Forum menu
EU Referendum - are...
 

[Closed] EU Referendum - are you in or out?

 DrJ
Posts: 13939
Full Member
 

The idea that the reorganisation of the UK economy, and our arrangements with the rest of the world, will be “over” anytime soon is a fantasy.

True enough - could be a long sleep 🙁 But really, I'm just tired of thinking about it! MissusJ is a damned forriner so her status post March 29 is not certain, so it could be bad news for us, still - I can't take any more of the endless bull-dust 🙁


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:05 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

Corbyn's fine line… enabling Brexit and damaging his party, and the lives of those who voted for him… while holding onto his position just long enough to win one election after Brexit… when he can then try and undo some of the damage he wished upon us all, before the regrouped Tories come back with Thatcherism on steroids. Get your thank you cards ready to send…


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:10 pm
 MSP
Posts: 15842
Free Member
 

He doesn’t have to tread the fine line that Corbyn does

Corbyn does not have to tread a fine line, he has chosen his path, it has not been forced upon him, in fact he is opposing the labour party memberships wish for a second ref.

I am quite tired of people trying to wish upon May and Corbyn some kind of Machiavellian scheming, when it is quite clear they are both incompetent and dysfunctional.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:10 pm
 DrJ
Posts: 13939
Full Member
 

Corbyn’s fine line… enabling Brexit and damaging his party, and the lives of those who voted for him… all while holding onto his position just long enough to win one election after Brexit… when he can then try and undo some of the damage he wished upon us all. Get your thank you cards ready to send…

This plus a zillion. Except that it now is clear that enabling Brexit will cost him even that election, as the under-35s who had been optimistic voters last time desert in droves.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:13 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

But if we leave at the end of march with no deal, won’t a hard border be there by default?

Thing is, will it be a real hard border or a paper hard border?

On our side of the border there is no infra-structure, and not enough Customs or Border Force staff to enforce it.

I can't imageine that on April 1st there will suddenly be thousands of uniforms , (complete with Cyril Blakey moustaches and clip boards), physically stopping lorries until they have completed a full paper customs declaration and goods examination.

I have a feeling that in the event of a no deal, there won’t be a real hard border on our side, for the short term at least. I doubt there will be one on the EU side either, for the same reasons.

Practical considerations will beat all the politicking.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:18 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

Yip. I think the scales have now fallen from the eyes of all but the most terminally deluded with regard to Corbyn. Restoring democracy to the party, my arse! He's not the remotest interest in representing anyones views but his own. And he's a rabid brexiteer. Always was, always will be

Unless theres a radical change of course, we're heading for a hard Brexit, entirely enabled by Corbyn as well as May, and the labour party will be held just as accountable for the resulting chaos.

Corbyn won't do the honourable thing though. He'll cling on and lead the party to be wiped out at the next election. I really can't see anything else other than an exodus of MPs and the disintigration o the Labour party. Lets face it, its been on the cards since the day that muppet accidentally got elected leader


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:20 pm
Posts: 91159
Free Member
 

I am quite tired of people trying to wish upon May and Corbyn some kind of Machiavellian scheming, when it is quite clear they are both incompetent and dysfunctional.

I'm not crediting them with scheming - I'm saying they are both boxed in by Brexit voters (not party members). If they were good at scheming they'd find a way to get their way whilst not pandering to voters. They are both in impossible positions. Only difference is it's May's fault for both of them.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:20 pm
 DrJ
Posts: 13939
Full Member
 

A tweet from someone or other:

Labour HQ clearly a bit panicked by reaction from MPs/ members to Brexit letter - am hearing a letter from Jeremy Corbyn will be sent out to members shortly that makes clear a second referendum *is* still on the table, as per party policy.

Nobody cares about your freakin' table any more Corbyn !!!


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 1:36 pm
Posts: 1635
Free Member
 

Im not a Corbyn fan boi/apologist by any stretch but some of the knee jerk vehement reaction to his move today doesn't sit easily with me. It could actually be deeply pragmatic and tactical, this comment from Guardian live put it best:

Corbyns offer is pretty timely and smart. It closes the 'Labour will reject any deal' excuse May pulls up constantly, hardens Europe towards giving May a larger straw and allows Labour to open up the other options on the table once she rejects this, including the centrists love the 'peoples vote'. That re-run can only be a final option for Labour once others are rejected, surely even the hardest remainer sees this, unless you all want civil disobedience on your home streets and the MSM burn the idea down before it flies. Some Labour 'supporters' here seem unable to see this. Many I suspect have never voted Labour in their lives though!


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 2:13 pm
 Del
Posts: 8274
Full Member
 

Union poll shows 'backing Brexit would be worse for Labour than Iraq invasion' - ITV News


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 2:17 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

while holding onto his position just long enough to win one election after Brexit…

Not a snowballs chance in a CAT scanner. He had his chance in '17, they'd like to believe that his better than expected result (they still lost of course) was due to a Youth uprising and how as older, more Tory included boomers die and more young people get to vote he'll do better last time. Sadly, it's not true, post-election stats show that in actual fact he was boosted by millions of disenchanted 'New' Labour voters, who, when it came to it, couldn't vote elseware or stay away.

I know personally I was promised by our local Labour rep that they would fight Brexit and felt duty bound to offer the public a second vote based on facts and not promises, so I voted for them, I won't be fooled again and I doubt I'm alone.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 2:20 pm
Posts: 17999
Full Member
 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-47152035

"Theresa May and Jean-Claude Juncker have described their talks on changing the Brexit deal as "robust but constructive", in a joint statement".

"The two leaders agreed to meet for further talks before the end of February".

Can kicked further down the street then?


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 2:33 pm
Posts: 34479
Full Member
 

mickmcd

Member
https://amp.ft.com/content/7beae1d2-2a39-11e9-a5ab-ff8ef2b976c7

Very disturbing

Posted 5 hours ago REPLY | REPORT
molgrips

Subscriber
Paywall. What’s it say?

It says that so far Liam Fox has only managed to agree FTA rollovers with Israel, chile & the Faroe islands, continuity deals with otswana, Lesotho, Mozambique, Namibia, South Africa and Swaziland-South & East African Trade partnership, mutual recognition with NZ & Aus & nearly with Switzerland- which is about 5% of the deals we have via the EU right now.

Even if May gets a deal through there could be huge gaps in the supply chains, to which SME could be particularly vulnerable, but the government are refusing to release details of exactly which deals they will have in place

who couldve guess that DFDS Liam fox wouldve have been so utterly incomeptent


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 2:40 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

STW USERS WANT THEIR PRIVACY STROKED AND WILL MAKE SURE WE HAVE IT TOO

Almost, but not quite, completely correct, in my case...

🤔🤯😱🤗🥳

Carry on.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 2:42 pm
 MSP
Posts: 15842
Free Member
 

I’m saying they are both boxed in by Brexit voters (not party members)

They have both boxed themselves in pandering to brexit voters misconceptions and lies. And they are continuing to do so, neither is showing any willingness to "do right by the country" instead they are still stoking up the anti eu fantasies, completely ignoring reality, just on a quest for personal power. They are so entrenched into their lies and fantasies that they are refusing to see the clear options available to them.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:00 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

post-election stats show that in actual fact he was boosted by millions of disenchanted ‘New’ Labour voters, who, when it came to it, couldn’t vote elseware or stay away.

Seems obvious to me. But then, that was me. But some of the "new" support (including mine) was because of a manifesto that was head and shoulders above the manifestos presented by the other parties… except on Brexit… but even then, in seats where it was a straight run off between Tory and Labour, the Tory policy still looked worse. The idea that those "new" voters supported Brexit because they voted Labour (80% supported Brexit lie) is what annoys me most, and is often trotted out by Labour MPs, sadly.

Still … I'm off to read more David Lammy speeches to stay sane…


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:01 pm
 dazh
Posts: 13385
Full Member
 

I’m saying they are both boxed in by Brexit voters

This. Funny that now Corbyn is offering an olive branch to May everyone is howling. I hate to say it, but all of you going mental about what is basically a sensible approach to delivering a soft brexit, are basically just pissed off because you've finally realised brexit isn't going to be cancelled. Brexit is happening, get used to it. Whether it's in no-deal, hard or soft form is still to be seen, but you really need to take your heads out of the sand.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:07 pm
Posts: 12649
Free Member
 

You are always missing the point that the further away from power you are, the plainer you can speak.

Yep, which is why all the armchair opposition leaders on this thread would be out within a week.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:16 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

all of you going mental about what is basically a sensible approach to delivering a soft brexit

Corbyn wants Brexit. And he doesn't want "soft Brexit"… he whipped against staying in the Customs Union and against EEA. The only line he is treading is keeping gullable fools believing he is just be being pragmatic, while seeking to inact policies he has espoused for decades. He wants, and is very likely to get, a hard Brexit with a transition period. Now, we can all accept that it is Labour who first proposed that we would need a transition period (May's rebranding if it as an implementation period was just her way of agreeing to it without rubbing her MPs & members up the wrong way) but what comes after it…? Hard Brexit with some unicorn dust sprinkled on it… those in the Labour Party suggesting a soft Brexit have been sidelined just as much as those suggesting we get another vote. They're sitting at the table… but it's over there, by the toilets, under that light that doesn't work.

You are always missing the point that the further away from power you are, the plainer you can speak.

People "further away from power" in the Labour Party are there BECAUSE they have spoken plainly on Brexit. It's not the other way around. The front bench has long since been purged of anyone suggesting either a soft Brexit and/or another vote, despite them speaking for their members, voters and constituencies.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:22 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

@slowoldman kicked onto a better path imo. They have now both agreed that the withdrawal agreement can't be re-opened so the backstop stays. In my mind, this basically means that ERG and DUP are stuffed and May has to compromise to get Labour on board to get her deal through.
I agree with DazH, peoples vote wont happen (and if it did i think the outcome would be bad) so a compromsie soft brexit is as good as we are goin to get.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:37 pm
 MSP
Posts: 15842
Free Member
 

Yep, which is why all the armchair opposition leaders on this thread would be out within a week.

At least some of us might try to lead, Corbyn is holding onto the title of leader without performing the duties that come with the title.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:38 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

He is leading. Some people just haven't woken up to how he is leading, and where to.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 3:45 pm
Posts: 2675
Full Member
 

I think Brexit of some form is inevitable and has been ever since the referendum result was announced. there has been momentum built around a 2nd ref but there hasn't ever been much love amongst Labour MPs ( and even less for the Tories)

Even if Labour had a whole hearted 2nd reffer as leader I don't think they would be able to command enough support in their party to have a hope of winning from a minority position in Parly. And they would be hammered in the popular press.

I'm getting a bit like DrJ - basically tired off it all and resigned to the inevitable and the shitty consequences that follow.

I'm going to another session with Hilary Benn in a couple of weeks - see what he has to say as chair of Brexit committee and a Labour MP. But I have a feeling it will just be depressing.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 4:10 pm
Posts: 17388
Full Member
 

I'm surprised that our govt is surprised that a powerful trading bloc that is going to be our competitor in a few weeks is starting to talk like a powerful competitor to a minor one.

What did they expect?

"Yes bwana" while knuckling the forelock?

Even greater humiliation awaits when they try negotiating with the USA without the EU behind them.

And Putin is pissing himself laughing...


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 4:20 pm
 MSP
Posts: 15842
Free Member
 

I hate to say it, but all of you going mental about what is basically a sensible approach to delivering a soft brexit, are basically just pissed off because you’ve finally realised brexit isn’t going to be cancelled.

I hate to break it to you, but the olive branch he offered includes staying in the customs union, yet he whipped his party against that very thing at a time when he could really have worked for a softer brexit. His olive branch isn't an offer to May, it is just another stunt to pull the wool over the eyes of his supporters, and it is surprising that they are still falling for such obvious trickery.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 4:36 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Is anyone else forming the impression that dazh might actually be a 'gillet jaune' incarnation of THM?


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 4:42 pm
Posts: 5708
Full Member
 

So Donald is telling a slightly different tale to TM...

https://twitter.com/eucopresident/status/1093535048454860800


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 4:48 pm
Posts: 2675
Full Member
 

Do people think that a 2nd reffer led Labour party would be able to win a 2nd ref vote in Parly. Or just that it would make a load of people feel less disenfranchised, give a better focus for protest and put Labour in a better position when the full Brexit shit storm hits?


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 4:49 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

One of those, yes. Either would been better than the deceit of the last year or so, wouldn't it?

It's gone past the point where a referendum is an option though… hasn't it?

[ don't mention the table ]


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 5:01 pm
Posts: 15555
Full Member
 

Well, Magic granddad may have come through, his letter to May seems to have met approval with the EU..

The European Parliament’s Brexit chief has welcomed Jeremy Corbyn’s new EU exit plan and endorsed calls for a cross-party conensus in Westminster to prevent a no-deal.

A permanent and comprehensive UK-wide customs union. This would include alignment with the union customs code, a common external tariff and an agreement on commercial policy that includes a UK say on future EU trade deals. We believe that a customs union is necessary to deliver the frictionless trade that our businesses, workers and consumers need, and is the only viable way to ensure there is no hard border on the island of Ireland. As you are aware, a customs union is supported by most businesses and trade unions.

Close alignment with the Single Market. This should be underpinned by shared institutions and obligations, with clear arrangements for dispute resolution.

Dynamic alignment on rights and protections so that UK standards keep pace with evolving standards across Europe as a minimum, allowing the UK to lead the way.

Clear commitments on participation in EU agencies and funding programmes, including in areas such as the environment, education, and industrial regulation.

Unambiguous agreements on the detail of future security arrangements, including access to the European Arrest Warrant and vital shared databases.

The only Labour test seemingly dropped is 'delivers the exact same benefits of EU membership.

By implication "A" CU & SM also means ECJ and FoM, plus continued contributions.

https://i.imgur.com/WVxOHPq.jpg


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 5:02 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

"By implication" suggests the use of logic… I admire your optimism… if either party leader says that FoM can continue… they have my support, it would open up the chance of a close relationship with the rest of Europe as a non-EU member… it's the compromise that should have been the centrepoint of a plan back in 2016, to respect a 52:48 result.

Oh, and you can "welcome" a contribution, without agreeing with it, or suggesting that it adds up to much.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 5:05 pm
 dazh
Posts: 13385
Full Member
 

Is anyone else forming the impression that dazh might actually be a ‘gillet jaune’ incarnation of THM?

Ha ha!. For the record I'd like nothing more than for the whole bloody thing to be cancelled but it doesn't change the reality that it's happening. We can either moan to eachother about how unfair it is that our middle class bubble has been punctured by a horde of white trash gammons, or we can actually address why they've felt the need to do so.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 5:06 pm
 MSP
Posts: 15842
Free Member
 

Did anyone read the guardian story about the "lead by donkeys" billboard campaign. I know it is a story that has been knocking around a few weeks now, but the bit that struck me, was that after raising the money to go nationwide, that the large advertising companies would not run their posters claiming they were too political. Th same companies that wee happy to run ukip propaganda about Romanians flooding into the UK, decided to draw the line at political accountability.

Just goes to show how the game is rigged, public school educated retired investment banker, no problem run any vile racist propaganda you want. Few working class blokes holding politicians to account, nah **** off and learn your place.

Thankfully some smaller companies are running the posters.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 6:42 pm
Posts: 28593
Free Member
 

Close alignment with the Single Market. This should be underpinned by shared institutions and obligations, with clear arrangements for dispute resolution.

SM alignment is not quite the same thing as SM membership. But probably as close as we can get without having to fully embrace FoM in future. But yes, would probably mean the dreaded ECJ (or some proxy) gets to oppress us from now on.

It's still a shit sandwich, but some of the shit has been mixed with artificial flavourings and colourings so it looks a bit nicer.

But, frankly, I think something along these lines will be as good as it gets for the UK. I don't support a 2nd ref, because frankly, I think the loons would win it again, and possibly by more, and outright remaining seems a remote possibility.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 6:53 pm
Posts: 91159
Free Member
 

I have actually been offered a new job within the global company for whom I currently work, which would be a worldwide role. It's a good job anyway, but I'm thinking that it's the best possible Brexit insurance I can currently get.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:01 pm
Posts: 34479
Full Member
 

We can either moan to eachother about how unfair it is that our middle class bubble has been punctured by a horde of white trash gammons, or we can actually address why they’ve felt the need to do so.

Any form of Brexit will be a pyhric victory for said gammons though.

Brexit has already stopped the Tories balancing the deficit, so their justification for austerity stays.
The next 5+? Years of trade talks will suck up all the focus of government, (who thinks brexiteers have a plan for the next phase beyond making money from kickbacks?) leaving the countrys actual problems to fester , with the poorest suffering the most.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:06 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

We can either moan to eachother about how unfair it is that our middle class bubble has been punctured by a horde of white trash gammons, or we can actually address why they’ve felt the need to do so.

But WHERE exactly could anyone with ‘more than a bit of a tan’ be deported to? Even leaving aside the fact that a lot of the people the gammons would like to deport were born here, it is still a difficult expectation to meet.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:12 pm
Posts: 16482
Full Member
 

kelvin

Subscriber
You mean wake you up once it’s started? Yes? The idea that the reorganisation of the UK economy, and our arrangements with the rest of the world, will be “over” anytime soon is a fantasy. We’re about to hit the “burn it down” stage that is just a starting point for a fight over what these countries are going to become. Just the starting point.

Utterly depressingly true.

There is going to be a costly fight in the years to come over which direction the UK heads. I predict the breakup of the UK for a start. This is largely an English issue imposed on the whole of the UK.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:29 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Corbyn won't win immediately after Brexit, last time a recession happened the British public voted for their own austerity. It'll happen again, swing voters will vote for cuts after the Tories scare them over ballooning public debt and the young will be angry with Corbyn. That will leave Corbyn with Northern voters who haven't been poached by UKIP and the inner London vote.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:32 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

Just reading on Twitter the predictable responses of the Corbyn fan club/labour membership to Owen Smiths interview today

It seems like they’re really revelling in making the Labour Party as absolutely and totallly unelectable as it was in 1980. And their messiah is certainly doing a great job on their behalf!

It’s like some mad political death cult


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:34 pm
Posts: 1347
Full Member
 

Yeah, Corbs is the Tories insurance policy for Brexit - that’s why they got him elected!

Always been suspicious how Corbs used the Stop the War campaign to get rid of Blair, and then they did F*** all to stop the carnage in Syria.  Almost as if he’s another one of Putins useful idiots.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:34 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Ha ha!. For the record I’d like nothing more than for the whole bloody thing to be cancelled but it doesn’t change the reality that it’s happening. We can either moan to eachother about how unfair it is that our middle class bubble has been punctured by a horde of white trash gammons, or we can actually address why they’ve felt the need to do so.

If you addressed the reasons why they are unhappy, they'd call you a libtard socialist.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:36 pm
Posts: 44720
Full Member
 

You guys are still forgetting half the Labour front bench and 100mps have said publicly they will vote against any attempts to delay or stop brexit. Corbyn is as boxed in as May by his own parliamentarians. No other labour leader could do anything different.

If Corbyn comes out for a second referendum he will lose any vote on it - thats clear. Tories would be whipped against it, a few would rebel. Labour would be whipped for it and dozens would rebel and half his front bench would resign including many of the so called moderates.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:48 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

Bowglie- same reason as he won’t condemn the regime in Venezuela as the oil-rich ‘socialist’ country crumbles into civil war, poverty and starvation.

My enemies enemy is my friend in Corbyn’s simplistic 1970’s worldview.

He’s a useful idiot for Putin, the hard right of the Tory party and all manner of other thoroughly unpleasant entities just through his sheer pig-headed stupidity


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:49 pm
Posts: 1347
Full Member
 

I wonder if one of the main problems in Britain is the right wing press, and until someone has the balls to say that they’re only supporting the Tories and Brexit so that their multimillionaire owners can keep avoiding paying tax...and dodge Leveson2.

Unfortunately, I can’t see any high profile opposition MP’s standing up and using parliamentary privelidge to call out the tax dodging bas***ds in the press and Tory party.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:50 pm
Posts: 1347
Full Member
 

He’s a useful idiot for Putin, the hard right of the Tory party and all manner of other thoroughly unpleasant entities just through his sheer pig-headed stupidity

Unfortunately for the country, I think you’re right.  I’ve always had the feeling that he’s just another pig-headed personality cult dictator that’ll have to be dragged kicking and screaming from the leadership.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 7:56 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

We wouldn’t have the problem of the likes of the Daily Mail if it wasn’t able to tap into a rich seam of ignorance, prejudice, self-righteousness, stupidity, racism, xenophobia and pettiness.

Unfortunately there is a rich seam of all the above to unite their fellow arseholes. And ultimately, that is what we are talking about here. Arseholes.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:09 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

Owen Smith on channel 4 news now saying Corbyn is enabling a xenophobic, nativist, racist right-wing Brexit that betrays every single Labour Party value

Bang on!

I hope this marks the beginning of the party membership finally seeing through Corbyn’s Brexiteer stance, his MPs growing a pair and doing something to stop it/him


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:12 pm
Posts: 44720
Full Member
 

NO chance of the labour MPs growing a pair - 100 of them are insisting that brexit goes ahead and half the front bench will resign if corbyn supports a second referendum or attempts to stop / delay brexit

If corbyn really wanted a hard brexit would he be pushing for this softest of soft leaves? Its the only position that he can carry most of his MPs along with.

Do you really want to see a labour party split with 100+ mps voting against the labour whiop if Labour propose a second referendum? Make no mistake - thats what would happen.

Its the spineless nincompops that are labour MPs that are the problem here


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:32 pm
Posts: 497
Free Member
 

dammit, its time we got organised and rebelled against this kind of shenanigins

lets go and form a protest queue in the great british tradition


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:35 pm
Posts: 31075
Free Member
 

I see Labour are polling really well again today.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:37 pm
Posts: 18590
Free Member
 

Always been suspicious how Corbs used the Stop the War campaign to get rid of Blair, and then they did F*** all to stop the carnage in Syria.

So what was leader of the opposition Corbyn supposed to do in Syria?

I hate to defend the clown but would rather reproach him for not doing things he could do than things he can't do.

Edit: caught out by the page lag again, this is now water under the bridge.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:49 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

Again... where are you getting these stats from about who will and won’t rebel/resign?

Jezza talks the talk, but when push comes to shove - every time - he whips his MPs to enable a hard Brexit


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:52 pm
 rone
Posts: 9783
Free Member
 

hate to say it, but all of you going mental about what is basically a sensible approach to delivering a soft brexit, are basically just pissed off because you’ve finally realised brexit isn’t going to be cancelled. Brexit is happening, get used to it. Whether it’s in no-deal, hard or soft form is still to be seen, but you really need to take your heads out of the sand

You speak absolute sense.

The hysteria on here rather than then pragmatism is bewildering.

I'm looking forward to the tiny centrist breakaway party of Owen Smith and the Yvette 'vote for more wars' cooper.

Good luck with that.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:53 pm
Posts: 2675
Full Member
 

Isn't there another thread about Corbyn specifically if you want to discuss Syria etc not just Brexit

May and her mates must be mighty relieved by the fact that Corbyn personally seems to be taking a large chunk of the blame for the Brexit disaster created and continuously mishandled by the Tories.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 8:54 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

half the Labour front bench

Because anyone publicly saying what needs saying about brexit has been kicked off the front bench. The Labour back benches is full of talented MPs ready to take their place in a shadow cabinet.

Corbyn is not in a corner, reluctantly supporting Brexit, he wants Brexit. Hard. Anyone supporting a Soft Brexit, or another vote, has been sidelined by his team. Portraying him as at the mercy of the very people he has chosen to surround himself with, because they won't question his approach, is grade A bullshit.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 9:25 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

At least two thirds of Labour MPs are strongly pro-remain. So where you get 100 of them resigning I’ve no idea

Feel free to enlighten me

Just about everyone outside the inner cabal/front bench think, correctly, that Corbyn is a brexiteer clown, so who’s going to resign?

Just seen on Channel 4 news that Tony Lloyd is shadow Northern Ireland Secretary. Who knew? Hear that? That really is the sound of the bottom of a barrel being scraped. Can’t be long before he runs out of similar minded 70’s relics to support his Brexit stance and surround himself with in his Islington echo chamber.

All his backbenchers think he’s a **** and can’t wait to see the back of him so they can try and drag the party back into the 21st century instead of 1973, and that includes being pro EU instead of being in some Bennite backwater


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 9:32 pm
Posts: 18590
Free Member
 

So back on tpic, May got nothing out of Junker, zilch. Which is exactly what he was mandated by the 27 to give her. The only stuff they're talking about is non-binding stuff outside the agreement(deal) offered and refused by parliament.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 9:35 pm
Posts: 17999
Full Member
 

lets go and form a protest queue in the great british tradition

Yes lets. After you.


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 9:50 pm
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

After you…


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 10:19 pm
Posts: 57300
Full Member
 

No... after you....


 
Posted : 07/02/2019 10:46 pm
Posts: 66093
Full Member
 

binners

Subscriber

Owen Smith on channel 4 news now saying Corbyn is enabling a xenophobic, nativist, racist right-wing Brexit that betrays every single Labour Party value

Someone should remind Owen Smith he tried to bring down Corbyn before, got his ass absolutely whipped, then instantly declared that they were bezzie mates. Still, he's one step ahead of Chuka Umanna, forever throwing peanuts but too scared to ever get on the stage.

AFAIC Corbyn actually did something very smart here. He's extended a reasonable offer that May won't and can't take, because her own party would eat her. It's pretty close to what he's demanded before- but moved enough that it's a compromise so people can't reasonably claim any more that he's refusing to negotiate. And it means that May's going to back to parliament and insist hers is the only possible deal (again) and can't be improved (again) while there's a better proposal right there in front of her that she's refused and that her own nutters won't accept.

And when it does go back to the commons, obviously one of the big risks is that people do panic and vote for May's shitty brexit out of fear of May's even shittier no-deal brexit. This puts another option on the table other than calling it all off- which means people can vote against May without instantly being put into the "no deal psycho" or "no brexit traitor" groups. Which imo is just 100% positive.

And also he's given the EU something to be visibily reasonable about at the exact point the ultras are claiming that Europe isn't listening. They can't accept it- they're not negotiating with him- so again no risk but it improves the visuals.

If there was any chance of May accepting his offer I'd say it was a terrible idea, but there isn't.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 12:37 am
Posts: 16198
Free Member
 

Owen Smith on channel 4 news now saying Corbyn is enabling a xenophobic, nativist, racist right-wing Brexit that betrays every single Labour Party value

As we all know, Owen Smith definitely represents the views of the membership.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 12:45 am
Posts: 15555
Full Member
 

A good analysis NW.. But the vice is tightening, there's very little room for the UK to manuvere now. That's both good and bad.. Good in that it will force our politicians to actually do something.
Bad in that no one knows what they might do with the in fighting in both parties as they are both broken and dysfunctional.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 12:50 am
Posts: 66093
Full Member
 

mattyfez

Member

A good analysis NW.. But the vice is tightening, there’s very little room for the UK to manuvere now.

TBH I don't think that's true- we can't maneouvre but not because there's no room, only because some idiot dropped the anchor in the wrong place. Nicely demonstrated by May's new demands being more or less laughed at, while Corbyn's comments get treated with more respect and seriousness despite him not even being in power,not because they're amazing but just because they're not basically moronic.

Also, neither of us can spell manuva.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 1:04 am
Posts: 44720
Full Member
 

Where do I get the hundred MPs that say they will vote against any delay? - publicly declared positions reported in many places. Same as the half the front bench will resign. Maybe less would when push comes to shove but there is no doubt there is a large swathe of labour MPs who believe the " will of the people " shtick

these are the folk who may be for remain but believe that their constituents will kick them out if they don't back leave.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 1:07 am
Posts: 17388
Full Member
 

It's all in the great British tradition of the Charge of the Light Brigade.

Only they're charging our own lines.

And all the casualties will be us.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 1:12 am
Posts: 15555
Full Member
 

I agree mostly but..

idiot dropped the anchor in the wrong place

It does not matter, the UK was never going to get a better deal than it already had.. So the placement of the anchor was, and still is, largely irrelevant.

.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 1:28 am
Posts: 31036
Full Member
 

half the front bench

'Half' of either, or both, of the front benches resigning is pretty much normal politics these days. Both leaders have survived that kind of 'manuva' by ministers and shadow ministers a few times already. The back benches are already full of people who have resigned or been fired over Brexit policy. More to come. Some you might even notice.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 1:34 am
Posts: 10944
Full Member
 

Huffington Post reporting on the US lobbyist's view of what they want from a future US-UK trade deal.

Lobbyists for big firms made more than 130 demands, which include:

  • Changing how NHS chiefs buy drugs to suit big US pharmaceutical companies
  • Britain scraps its safety-first approach to safety and food standards
  • Law changes that would allow foreign companies to sue the British state
  • Removal of protections for traditional British products.

https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/what-us-lobbyists-want-donald-trump-to-get-from-the-uk-in-a-post-brexit-trade-deal_uk_5c5b26c6e4b00187b5579f64?utm_hp_ref=uk-homepage

Just an example of what DFDS Liam would be up against.  He hasn't got a chance.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 9:24 am
Posts: 0
Full Member
 

We have a solution, a solution proposed by a staunch Brexit supporter here at work.

Pack your bags Scotland you are moving to Ireland and the Irish are moving to Scotland.

No border issues, except the Sea.

Off you trot..

🤣🤷‍♂️

And i’d say that’s a fairly typical attitude from a Beexiteer.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 9:27 am
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

We wouldn’t have the problem of the likes of the Daily Mail if it wasn’t able to tap into a rich seam raging flood of ignorance, prejudice, self-righteousness, stupidity, racism, xenophobia and pettiness.

FIFY


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 10:23 am
Posts: 34479
Full Member
 

Good analysis (if a little optimistic) of labours plans here http://www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2019/02/07/labour-s-new-brexit-policy-looks-an-awful-lot-like-norway-pl

My worry is that May will simply never go for it, which leaves everything unchanged & a choice of Mays deal Vs no deal.

As for DFDS fox, that huffpost is terrifying considering how desperately out of his depth he is, even worse in a no deal scenario where we would be so desperate for trade deals we'd be shafted by everyone.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 10:25 am
 DrJ
Posts: 13939
Full Member
 

My worry is that May will simply never go for it, which leaves everything unchanged & a choice of Mays deal Vs no deal.

This has been the plan since last year, IMO. At the last moment Labour will support it on the basis of some vague assurance that maybe at some point in the future the govt will perhaps consider doing something for the poor folk below stairs.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 10:34 am
Posts: 12522
Full Member
 

Huffington Post reporting on the US lobbyist’s view of what they want from a future US-UK trade deal.

And that, given the complete lack of control over US politicians being totally owned by lobby groups, is rather scary:

And what a position we'll be in to do a trade deal with the US that looks after UK interests. All the cards, they need us more they we need them, etc.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 10:46 am
Posts: 5708
Full Member
 

So a quick poll - who's the worst PM out of May & Thatcher?


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 11:29 am
Posts: 3322
Full Member
 

Cameron


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 11:32 am
Posts: 91159
Free Member
 

My worry is that May will simply never go for it

Does she have to though? Isn't there enough centre ground who'll go for it and get it through?


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 11:40 am
 piha
Posts: 729
Free Member
 

So a quick poll – who’s the worst PM out of May & Thatcher?

Corbyn


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 11:42 am
Posts: 4689
Full Member
 

May, Thatcher at least had a plan, no matter how heartless or destructive that was.


 
Posted : 08/02/2019 12:12 pm
Page 745 / 964