[Closed] Running 1x9 for XC: What are my options for keeping the chain on the front?

Can you adjust the front mech over the middle ring with the hi/lo screws?

apparently a shorter cage rear mech run as tight as possible will negate the need for any chain device on the front.

Hmm interesting. A front mech would probably work OK, but if I stuck with 1x9 long term I would probably want something prettier!

As for rear mechs, would a 1x9 with a 11/32 cassette work with a road rear mech, or do I need a medium (i.e. GS) MTB rear mech? I am guessing since my road bike has a total range of 30 (14 at the back, 16 at the front) I could use a road mech if I wanted?

Poppa - I have an MRP 1x9 chain guide that I've bought but never used. It works well. It you're interested I can let you have it for £30.

Ive ran road mechs with 32 tooth cassettes...it works but they dont like it! The mech sits right on the 32 ring and makes a noise(like too much B tension), other than that all good.

I dont have anything up front and havent had any problems. Give it a try you may be lucky. So long as your chain length is right you shouldnt have problems, the removal of the big ring allows you to take a couple of links out.

What HTTP404 said

Good chainline most important

I have a similar 1 x 9 setup. Was having problems with chain jumping off front on fastish downs when free wheeling - a real pest, allways jumped out the way because of chainline when in higher gear. Tried a road mech and tight chain - was marginally worse in my case.
As this was on my hack bike didn't want to fork out £40+ for a chain guide, so stuck on an old front mech - not the prettiest, but does the job. Haven't dropped the chain since.

To the people that aren't using chain devices and haven't had any problems, I am assuming that you have single-speed (i.e. non-ramped) front rings?

To the people [i]have[/i] had problems, do you also use a single-speed (i.e. non-ramped) front ring?

I've seen [url= http://www.jdcycles.co.uk/components/tandem-components--accessories/n-gear-jump-stop-chain-guide ]these[/url] recommened several chains following similar questions on here.

Not used it yet myself, but I plan too get one to run with a Blackspire Stinger and a DH 36T chainring.

Should be fairly tidy too.

A road mech swings at a different angle to an MTB mech thats why they foul on MTB cassettes in the bigger cogs, you can run an MTB short cage mech with 1x9, but thats loads more expense the long cage you have will be fine but run chain as short as possible.

To stop the jumping on the front its the MRP 1x9 device or a n-gear jump stop and a bashring.

If you ride offroad with nothing it will drop the chain, my record was 13 in one 1hour 20 min race, I bought a jump stop and bash the next day, they didnt make the MRP thing then.

I did exaclty the same as I can quite happily do my local loop SS or 1x9, but after a few years ****ing about being a bit niche, I have gone back to having the full 27 gears, its no more hassle, and I didnt find running less gears a great deal less expensive. (ok singlespeeding was a bit but still needed a chain and front ring every now and then)

poppa, I was using an unramped chainring when it dropped the chain 13 times in one short race, thats all rubbish as far as I can tell.

Which side is the chain dropping? Inside, then go for a Deda dog fang (~£6). If both sides, there's a very pretty Paul's chain keeper oner (but ~£50 ouch!).

Useful stuff, thanks everyone. I think I will try with a front mech on first, to see if I get on with the set up. Those MRP 1.x guides look like what I am after, but they seem expensive for what they are! Still, I suppose if no-one else is making them they can charge what they want.

The reason I want to go 1x9 is simply because I never seem to need the other gears, so it offends me to have all this stuff on my bike for no good reason. I sometimes guiltily change up into the big ring on road sections, but even then I could be comfortably spinning in the middle instead. I tend to save my energy for off-road anyway...

Get the N-Gear Jump Stop :
http://www.billys.co.uk/english/group.php?prod=chng-js

and a bash guard :
http://www.bbgbashguard.com/

I run this combination with a standard SLX middle chain ring and a med cage rear mech, it is faultless, chain stays on permanently.

Kev

I do exactly as Keva - no problems

The Paul's Chain Keeper looks a neat solution for XC use

http://www.paulcomp.com/chainkeeper.html

simple and tidy design, I use an E13 full chain device with upper and lower guides but think this would be overkill for what you ask, but the Pauls one is worth a look! Not sure of availability in the UK though.

No dropping problems for me. I'm using a Middleburn unramped chainring.

Been having this same problem on a recently built up 1x9 bike. It's only falling on the inside, and then it only happens when trying to put the power on while going downwards on rough stuff.

I'm going out to the shed and going to see what I can make. I have a box full of old front mechs, plastic light brackets, etc. Must be a cheap and simple bodge that'll work 🙂

mackem, enter a Summit MTB race at Lotts wood next year and report back.. You got 13 dropped chains to beat.

Mackem - Member

No dropping problems for me. I'm using a Middleburn unramped chainring.

I use one of those too with no drop.

Also use a BB which adjusts dise to side so can get good chainline

Think I may have cracked this using a rear light bracket and a file (used on the bracket - not the bike!) Loosely based on the Dedo Dog Fang idea.

If it does do the trick, I'll post some piccies.

[url= http://www.sjscycles.co.uk/cid/9PQCYIJRI7171P51YCM0GCUAGM47GAU2/product-Rohloff-Rohloff-Chain-Guide-CC-8290-11874.htm ]The fancy German one![/url]

geetee 1972
interested in MRP 1x9 chain guide
thanks
phwill@btconnect.com

seen this thread:

http://www.singletrackworld.com/forum/topic/trail-bike-with-single-ring

from there:

[img] [/img]

unramped sing speed surly ring 33t, fsa polycarb bash and n-gear jump stop

also moved the bottom bracket across by one spacer