[Closed] Karate Monkey, what other SS 29er should I consider

Stooge.

Still not convinced by the one size fits all, I need to borrow one really......

El Mar? Don't think the Selma is still available.

Still not convinced by the one size fits all

Genesis high latitude or fortitude. (In a classic recommend what you own stylee) 😀

I've ridden one with Unicrown forks and that was OK. I think for me (being a short house) the truss forks raised the front end too much....

And I should have said I'm looking for a used bike. I always fret about thrashing a new bike and except wheels I've everything else to swap over.....

Vassago Jabberwocky

Krampus? Works fine with normal 29er wheels, but you have the option to go bigger if you want.

Vassago, looks interesting. Krampus Ian a possibility. Off for an ale and a think......

Another vote for the Stooge. I came very close to getting a Karate Monkey, but was swayed by the Stooge style and geometry.

These frames basically made by similar (if not the same) people, but to different designs and styles:

[img] [/img]
[img] [/img]
[img] [/img]

Love that Stooge...

Singular, lots raced on the endurance scene, and always seem to be the pointy end of the results sheets.

Another vote for the Stooooge.

Frames cheap enough to buy new and not worry about.

Carver 69er

El Mar here.

Looked at the Stooge, but decided it was a bit slacker and more suited to technical MTBing - I had a somewhat different brief. However the Salsa turned out to be bloody brilliant handling - if a little steep for anything really steep.

I have a Stooge and an El Mar, and prefer the Stooge for fun stuff but I think the El Mar will be better over distance. I've done multiday races on the El Mar, but I think the Stooge might be a bit heavy by comparison. The Stooge is more fun on the downs though, especially with a big tyre up front.

If it's recomend your own then a SIR.9 or an MCR.
You will love either.
Lovely ride quality.

Singular Swift

http://shop.singularcycles.com/products/singular-swift

[img] ?v=1415365369[/img]

I think I'll have to borrow a Stooge. Anyone have one near Bristol I can have a play on?????

Test rode a Sir 9 with matching steel fork, while it was comfy and a joy to ride for xc, when pushed i found the fork a bit flappy, brake judder and toe overlap.

I went KM, they have a rep for a harsh fork. If only doing xc maybe change the fork. For me when i gave it some stick it had direct steering and stable, only broke the lower headset bearing.
If ridden hard or a heavyweight rider or the bike will be loaded up then a good workhorse.
From ragging one in DH races it was immense fun, like a roided up bmx with a nice comfy ride. The more it was pushed the nicer it was, apart from bursting a headset bearing 🙂
I got a 2011, the facelifted frame design but the last year of the v-canti brake mounts, the frame is a keeper.

If i had Sir9 money to drop i would consider a custom frame as well.

At the time i did consider a Swift, but the KM had more options, Swifts are nice though....

Yep, it'll be hard to beat a early mud brown KM frame. If it has to be new, I reckon a Krampus or Stooge might be worth trying.....

Please get a Krampus. You'd look proper hilarious on a Krampus.

Genesis longitude, comes as frame and fork with bars and headset. Great vfm. Can put gears on it later if you like, takes up to a 3 inch tire too. Very versatile and a lot better value than surly

What type of riding is it for?

To [u]completely [/u]oversimplify:

XC = Swift/SIR 9
Trail = KM/Stooge/Krampus/Jones
Exploring = Longitude

Obviously you can ride anything on any of them, but they are biased to a type of riding. I do know that the stooge is great fun and very confidence inspiring. There will be several at Battle on the Beach and Bristol Bikefest if that helps?

They are quite different bikes.

Good question. It'll be my only SS (non fat bike), so most evenings on the way home man made trails at Ashton Court, Bristol, then away days like, SSUK, HONC, HOTS, Gravel Dash, FOD but also able to cope with forest type trails round here.
I'm stopping "racing", so can be quite Karate Monkey-ish. Doesn't have to be very light, will have rigid forks.

I think the Stooge's front end being so tall would mean I'd end up not being able to get the bar / seat level....like on the Jones. I need to try one.....

And Garry, thank you for the comments. I think I'd look dashing no matter what I ride.......

I think the Stooge's front end being so tall would mean I'd end up not being able to get the bar / seat level....like on the Jones. I need to try one....

Talk to Andy - pop over to see him for a test (Oswestry)?

I'm in Somerset and my mate in Shepton has one too.

My Stooge has its seat lower than the bars .....after some advice from Andy (Mr Stooge). I was sceptical but I have still got 35-40mm of spacers under the bar which raises it higher than the seat by 50mm ....I've got short legs you see.
It rides much better than a slammed stem ....I've emailed you Flashes to meet up for a test ride

Ps just to add ...that brown KM is still not for sale .....we both know how good it rides ....and tbh the Stooge rides better

Right, we'll converse nearer the time. I'm away Pugsleying round Dorset next week........

Flashes - you've listed my riding (well until I recently moved from Bristol). The Swift was brilliant for that.

[img] [/img]
Upper Quarry trail at AC

Good question. It'll be my only SS (non fat bike), so most evenings on the way home man made trails at Ashton Court, Bristol, then away days like, SSUK, HONC, HOTS, Gravel Dash, FOD but also able to cope with forest type trails round here.
I'm stopping "racing", so can be quite Karate Monkey-ish. Doesn't have to be very light, will have rigid forks.

I think the Stooge's front end being so tall would mean I'd end up not being able to get the bar / seat level....like on the Jones. I need to try one.....

All my pics above (of the Stooge singlespeed) are taken at Ashton Court, which is where I do most of my riding these days.

If you are flexible about times (kids), you are very welcome to see mine in the flesh. I live in Southville.

Ben, I'd like to sit on one....what sort of days / times are good for you. When do you tend to be at AC?

Flashes: I will get back to you. Aligning childcare and good weather means that planning rides is quite hard! 🙂

I have a Karate Monkey and by a twist of fate a Krampus.

You'll not go wrong with a Karate Monkey, that being said if I was to replace both the Karate Monkey and the Krampus with one bike I'd replace it with a Stooge.

Worth looking on the MTBR Surly Forum for build ideas etc if you go KM.

Jones - I've put a negative rise stem on mine, also my bars is a bit higher than seat, works well for me.

FRC, I tried a negative stem on my Jones. I ride SS so spend a bit of time out of the saddle and it felt somehow wrong.
Bill, I have a KM I ride fixed and I had the early frame SS use. I do really rate them. But although I'm no longer racing (well except Tide 2 Tide, oh and a few others) I would like something different from another KM (unless an early 16" frame came up).......looking forward to trying a Stooge.

Surly Krampus or Genesis Longitude would be on my list, you then have the option of running fat or normal rims/tyres.

The Stooge is stunning in my opinion, and the Kinesis Sync / FF29 and Singular Swift are also worth considering.

Have you posted a wanted ad on here for a KM? That's how I got mine. Love it.

I also have an older style 1x1, which is similarly excellent - if anything it handles better than the KM - not as solid feeling but more nimble and will take a modestly shod 29er wheel without screwing the handling - there is bags of clearance in the back, OK at the front but could always upgrade the fork at a later date.

I only mention that as there are some good deals on 1x1 F&F at Triton at the moment (£280).

...although looking at that Stooge, I think if I was looking now, it would also be high on my list!

Paceman, I did think Krampus, still on the list. I had a Genesis IO, it did nothing for me.
SJ. I have advertised for a KM, nothing. I have a spare 1X1, I hadn't thought of 29ing that, although i use V brakes, would that work?
Currently not advertising as I could be having a sit / ride on a Stooge and would like to see if that is a poss...........

Or I could go and buy a Niner or Canfield Nimble (cos they look like sex on wheels)

The KM is an awesome bike. Get one!

I have a spare 1X1, I hadn't thought of 29ing that, although i use V brakes, would that work?

Ah I run disks on mine so that wasn't an issue for me... Mavic and Xtracycle used to do a 700C adaptor kit for 26" frames but you might struggle to track them down. Paul Moto brakes can also be adjusted to do the job but they are very spendy... probably cheaper to get some new wheels!

Were you planning on running Vs on your new bike then? If so that's going to limit the choice a bit further. Stooge is disc only isn't it? In fact a Surly may be the only option if you want to keep on using Vs.

FWIW - Heres some pics of my 1x1 with 29er rims. It's currently running 'cross tyres on MTB rims but I've had 29 x 2 Bontys in there without any problems in the past... should give you some idea of clearances.

[IMG] [/IMG]

[IMG] [/IMG]

[IMG] [/IMG]

That's nice.
I like V / cantis, so if I could, I would run them. If I don't go KM, discs are probably the only option.
I might have a play with my existing 1X1 and the wheelset off of the existing KM to check if I like that set up.......although I could convert the 1X1 to fixed with a disc up front and make the fixed KM my SS bike......
Thanks for the ideas..