, thols2 and 1 people reacted
Posts: 12428
Full Member
 

I think Max has dispelled the theory that his championships were only because he had a dominant car. Next year's going to be interesting, if Merc can find some consistency, we might have four teams in the fight.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 9:32 am
nickc and nickc reacted
Posts: 35298
Full Member
 

Aye, 7 different winners this year despite Max's early run of wins. looking good for next year if the racing's as mixed up as that. Really pleased for Russell though.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 10:09 am
Posts: 2102
Free Member
 

Great race, well done Mercedes & Max.  Been a good season overall - unusual that you couldn't tell who would be quick from week to week.

Cack from Checo again.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 11:49 am
nickc and nickc reacted
Posts: 21040
 

I’m looking forward to finding out how George’s pole to flag win wasn’t actually that good.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 11:55 am
Posts: 27603
Free Member
 

God, the Rolls Royce procession really is an unneeded tacky thing we could do without.  Driver of the day for a Lewis thoroughly deserved.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 12:54 pm
Posts: 5054
Full Member
 

Yeah the Rolls Royce procession was a bit odd.
‘Let’s just drive them round in luxury cars. With tinted windows so no body can see them’


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 1:08 pm
Posts: 1257
Free Member
 

I think Max has dispelled the theory that his championships were only because he had a dominant car.

Has he?

He had by far the quickest car in the first part of the season.

It only faded after Newey left after the boss sent dick pics around. It doesn't look like the constructors will go to RB as the 2nd driver is not performing.

If that was Ferrari the money men would have a new broom through the place.

As it's a marketing company for a gruesome fizzy drink, expect the same next year.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 1:12 pm
pondo and pondo reacted
 igm
Posts: 11889
Full Member
 

On that Monaco stuff, given everyone likes the qualifying, but the race is a bit processional, how about…

1. Scrap the qualifying - no, reallly, stick with me.
2. Scrap the race - wait for it…

3. Replace it with a 10 lap, perhaps 15, team time trial.

Head off in reverse team championship order, rolling start, time starts on first car crossing line, finishes on second car.
If a team bin it they’re ranked on how far they got, not the time.
Identical driver points based on the team’s position.
Perhaps the combined normal points of 1st & 2nd to the first team, then 3&4, and so on.

Different from normal racing, might suit Monaco, great PR photos, and not really that contrived (like DRS, or joker lap routes, etc)


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 4:23 pm
Posts: 10976
Full Member
 

Different from normal racing

Sounds a lot like single lap quali and that was a disaster in so many ways.

And Max's win this year has some echoes of the 2009 season - have a substantial car advantage at the start of the year and build a buffer which gets eroded as the other teams catch up.  I really hope nobody (well, none of the top 4) make a major step for 2025 - I've enjoyed the ebb and flow in the performance of RB, Ferrari, Merc and McLaren depending on the circuit and conditions.  It'd be great if one of the other teams could catch them up, but think even a newly Newey'd Aston will struggle, Williams are still building to 26, Alpine are just all over the place, SAudiber likewise, VCARB won't be allowed to compete with RB and Haas are amazed that anyone's slower than them this year so will be happy enough if that doesn't change.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 5:17 pm
Posts: 14293
Free Member
 

I think Max has dispelled the theory that his championships were only because he had a dominant car.

Really .... how?

He seemed pretty average today.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 5:55 pm
pondo, Keando, Keando and 1 people reacted
Posts: 14179
Full Member
 

He seemed pretty average today.

He just did what he needed to do today - even letting Lewis pass without any silly games! 🙂

Expect elbows-out Max to be back for the last two races!

Good race though, certainly worth getting up for.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 6:49 pm
thols2, nickc, thols2 and 1 people reacted
Posts: 4374
Full Member
 

 Scrap the race

That's all that is required. The rest is just a compromise to keep it on the calendar. The sooner it gets consigned to history the better. The current and for the foreseeable future cars are just too big for it to work as a venue.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 7:07 pm
Posts: 14293
Free Member
 

He just did what he needed to do today

Agreed [but even an idiot wouldn't have risked anything], but that has nothing to do with

I think Max has dispelled the theory that his championships were only because he had a dominant car.

He's going to have a lot more on his plate next year.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 7:10 pm
Posts: 14179
Full Member
 

Next year will be a weird one. Teams that will do sod all on their 2025 cars as their sole focus will be 2026…

• Haas

• Alpine

• Williams

• Aston

• Sauber/Audi

• RB

Red Bull, Ferrari, Merc and McLaren have the basics of decent 2025 cars anyway. And one of them may chance chucking a bunch of cash at next season to try and steal championships while the others have half an eye on 2026.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 7:19 pm
Posts: 18077
Full Member
 

God, the Rolls Royce procession really is an unneeded tacky thing we could do without.

Quite appropriate for Las Vegas, the home of tacky things.

Anyway, yesterday I was wondering if Ferrari would be kicking themselves for signing Lewis. Today, I'm sure they won't be.


 
Posted : 24/11/2024 10:54 pm
Posts: 9131
Free Member
 

I think Max has dispelled the theory that his championships were only because he had a dominant car.

He's very difficult to judge. He was pretty even with Sainz and Riciardo. Checo appears to have lost his mojo the last couple of years and Albon and Gasly were almost rookies who weren't given time to get the hang of things.

He is the only world champ not have been teammates with another world champ (Jones/Hunt slightly contrived)

Very difficult to judge how good he is, compared to say, a Hamilton who we can compare to Alonso, Button and Rosberg.

Definitely has an attitude problem, but then races like Brazil are true champion's drives.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 1:12 am
Posts: 24446
Free Member
 

Isn't this technically his second championship on merit plus the one gifted and one paid for with buffet sandwiches?


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 1:31 am
vlad_the_invader, pondo, Kryton57 and 9 people reacted
Posts: 2022
Full Member
 

Anyone thinking that Checo overtaking two cars at one corner is enough to secure a drive for next year?

Me neither....


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 2:58 am
Posts: 2034
Full Member
 

Don't think Checo can really be bothered. Would you want to drive for a team wholly focused on the evil one?

He will never keep a win if, Vestaphen is behind him.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 8:25 am
Posts: 27603
Free Member
 

It’s interesting to know just how much difference the car makes.  I’m watching the Brawn series - notable how pre double diffuser additions to red bull  the Brawn was immediately uncompetitive in the wet and Red Bull surged in those conditions.     Yet who’s the better driver - Button or Webber?

It’s a game of such fine margins, see a suddenly dominant Mercedes this weekend, which even they report to not knowing why.

I suspect the drivers are within very tiny decimals of percentage difference on ability.  Verstappen brought the fear of “Crashstappen” to the game to bully his way through on top of a dominant car and made a change to F1 that way… …before this years finer margins and penalties tempered that a little.

We await to see if someone finds a revelation in 2026, but as above for 2025 i suspect most has been wrung out of the cars with the top teams unwilling to risk current performance for a risky innovation.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 9:06 am
Posts: 35298
Full Member
 

Anyway, yesterday I was wondering if Ferrari would be kicking themselves for signing Lewis. Today, I’m sure they won’t be.

I'm sure Ferrari are going to be happy, but after their frankly woeful off-track performance  on Sunday - that probably cost a podium place,  I can't imagine that Hamilton is massively impressed.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 10:35 am
Posts: 14179
Full Member
 

Isn’t this technically his second championship on merit plus the one gifted and one paid for with buffet sandwiches?

There is of course the asymmetric braking technical directive which coincided with Red Bulls sudden decline. So he's maybe got x1 WC! 🙂


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 10:39 am
towpathman, pondo, pondo and 1 people reacted
Posts: 590
Free Member
 

2 races left, plenty still to fight for....

1) Can Ferrari overturn McLaren for the constructors

2) Can Leclerc overturn Lando for the runners up spot

3) Will Perez finally be allowed to win a race 😉


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 10:56 am
Posts: 27603
Free Member
 

4) Will Mercedes performance collapse again


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 12:03 pm
Posts: 35298
Full Member
 

I think rather than collapse, I think we're seeing very track specific performance from each of the teams, look at how badly (relatively) McLaren did yesterday for example.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 12:09 pm
Posts: 9131
Free Member
 

Isn’t this technically his second championship on merit plus the one gifted and one paid for with buffet sandwiches?

There is of course the asymmetric braking technical directive which coincided with Red Bulls sudden decline. So he’s maybe got x1 WC!

I think that's the problem. Regardless of how good he is his titles will always be tainted, much like Schumacher for instance, it's likely there was a lot of cheating going on in the Benneton days and so, IMO, he's not an equal to Hamilton, even if he is by number of titles. I think Verstappen will have the same problem, 2021 isn't any more valid than 1994 for example


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 12:13 pm
Posts: 12428
Full Member
 

I have no doubt that Verstappen will be remembered as one of the greats, just like Schumacher. Both of them are difficult to like but nobody seriously doubts their skill behind the wheel. 2021 was one of the greatest championship battles ever. Yes, it ended in a farce but Verstappen would still have gone down as a great driver even if he had lost that championship. This year he maximized the performance of a difficult and often unpredictable car. Perez is a decent driver when he has a decent car but he was made to look hopeless by Verstappen this year. The victory in Brazil sealed the title, that was a race that Max really had no business winning, it really was a superb drive. Norris had a car capable of winning the title but he just wasn't quite at the same level as Max. I'm pretty sure that Alonso or Hamilton at their best would have taken the title in this year's McLaren (and Verstappen too).


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 12:31 pm
nickc and nickc reacted
 Bez
Posts: 7445
Full Member
 

There’s always a fine line between exploiting loopholes and cheating. Much as I don’t find Red Bull’s general behaviour endearing, I don’t believe they’re cheats in the way that more than one of Flav’s teams were. I think the thing about Verstappen’s racing is how he responds on track when the pressure is really on. He teeters on the edge of Schumacher’s tactics—and for me, Schumacher’s legacy is absolutely tainted in a way that almost no other truly great driver’s is. (OK, Senna had Suzuka ‘90 but that’s an outlier.) I can’t imagine Verstappen would ever park up at Rascasse, but I don’t think it’d be inconceivable that he would consider torpedoing a championship rival if he felt that was his only chance.

Unexpectedly enjoyable race at the Spiderpig Speedway, though—no shortage of action. I’d thought Fred had dealt with the Ferrari strategy gremlins but apparently not. I really hope they get their ducks in order for next year; they’ll need to. Could be a big year for them.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 1:59 pm
multi21, thols2, nickc and 3 people reacted
Posts: 532
Full Member
 

Kryton57Full Member
4) Will Mercedes performance collapse again

Russell apparently said the reason they were so fast is a combination of a very efficient rear wing, cool track & smooth surface let them get the car into the window which is to be run very low and very stiff.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 3:53 pm
Posts: 12428
Full Member
 

Mark Hughes' analysis of why Merc dominated:
https://www.the-race.com/formula-1/mark-hughes-extreme-factors-behind-mercedes-vegas-domination/

Basically, the perfect track and weather conditions for Merc, the worst for McLaren. Merc will need to make their car work over a much wider range of conditions if they want to win titles next year, so will Red Bull. But, they will all have learned a lot from this year so hard to predict much beyond any of the top four teams might win next year.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 4:03 pm
 Bez
Posts: 7445
Full Member
 

cool track & smooth surface let them get the car into the window which is to be run very low and very stiff

It’s about 30 years since I studied fluid dynamics (and to be honest most of the fluids I was studying at the time came in pint glasses) but the thing that strikes me about that is that I’d confidently reckon that would be the easiest set of parameters to model accurately. It really reinforces the idea that at least one key to cracking the modern ground effect regulations was to understand the complex relationship between the suspension and the airflows, and by implication the notion that Newey understood that relationship more clearly and more quickly than anyone.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 7:11 pm
Posts: 6581
Free Member
 

Looks like there will be 11 teams in 2026...

https://adamcooperf1.com/2024/11/25/f1-confirms-agreement-for-gm-cadillac-to-be-11th-team-in-2026/


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 7:26 pm
 Chew
Posts: 1348
Free Member
 

Unsure what to make of it.

Its good to have another team on the grid, but it feels like 2000's when loads of manufacturers entered as constructors, only to leave a few years later when they worked out that they couldnt win against the big 4 "independents".

Seems like F1 had their hand forced by the threat of US competition laws, but as a compromise the Andretti connection had to be dropped.


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 9:47 pm
Posts: 2102
Free Member
 

Chew

Seems like F1 had their hand forced by the threat of US competition laws, but as a compromise the Andretti connection had to be dropped.

Indeed, but also they don't want Andretti making a car outside of the restrictions.

https://bsky.app/profile/rorymitchellf1.bsky.social/post/3lbs6a6lkek23


 
Posted : 25/11/2024 11:05 pm
Posts: 1752
Full Member
 

Monza has had a stay of execution for a couple of weeks.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/formula1/articles/czd56e6r9epo


 
Posted : 28/11/2024 10:26 am
Posts: 9227
Full Member
 

"We are all aware that history is no longer enough."

That's so sad. 🙁


 
Posted : 28/11/2024 10:45 am
brian2 and brian2 reacted
Page 70 / 73