Forum search & shortcuts

Annual house insura...
 

Annual house insurance "head in hands" moment ...

Posts: 4919
Full Member
Topic starter
 
[#13534828]

It's that time of the year when the annual home insurance renewal quote has come in.

The quote is neigh on £1000 - an increase of £85 from last year.

We've lived where we are for 5 years and I've always thought the home insurance quotes for the house have been high, certainly higher than our previous home.

House is traditional build, no flat roofs, detached, not in a flood risk area, not in a crime hotspot etc. 

We have never made an insurance claim.

Every year I have asked our insurer (the insurer has varied over the years) if there are any "markers" on the property to substantiate the "high" premium and no one has ever said anything other than insurance is expensive 🙄 

Previous home owners had lived here for 40 plus years. I checked back through the original disclosures and there had been no home claims for flooding etc.

I don't think our insurance is covering much more than what now constitutes a "standard offer".

My folks, who have made a claim in the last year, have seen their premium increase but their renewal is less than £500 and their house is semi detached.

I appreciate I don't have to accept the premium increase and I could go down the MSM route but I'm not clear as to what I should really expect. 

It's just disheartening. 

 

 


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 1:21 pm
Posts: 1660
Full Member
 

If you're not trying to insure specific value contents (like bikes or jewellery) then spend 10mins with money supermarket creating an account and plugging your details in, and see where it gets you? You'll then have a kind of benchmark each year.
Have you checked your credit files to see if there's anything out of place?


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 1:29 pm
Posts: 4919
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Posted by: roger_mellie

If you're not trying to insure specific value contents (like bikes or jewellery) then spend 10mins with money supermarket creating an account and plugging your details in, and see where it gets you? You'll then have a kind of benchmark each year.
Have you checked your credit files to see if there's anything out of place?

 

Thanks RM. 

No issues with credit files.

 


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 1:30 pm
roger_mellie reacted
Posts: 14158
Full Member
 

Have you tried calling an insurance broker as well as the comparison sites?


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 1:41 pm
nicko74 reacted
Posts: 44846
Full Member
 

Just to make you feel better - my insurance for my flat ( all bells and whistles house and contents) slowly crept up to well over £1000 pa.  I have a week to get a new more reasonable policy


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 1:42 pm
Posts: 24883
Free Member
 

That's mad! I pay £23 a month = £276 including the premium for paying monthly.

3 bed semi, jewellery, bikes, electronics....

I thought when I read the start that the head in hands bit was going to be that you'd shopped around and realised that you'd been paying well over the odds and had 'wasted' thousands over the years, but you say that you've had various insurers. Have you been with a broker rather than a prime and they've 'shopped around' for you or are they your own efforts to have used different insurers.

Definitely shop around - that seems as I say mad, and Google confirms it

https://www.gocompare.com/home-insurance/how-much-does-home-insurance-cost/

 

and don't be disheartened, shopping for insurance is dullsville, but you might be about to put several hundred pounds in your pocket (and then be disheartened about the money you 'wasted' by not doing it sooner)

 


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 3:36 pm
Posts: 1796
Full Member
 

I use Confused as an annual comparison. It does specified items just fine.
Mine is under £500 for a platinum tier cover on a detached house (with some flat roof, bikes etc).
Mine has come down over the last 2 years but I've had to move to get that, but I've never gone with the cheapest.


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 3:44 pm
Posts: 46179
Full Member
 

Indeed you are paying the price for not seeking cheaper quotes. It's boring, but half an hour of work can put a lot of money back into your pocket.

Never renew back with same folk unless they genuinely match lower quotes and quality of cover.


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 3:48 pm
Posts: 21661
Full Member
 

Maybe it's time to start the insurance thread again to find out who's doing decent cover for a few nice bikes and what value they top out at.

M&S were silly last year but had us over a barrel. I believe that pedal over are back in the game after pricing themselves out for a few years.


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 3:48 pm
Posts: 2225
Full Member
 

Ours crept up over the years and when I finally looked into it I found what we were covering for contents value had gone up a silly amount. Quick call reduced it down and therefor the cost reduced. Great…no! The following year they just put the premium back up despite having reduced the contents value.


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 3:53 pm
Posts: 3657
Full Member
 

Posted by: letmetalktomark

The quote is neigh on £1000 - an increase of £85 from last year.

Were you expecting prices to be stable?

 


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 4:21 pm
MoreCashThanDash, scaredypants, wooobob and 3 people reacted
Posts: 888
Free Member
 

Be careful on reducing contents value - the sum total of your contents is often a lot more than you think.


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 4:24 pm
b33k34 reacted
Posts: 888
Free Member
 

On a slight thread hijack (and possibly contradicting my previous comment above), but a conundrum as to “what’s it worth?".  My MIL an engagement ring apparently worthy of its valuation for insurance purposes which was last put at £17K by a local jeweller.  MIL has passed away recently and the same jeweller has certified a probate value of a little over £3K, but then added that if Mrs BH wanted to sell it to them it probably wouldn’t fetch more then £500.  I know there is new for old, old for old and all that but this all feels a little cosy between jewellers and insurance companies


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 4:37 pm
Posts: 4919
Full Member
Topic starter
 

Thanks folks.

Just a bit more context.

With the exception of last year we have shopped around every year and have had 3 insurers over the last four years - the first year (in this house) was via a broker, second via my bank, third via a well respected national and we went with them again last year as the premium change was negligible.

I've had a chat with a broker today and it looks like we might have a few more options ticked re cover that is accentuating the costs. The insinuation was "you are paying for what you are getting (cover wise) but do you need all the options you have ticked?"

In our last house we always went via a broker but the annual sums were ~ half what we are seeing at the moment and so seemed less of an issue (this makes more sense in my head than reading it back!) 

I've got no expectations that costs won't continue to rise, as they always have, but nearly hitting a £1000 was a bit of a WTF moment. 


 
Posted : 20/03/2026 5:20 pm
Posts: 3657
Full Member
 

One thing that may be worth pointing out (as I've recently had to think about this) is that the value of your jewellery will likely have risen dramatically.

For example, I paid for an engagement ring in about 2005. The spot value of the platinum has tripled since. Gold is tenfold.

The value in my wife's ring (fnarr) was the stone; now it's the metal.

It's definitely worth a reappraisal and possible therefore listing stuff as specified items on your policy.


 
Posted : 18/04/2026 1:19 pm
Posts: 3501
Free Member
 

I’ve got named bikes and new for old cover etc and I was with M&S until they pulled the offer. Aviva direct was no where near as good and needed a lock that weighed as much as the bike carrying around in order to insure away from home. I have since discovered that AA do a policy nearly as good as the M&S one for not much more. Main difference is storm fence damage is not covered with AA but was with M&S. 


 
Posted : 19/04/2026 5:10 pm
Posts: 44846
Full Member
 

i shopped around.  tried specialist brokers.  £1400 for my flat.  most quotes £2000 and over.   Thats even with downgrading my bike cover.  2 bed flat with £25000 contents


 
Posted : 19/04/2026 5:17 pm
Posts: 12362
Full Member
 

Bloody hell, that's mad expensive! Is it a consequence of living in a flat? I.e. an electrical fault in yours burns down 5 others with all the associated costs. And what is building only insurance on your rental flat cost, is that also mega?


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 7:16 am
Posts: 12673
Free Member
 

Just make sure you never but a thatched cottage.  My insurance is £2600 a year with no additions at all.  No options to shop around as NFU are only insurer I would trust out of the 2 or 3 insurers available.  Yes, I choose to live in the cottage but only a few years ago it was well under £1000 to insure.  It is high for an obvious reason in that there are not that many thatched cottages relatively speaking and of those that exists they are much likely to burn down than a non thatched house.

Just posting to make some of you feel better 🙂


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 8:23 am
Posts: 44846
Full Member
 

tthew

 

top floor flats cost more because of the risks of water damage from the roof.   listed buildings cost more. ive had a stolen bike claim.  its a mixed use building that costs more

 

rental is 800 a year for a studio flat and i had to remove flood risk ( there is none and no liability either but insurance had it in a risk zone)


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 8:30 am
Posts: 33303
Full Member
 

Posted by: oceanskipper

needed a lock that weighed as much as the bike carrying around in order to insure away from home

I just accept that my bikes aren't covered if stolen away from home. Looking at comments on here, a couple of years premiums will cover the replacement cost. Dreading the renewal in June now.

 


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 8:42 am
Posts: 708
Full Member
 

Good grief 😲 I know costs vary across the UK but that is bonkers! 

For the same price, we have (super performance) car, van, detached house and bike cover. That’s also full business use on the car. I did shop around and the variation between insurers was a lot more than usual, with some being £3k plus… so definitely look around. We have everything with Admiral for info, just in case they work for you!


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 8:46 am
Posts: 6462
Full Member
 

Our house & contents renewal was £310, included bikes and stuff away from home up to total of £2.5k - max single item value £1k. Apart from the couple who always advertise their airport departures on Facebook and the over enthusiastic BBQ lighting by another neighbour I don't think there has been any claims in our postcode since we've been here.


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 9:01 am
Posts: 839
Free Member
 

Yikes, my renewal with Swinton went down recently, circa £300 with several named (e)bikes covered away from home if locked.  3 bed semi in Cambridge.


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 9:13 am
Posts: 7518
Full Member
 

Just to confirm, you can't stay with the same insurer. It's a mug's game, they know it and will rip you off. Fact.


 
Posted : 20/04/2026 9:53 am