Forum menu
New Sturmey Archer ...
 

[Closed] New Sturmey Archer hubs - whats the difference then?

Free Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 0
Topic starter   [#2927159]

http://www.sturmey-archer.com/products/hubs/cid/3/id/47

Anyone info on this?

There's '3 speed' hubs and also '3 speed rotary' hubs?
What's the difference?

Also, anyone know specifics about the Sturmey Archer 'S3X' - 3 speed fixed gear!

cheers



   
Free Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 272
 

'3 Speed' uses the old school chain and rod through the axle, the rotary hubs use a system like alfine's, nothing protruding from the end of the axle.

S3X is a 5 speed with some stuff taken out to give 3 fixed ratios (direct drive, under drive 25% and under drive 37.5% - we are possibly looking into the idea of a "Peak District Fixie" that would use this hub or the 2 speed kickback hub

Matt



   
Full Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 17396
 

Rotary hubs have the cable actuation on the inside of the dropouts (bit like an Alfine) , the ordinary hub works through a fine chain that runs through the end of the axle and so is a bit more exposed.

The fixed gear is pretty heavy because it has been considerably beefed up from the standard 3 speed. I think it's one of those things that look better in theory than in practise. I should know, I bought one and have never fitted it ๐Ÿ™ Just felt it was too heavy to stick on the back of a lightweight fixie.

You can however stick a freewheel on it and then you would have a very robust hub for offroad use.



   
Free Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 272
 

Oh and the S3X can take a screw on freewheel, converting it into a conventional 3 speed should you wuss out of riding fixed

Matt

EDIT-(kind of beaten there)



   
Free Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 0
 

As far as I'm aware its a 3 speed fixie,so no freewheel.

Hence allowing you to do hills that you might not get up normally with a single fixed gear.



   
Full Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 17396
 

unovolo - Member
As far as I'm aware its a 3 speed fixie,so no freewheel...

It's an odd piece of kit. You can screw on an ordinary freewheel - my White Industries on slips on nicely, or you can even use a cassette type cog and have multiples on it. I think there's even room to have a freewheel and a fixed cog, so you could swap from on to the other.