For value the Rapha one looks very good but it does make you look a bit like a 'try hard w@@@er'
There's some decent ones from small companies on the Etsy website. I bought a Camel chops for my daughter and she likes it. Perfect for a jacket, multi-tool and some snacks.
I'm using this:
Was sceptical of the cam operation on the fixing mechanism but it is rock solid and holds alot of stuff, or it cinches down when you only have a part load.
I'm still happy with our OnOne bargainciois Altura KlikFast bags. They are rock solid and easy to access.
I tried a tie on bag and just found it flopped and flapped everywhere.
The fluoro Carradice looks very similar to the zipped roll. Might try mine on the bars.
singletrackworld.com/forum/topic/handlebar-bags-what-do-you-recommend/page/2/#post-12141589
I have the Restrap Canister Bag and it is perfect for everyday riding. Just the right size to hold a light jacket, multitool, CO2 cartridge and adapter, an energy bar and a folded up musette for emergency use.
For long day rides and when bikepacking I also have the 10l Bar Pack. Great for holding a change of clothes, sarnies, snacks, etc and the front pocket is quick and easy to access for smaller items.
They are quite expensive but worth the money in my opinion.
Certain colours of the Rapha handlebar bags are currently £38 on their website.
My wife has claimed the Topeak barloader I bought so now I'm looking for a slightly smaller bag that doesn't interfere with GPS, light and bells on the drop bars
Has anyone got one of the Carradice Bikepacking Handlebar Bag (link above)?? It looks pretty good but can't find many reviews of it.
Not sure these are any smaller, but just seen the thread pop up and wanted to give a vote for victory chimp https://www.victorychimp.cc/collections/bags/products/norfee-industries-ror-handlebar-bag-olive
The straps are a bit fiddly if you're swopping it between bikes a lot, but other than that it's been a great bag. Perfect size for a day out.
I have a WizardWorks one based on @rocketdog review. It's a whole lot stiffer than the cheap Alpkit one I had before. Need another and will prob get a second one although the victory chimp one looks pretty good for a bit less money,
Camelchops Blimp.
have a restrap canister myself but have bought Camelchops bags for my partner (you can customise colours to go with your bike).
They are a husband and wife team making the bags in the U.K.
I've got a wizard works/restrap/Rapha bar bag test ongoing. So far there's a clear leader
I did ask camelchops to join in but they didn't in the end
I have a WizardWorks one based on @rocketdog review. It’s a whole lot stiffer than the cheap Alpkit one I had before. Need another and will prob get a second one although the victory chimp one looks pretty good for a bit less money,
Great! The voile strap fixing is a highlight too
I have the Restrap Canister Bag and it is perfect for everyday riding.
Same here. Doesn't carry much, but ideal size if you want something without fitting any hardware. Good for swapping between bikes super quick.
Ortileb Handlebar Bag. (touring style not bike packing).
👆
I tried a couple of on-trend 'bikepacking' handlebar bags. They were not great, took longer to fit, and wore out bits of frame, flopped around, cost lots.
Mrs_OAB and I now sport 'granny bags' - Altura versions of the Ortileb bags linked below. Klikfast is great - stable, vey quick to mount/unmount, no rubbing, no problems offroad. The bags were £8 from OnOne sale!
I would like some on-trend companies to make a klikfast mount bar bag - I do like the Camelchops colours and patterns of gear, maybe I should ask nicely...
https://www.cyclestore.co.uk/productDetails.asp?productID=79394&categoryID=91
I have the Restrap Canister Bag and it is perfect for everyday riding.
Ditto
I also have the Restrap bar bag, it's ok, and definitely waterproof but quite deep if you've got a low stack height- I've had it rub on the front wheel before...
It actually works better as a saddle bag!
Love my altura box that is rixen and kaul quick release, has a carry stray for cafea/shopping, and has an old school map holder on the lid for err, a map.
I’ve got a wizard works/restrap/Rapha bar bag test ongoing. So far there’s a clear leader
@rOcKeTdOg - When will the reviews be posted on your website?
When will the reviews be posted on your website?
just got to finish writing it, hopefully beginning of next week
👍
Missed your reply ages ago, but:
https://www.tailfin.cc/blog/how-aerodynamic-is-your-bikepacking-setup/?v=79cba1185463
https://www.cyclingabout.com/fascinating-aerodynamics-bikepacking-bicycle-touring/
These silly round hipster bar bags are about as bad for aero a choice you can make.
See them strapped to 5 grand road bikes everywhere these days. They carry less than jersey pockets do. If you need more, a frame or seatpack is by far a better idea.
Unless like, fitting in at your local gravel ride is your jam.
Aero? Have you seen the shape of me?
If you're bigger and slower, you spend more time in the wind and you're more impacted by wind at a wider angle of attack.
Which means you actually have, objectively, more to gain from not making aero mistakes.
I'm not saying get in a skinsuit, just - why spend money that's only gonna make you slower all the time.
I think most of us are leisure cyclists, aero is just something to eat (preferably not the mint one, it's an abomination)
They carry less than jersey pockets d
You must have very big pockets. Who wants three loaded down pockets anyway? I can't stand hip or back packs so everything I need can go in the bar bag plus my cheese sandwiches don't get sweaty, crushed or covered in crap from the rear wheel as they would if they were sat in my back pocket 🤷♂️
I'd add one these if you don't like the paint on your bike been rubbed off or your cable outer rubbed away.
I'd keep the bar bag to a sensible size and keep it as close to your bars as possible. Or the weight can affect handling.
Brooks, Rapha, Caradice and Ortlieb have some nice bar bags too.
I like minimalist type bags as I hate the dreaded rattle.
Bar bags are good about 3 litres. Used for food, warm layer, pump, spares, tools, gels, glasses
Bum bags are good about 1 litre, used for keys, phone, snack, windproof gilet/jacket, essential spares, money
Saddle bags are best less than 0.5 litre, used for tools or spares
Small top tube bags are good for food
A bottle feed bag is also good to add extra food or water bottle
Bargain bags can be bought from Decathlon, Halfords, Planet X, eBay and Amazon.
Or a tool bottle is awesome on the cross/gravel/MTB marathon bikes.
The fluoro Carradice looks very similar to the zipped roll. Might try mine on the bars.
Update, it went on the bars with longer straps and foam spacers bought from Carradice. It worked well, and there was just enough room for a spare pair of shorts, jersey and travel towel, which I used on the Bryan Chapman audax.
I’d add one these if you don’t like the paint on your bike been rubbed off or your cable outer rubbed away.
Or helmet tubes https://tightbike.co.uk/products/helmet-tubes-handlebar-bag-support
I us a bar bag and fork bags on both of my bikes and find the effect on handling to be minimal. You need to look at the overall packing system, to balance the front I also use a rear rack.
I thought 4 year old threads were locked?
As it’s arisen, can Rocketdog post a link to his review now?
Currently running an Alpkit AirLok Dual 20L with the Joey harness. It fits my sleeping bag and jacket well enough and is properly waterproof.
Straps are a bit poor though, it can sort of slide out of one of the loops making it lopsided. Still secure but not the best weight distribution
As it’s arisen, can Rocketdog post a link to his review now?
I'm assuming this is the review mentioned.
https://ukgravelco.com/2022/10/16/bar-bag-grouptest/
But there are lots more bag reviews available on the site too. I'm just about to read through a few as I'm after a smallish bag that (a) fits below bar height so that lights and GPS can be accommodated and (b) has some sort of stiffener so that it doesn't go floppy when not stuffed full.
I've got a big roll closure Alpkit one for bikepacking, but it's a bit too big when full and fouls the gearshift. I recently got one of these for day rides and it's perfect. Ideal size (2.8L), maintains its canister shape without sagging, extra mesh external pockets and elastic to stow snacks and waterproof etc. It seems pretty well made and durable. The main zip is really sturdy and can be opened and closed with one gloved hand to access stuff whilst riding. A bar mounted light points over the top and doesn't foul the opening. I have had to move my Garmin from an out front mount to a stem mount, but that's no biggie.
+1 for the Victory Chimp one (bought one recently for the bike packing bike for when it's in winter road bike guise), it's almost as good as the Ornot cannister I have on my gravel bike (but that's crazy expensive once you factor in the delivery & duty, at least I bought mine from US as couldn't find a local distributor). I did also get a Restrap one to try for a road bike but it's a bit floppy and had to buy some extra foam spacers from Amazon to be it far enough off the bars I could still hold them.
I have the Victory Chimp mounted on a Tailfin bar cage via the Tailfin long straps so it's well out of the way (will replace with a bigger Tailfin bar bag for bike packing trips). Was a bit of hassle routing the straps but they do fit in the bag slots (the ones the bag came with are too wide for the bar cage slots).
I'm assuming this is the review mentioned.
Cheers @scotroutes that review was a while ago and as you say there's a few more on there now!
I'm looking for something like this but a little less industrial.
https://restrap.com/products/bumper-bar
