I've a Genesis Fortitude SS bike, but I'd like to use it as a MTB-tourer. I'm thinking about upgrading it with Alfine 8 or 11spd IGH, or get Problemsolvers gear hanger and Paul Components Thumbie Shifter mounts with Shimano 9spd thumbshifters and use them as a full-length-cable system...
What's Your opinion? IGH or 1x9 derailleur? Why?
Thanks!
Alfine 8 for reliability v cost but it largely depends on what range and ratio you'll need
I'll need it on hilly and flat terrain, too.
You will need a new rear wheel either way but also think how you're going to run gear cable - zip ties? How often do you want to convert between?
Personally I'd go with the mech cos it seems simpler but in true stw stylee I am recommending what I have!
Dmr also do a chain tensioner with a hanger
Just come back from a 350 mile mainly road tour in Scotland on my Fortitude Race. Its 1x10 with a 11-36t cassette and 38t chainring. Prefect ratio for lumpy terrain, the slack head angle makes it super stable with panniers at speed and i used 35c Marathon Supreme - but you can go any size on the tyres.
Comfy, fast and a joy to ride
I'd like to use Alpkit bags or sg similar, as the Fortitude SS doesn't have any eyelets for rack or panniers.
I like the idea of the derailleur, because if sg goes wrong, I still can use my bike as a singlespeed. But... on the other hand, the IGH is cleaner, and seems to be trouble-free. (I've no experience with the Problemsolvers gear hanger.)
Anyway, I have to build a new rear wheel...
Here's mine, had no problems with the 11 speed plenty of gears for a fully laden tour. 2 inch Big Apples by the way great for road and gentle dry tracks
[img][URL= http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a257/ottocat/fort_zps5a4cdfd2.jp g" target="_blank">
http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a257/ottocat/fort_zps5a4cdfd2.jp g"/> [/IMG][/URL][/img]