Finally managed to remove a seized pedal from the crank today but going along to my local garage and borrowing some 'heavy equipment' and it's turned out a right mess........
Cranks...
My lovely RF Atlas threads are stripped 🙁
[img] 
[/img]
[img] 
[/img]
Pedals...
XTR pedals have seen better days, threads are fine but cracks have appeared on the barrel of the allen bolt 🙁
[img] 
[/img]
so whats the general opinion?
a) nah, they're fine
b) should be okay but i'd watch it
c) completely gubbed, for the bin!
d) personal comment
thanks in advance..... 😉
bin em
oh and cut ya finger nails 🙂
You could get the threads in the cranks drilled out and helicoiled, then replace the pedal axles and all is sorted.
Helicoil for the threads, dunno about the pedals
You can try retapping the threads at home by threading the pedals in the opposite way. It's a crude method and not one guaranteed to work, but it's worth a try.
replace them
helicoil, £15-£20 a thread usualy, and generaly stronger than the original thread. Try local engineering workshops, places that do engine re-builds, etc etc.
God knows how you siezed them that badly though?
a bad case of over tightening if you ask me
Re tap the cranks with a proper tap (LBS should have one) they are alloy and you will be surprised how they will come back. but your next pedals in with a suitable loctite (try bearing fit) or copperslip.
They will either go up nice and tigh or the threads will strip. they won't come undone as you are pedalling.
Spuds- the axles are rubbish, bin them, but you might be able to source replacement ones via madison.
Good god, what did you do to then to get them like that?
**UPDATE**
Just called the local wheelbuilder and he seems to think the cranks are no problem, the pedals however may be a different story!
oh...and i've trimmed the fingernails! 🙂
Got to ask.....
Why were you so keen to get them out?
Why not just carry on using them as they were?
.........Jim.
Get yourself some shimano cranks, cheaper and better and replace the axle.
Could potentially even just tap that crank thread - hard to tell from the photo. Seen a lot of shimano pedals with cracks like that but never seen one actually break.
i personally would not helicoil those cranks i just wold not trust them,its certainly not stronger & the risk of failure is too high.
slx cranks £89.00crc & new pedals £30.00merlin job done.bin the old stuff in the bin.
A helicoiled thread is stronger than the original alloy thread
there's only way to find out...
Sell them as new in the classifieds. 😆
Get them threads retapped, they'll be fine. Seen much worse saved.
I'd replace the pedal axle- be a bit of a beggar to be stuck in the middle of a ride with a snapped axle.
in my (limited) experience I would helicoil the crank. But you could do this if the re-tapping was unsuccessful. Shimano axles should be easy to hold of. And use copper slip next time young man.
bin em
29erKeith is obviously fabulously wealthy
*********UPDATE*********
8)
Cranks sorted absolutely no problem £4 at lbs
Pedals, lbs replaced the spindle £4
£8 sorted all the problems, kinda glad i didn't bin 'em now! 😀
Result!
😀
result that i had the same happen to raceface evolve cranks just got new 1s in the end . might look into getting them repaired now
XTR pedals have a ti axle (probably don't now for the £4). Cranks are Alu. I'm guessing they were installed without proper grease, and so bonded with the cranks... schoolboy error.
yarp, zee bonding is zee problemz imz zinking.
but vunce you knowz, you von't be dong itz again yarp
ala ti rotor bolts.....
XTR don't have a titanium axle.
schoolboy error? 😆XTR pedals have a ti axle
i az no ideaz