[Closed] A Bridge too far- the best made war film ever?

Zulu
Empire of the Sun
Apocalypse Now
Platoon
Thin Red Line

Guns of Naverone always seemed a favour growing up, but I bet it looks naff now.

Went the day well

The Cruel Sea
My father was in the Royal Navy & took part in the Battle of the Atlantic. Like the Compass Rose his ship was torpedoed with large loss of life. He was picked up two days later.

Come and see - should be part of school curriculum... Brilliant film. Totally agree with fin25(?) on the first page.

Reach For The Sky
The Dam Busters
The Cruel Sea
Schindler's List
A Bridge Too Far
Where Eagles Dare
The Great Escape

Soviets in afghanistan.

The Beast

Inglorious basterds ranks right up there with Fury as probably the worse war films ever made imv and a stain on Brad Pitts career.

On the other hand I quite enjoyed Monuments Men.

Best war movie for me? Battle of Britain not least because half our sixth form were extras in it.

2 that haven't been mentioned which I love are hamburger hill, Vietnam film. And 9th company, soviets in Afghanistan.

My Uncle was at Arnhem he was in the Border regiment (Gliders) and his glider was the first on the ground at Arnhem their platoon commander was killed before they hit the ground, he fought around the Brickworks at Renkum and was eventually seriously wounded by a morter round. He was taken prisoner and a German Army surgeon cut the shrapnel out of his back with no anesthetic and probably saved his life - he was 22 years old. We have much to be thankful for.

[i]Inglorious basterds ranks right up there with Fury as probably the worse war films ever made [/i]

I like them both. Became trendy to slag them off, but both have some great scenes. Definitely not "worst ever made" I wouldn't think.

Not been mentioned but I founf Korengal really intense

Tough to see past Platoon. A masterpiece. Loved FMJ too.

DezB - Member
Inglorious basterds ranks right up there with Fury as probably the worse war films ever made
I like them both. Became trendy to slag them off, but both have some great scenes. Definitely not "worst ever made" I wouldn't think.

Not seen Fury, but Inglorious Basterds is (IMO) a great war film. Not gritty, realistic or accurate but a great film (as are pretty much all of Tarantino's films - always love to see the work of a director who is in love with cinema) set in wartime.

I really liked Clint Eastwood's "Letters From Iwo Jima". They say history is written by the winners, but this is history from the other side. Very good indeed, and much better than its sister film "Flags Of Our Fathers".

Also, "A Midnight Clear" for the whole banality of war with a bit of 'oh, for ****s sake' thrown in.

Special mentions to:
Good Morning Vietnam
The Railway Man
Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence
Enemy At The Gates
Jakob The Liar
Schindler's List

I 'enjoyed' Fury, if that's the appropriate description. Thought the plot and reality of war was plausible and gave you a sense of what it felt like in a tank regiment.

633 Squadron just for the planes.

Tae Guk Gi: The Brotherhood of war,South Korean film would recommend it

A Bridge Too Far has a Leopard tank crossing the bridge.

Fury is terrible.

Not a movie but Band of Brothers is amazing. The Pacific is pretty good to.

I enjoyed Fury the first time but watched it since and decided I must have been drunk the first time as it's pretty bad.

Ingloreus Bastards is one of my favorites and one of the best movies there is.

Good list of war films there I'm going to add Schindler's List

The Beast
Ran
The life and death of Colonel Blimp
The four feathers

I class a good film as one that if I see when channel surfing I'll watch it again and again. By that criteria;

Downfall
Platoon
Saving private Ryan

But the most accurate films to capture squaddie humour for me are;

Dog soldiers (woeful otherwise)
Kajaki (frustrating)

Dog Soldiers is ace full of Geordie humour. 😀

"I hope I give you the shits" nailed it for me.

A classic line.

It's a play on when someone is eating something or drinking something and you can't, the response being "I hope it gives you the shits."

Another one for the barstewards and dog soldiers

A lot here to watch, if the weather wasn't so nice today I'd be ticking a few off

Mosquito Squadron
Platoon
Bridge over the River Kwai

But always Das Boot for that gritty realism.

[b]The Longest Day[/b], which remains (with the exceptions of John Wayne's piss poor contribution playing a man who was half his age, and Sean Conneries lamentable attempt at an Irish accent) an utterly remarkable film for its ambition in telling different aspects of the story and its attempt at accuracy, employing so many of those who were really there as advisors.

[b]Waterloo[/b] - for the sheer scale of the battle scenes [i]"Raise high the black flags children, no pity, no prisoners..."[/i]

[b]Come and See[/b], for being just, well, haunting, in its portrayal of the work of the german death squads as they advanced in to Russia

Peter Watkins 1964 version of [b]Culloden[/b]

but the best of all: [b]Went the day well[/b]

[img] [/img]

I have a book... 🙂
[img] [/img]

The Killing Fields.

All quiet on the Western Front gets it for me .

Off topic slightly but I thought the over the top scene at the end of Blackadder was really moving and very well done

Inglorious basterds ranks right up there with Fury as probably the worse [s]war[/s] films ever made imv and a stain on Brad Pitts career.

FTFY

Inglorious Basterds is a couple of good scenes loosely thrown together. Too long and completely self indulgent.

Das Boot has to be the best, its just unbelievably atmospheric.

What about master and commander? not war filmy enough.

Battle of britain-so many aircraft it was by numbers the 35th largest air force in the world.
;:
Oh and Bridge to far has the best line in any war film:
Major Harry Carlyle: We haven't the proper facilities to take you all prisoner! Sorry!
SS Panzer Officer: [confused] What?
Major Harry Carlyle: We'd like to, but we can't accept your surrender! Was there anything else?

Kajaki was really good but so tense found I couldn't watch half of it! 633 squadron and The Guns of Naverone. The start of Saving Private Ryan I thought was absolutely outstanding.

Ha! Funny you should say that... on the back of this thread I watched Kajaki again this afternoon, I skipped a lot of it due to the tension

I thought Fury was alright, bit hollywood in places but tanks and AP. Some good filming.

The book it was loosely based on is a bit contentious.

Black hawk down is ****ing awful, who ever mentioned that should just stop giving opinions

Band of brothers (although not a film) was epic and better than most war films

The tank gunshots in Fury seemed very weird - more like lasers from Star Wars. Do real tank rounds actually look like that?

13hrs...the story of the attack on the American compound in Bengazi was pretty good, think it was made by the same guy who did Black Hawk Down. We Were Warriors...about the air cav in Vietnam has some good moments.

lazybike

13hrs...the story of the attack on the American compound in Bengazi was pretty good, think it was made by the same guy who did Black Hawk Down. We Were Warriors...about the air cav in Vietnam has some good moments.

Nothing about his post is correct.

@ wiggles "it's all in the grind"

Hedd Wyn is worth a watch if you can find it

My 95yr old grandad was in the glider pilot regiment flying horsa's at arnhem. There can't be many of them left now.

Broadsword calling Danny Boy.?

One of my favourite scenes of all time (for me) is the bar scene in Inglorious Bastards.

The tank gunshots in Fury seemed very weird - more like lasers from Star Wars. Do real tank rounds actually look like that?

Machine gun tracer looks very much like star wars blasters/lasers. Being part of a company level night shoot many years ago was an amazing thing, tracer rounds would often bounce off some of the targets zipping skywards. The tank battle scene in Fury was accurate in that regard. What I will say is that movies tend to over do muzzle flash and tracers in daylight. In bright day light they are not as bright as movies depict them, and you tend not to see muzzle flash at all.

I just checked and the Germans did use tracer on Armour Piercing 88mm rounds that tanks and anti-tanks guns used, so that was probably accurate in Fury too.

I've not seen anyone mention 'Only the Dead' its on Netflix and is a documentary, it is really sobering stuff and gets inside the minds of insurgents, terrorists and US infantry in Iraq.

Second only the dead..the firefight in the house was chilling.