[Closed] Narrowed it down: All Mountain Bike decision

[img] [/img]

Now with a Reverb and some orange pedals 🙂

Dave

Both great looking bikes. I know people who ride both and love 'em. Would seem that the Transition is a bit harder to peddle. I'd go El Guapo.

Read the STW review of the Transition over there *points*

There needs to be a wallet warning next to alfabus' photo.

I want that bike...

Not ridden either but if I was taking the plunge, I'd find the el guapo hard to resist at £800!

Oh my, alfabus. She is a beauty.

me also, and there are last years covert frames available for a [s]grand/[s] 1100.
[url= http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Transition-Covert-2011-Frame-Orange-Small-Fox-rp23-Rear-Shock-150mm-Travel-/260905048053 ]here[/url] and [url= http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Transition-Covert-6-Travel-Enduro-2011-/260884066728#ht_1819wt_956 ]here.[/url]
Could also ask [url= http://www.flyingfoxbikes.com/ ]pete moulding at flying fox[/url] my mate bought a cheap one off them recently.

Love mine, best bike ever.

[IMG] [/IMG]

Just got an EG, only one ride so far but liking it a lot... rides more like the socom it's replacing DH than I expected it to*

*a good thing.

Oh my, alfabus. She is a beauty.

She rides better than she looks 😀

Bikes don't come any more right looking than that. Always going to play a part in the decision.

Loving my Covert 🙂

[img] [/img]

I have a 2011 covert frame for sale if you want. Medium in size.

So I think looking at the bikes here it's got to be the Covert.

Black or Polished?

dafoxster - Member
So I think looking at the bikes here it's got to be the Covert.

Black or Polished?

Not sure on your conclusion, given that nobody's posted an El Guapo...

🙂 I used google as well.

Playing devil's advocate here (I liked the Covert myself when I demoed one) - what are the differences?

Travel and geometry are very similar, I think the EG looks every bit as good, suspension wise the EG is a proper 4-bar (IIRC) while the Covert is single pivot/linkage, the Covert comes with a Fox, the EG with a Monarch.....

Above all else, the EG is 899, the Covert is ~1400. Are you at all tempted by an EG with a CCDB and two hundred quid in your pocket?

She rides better than she looks

Eg=£799

brant - Member

Eg=£799

Right - so an EG with CCDB, two hundred quid in your pocket and a hundred for me.

Where are you going to get a deal like that?

The EG is nice and cheap but will never get admiring glances like the covert will (if that's important to you!). Sometimes it's nice to be smitten with your bike rather than happy that you have saved some money.

[img] [/img]

I know it's a personal thing and I have a Covert myself, but that Guapo just looks like a pile of sh*t.

Its just butt ugly and wrong in so many ways.

Its probably why its so cheap they can't give them away by the looks of it.

that Guapo just looks like a pile of sh*t.

haha, don't hold back, will you 🙂 say what you really mean.

Dave

I think they're quite nice looking.

http://www.shedfire.com/2011/11/11/titus-el-guapo-x9-1999/

Above all else, the EG is 899, the Covert is ~1400

I paid £900 for mine. Pretty sure you can still find the 2011 model at that price - only thing different is the lack of bolt through rear - can't say that has bothered me yet.

Dave

The Covert isn't a good looking bike, but it looks like its right, as though it is meant to look that way for the type of riding it's capable of.

The El Guapo, which is a crap name anyway, just looks a mismatch of styles and angles,
the cable routing is messy, the lines are all over the place and its just wrong.

Don't mean to offend its just a personal opinion.

Playing devil's advocate here (I liked the Covert myself when I demoed one) - what are the differences?

I chose the covert because I liked the look of it. If I did a blind test riding (if you could) I doubt I could tell the difference between it and the guapo. In the end it comes down to what you fancy..

I wonder if the price difference is down to the shock? The rp23 is adored in these parts, I don't know anything about the monarch, but doesn't that tell you enough about what it's perceived worth is?
(note you can get the covert cheap so I dunno if price comes into it)

brant - Member
I think they're quite nice looking.

http://www.shedfire.com/2011/11/11/titus-el-guapo-x9-1999/

It's every bit as good-looking as the Covert. Which is kind of damnign with faint praise, but regardless, I don' think there's much to choose looks-wise.

[img] [/img]

Sancho +1.

Resale value probably better on Covert too as Transition is a cool brand, Titus not.

Thanks for the comments. I took the plunge and went for a Large Black Transition Covert frame at £999.

Now for the fork.

Marzocchi 55 RC3 Ti

You knows it!

Dave

dafoxster

I'm tending towards the Transition. Thoughts?

Heavy and overpriced for what it is.

dafoxster I took the plunge and went for a Large Black Transition Covert frame at £999.

Edit: Enjoy your new frame, 🙂 I'm sure it'll be great, that's a good price.

dafoxster - Member
Thanks for the comments. I took the plunge and went for a Large Black Transition Covert frame at £999.

Now for the fork.

£999 is a good deal.... that makes for a whole different argument.

[IMG] [/IMG]

[IMG] [/IMG]

Both great bikes, can't go wrong wither way to be fair. But here's my El Guapo before first ride last weekend. Awesome, pedals great and is fantastic on the way down, soaking up drops, jumps and cornering brilliantly. Built up to exactly 31 lb

Have fun with the Covert, post up when its finished

PS hope the photos come out, my first attempt at attaching photos on here...

Enjoy the bike, let us know how you find it (fwiw that's the choice I'd have made between those two)