Constructive critic...
 

[Closed] Constructive criticism required for new bicycle stability tool

Posts: 0
Free Member
Topic starter
 

Hi there
Have you found yourself swearing because your bike has fallen over when leaned against your car or a wall? I have and became so exasperated when it once slipped over damaging my car and the bike itself that I decided to invent a gadget to help. I did just that and came up with "The Bikelean". All the details are at www.bikelean.co.uk. This isn't a sales technique. I'm just looking for advice from the cycling community (before I stick loads of money into something which won't sell!) as to whether you girls and boys think it could be useful. We have already taken onboard the fast the design needs modifying (the "inner" part of the circle is being removed to enable the bike lean to be attached to all types and sizes of handlebar for both mountain and road bikes) and we also intend to incorporate a tyre lever as opposed to the compass. Please feel free to offer any words of wisdom - negative or positive - in order that we may produce something which could save everyone that sinking feeling, a damaged bike and a big dent in the pocket. Thanks very much, Gary


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:38 pm
 j_me
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

[img] [/img]


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:47 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

In all honesty, this 'problem' has never crossed my mind before.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:50 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I read the home page twice to try and find the subtle joke... but failed.
I think this guy is actually serious 😆


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:51 pm
Posts: 8177
Free Member
 

Sorry, but I looked at your site and I still haven't got a bloody clue what it is or what it does! Am I being dumb?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:51 pm
Posts: 91157
Free Member
 

What? Compass? Seriously?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:53 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

elastic band +1

lightweight, cheap and if you're lucky the postman might bring you the odd free one or leave one on your driveway!


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:53 pm
Posts: 2
Free Member
 

You need some pictures of it on the bike on the front page as well as the videos so people can quickly see what it does.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:53 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Great idea, I think your all missing the point with that picture of those rubber bands?

Surely the beauty of the bike lean is the fact it has a compass? Im sure many people check the weather before riding their bikes, and the weather reports generally give a windspeed and direction. The compass enables you to lean the bike up in a prime position that isnt directly agains the wind, which means its even less likely to fall over. If you use rubber bands, the chances of the wind blowing your bike over a greatly increased.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:54 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Not for me I am afraid. Solution in search of a problem - but it might be attractive to the guys that like all the gadgets


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:55 pm
Posts: 12
Free Member
 

I'll tell you where I am....

...at my desk.

(Overengineered solution for an almost non-problem)


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:56 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:57 pm
Posts: 2
Free Member
 

Tyre lever instead of compass is a much better idea.

But judging from the responses hear I think you really need to market it as a tyre lever with an extra bit(the bike lean). Not as a bike lean with a tyre lever.

Is there anyway you could add in a 5mm allen key as well ? maybe sell it as multitool which can also be used as a bike lean.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 2:59 pm
Posts: 1468
Free Member
 

Your having a laugh........ right?

If not, pull out now and save your money.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:00 pm
Posts: 41786
Free Member
 

Whats wrong with putting the bike on the floor in the first place?

Plenty of wheel stands, BB stands on the market already, and no one uses those, do they?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:01 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Bike Lean have a Warehouse and Distribution Centre in Nottinghamshire and an Administration, Sales & Marketing office in Berkshire.

That sounds like a big operation to sell a little plastic gadget that nobody seems to want.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:01 pm
Posts: 251
Full Member
 

as above - picture of it on the bike so people get an idea of scale.

Compass is a waste of time - make the device smaller and drop it.

Home page is a waste of time - the Olympics and cycle to work might be 'google freindly' but they won't help actually sell the product.

A removable kick-stand/bicycle pump thingy woudl give the same result and avoid the need to lean the bike on a wall?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:03 pm
Posts: 9440
Full Member
 

What? Compass? Seriously?

I agree. To be truely multifunctional. You need to add a bottle opener...........or a cigar lighter. Yes that's it, a cigar trimmer and lighter. Then I'd buy two*

*maybe


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:03 pm
Posts: 16137
Free Member
 

From reading the web page alone I couldnt work out what it was supposed to do.

Then I wondered if it was some form of knucle duster. However 4 things sprung to my mind when I finally understood what it does.

0.5 Sh!t I've never worried about this problem, will have to now.
1. Rubber band
2. It doesnt actually stop the car from getting scratched.
3. Whats wrong with the ground.
4. You will never make money unless their are lots of gullable people out there.

oh 5. Whats the compass thing for ?

Its a bit like spending £100's of pounds for a seat post that drops when you can just undo a leaver that does the same thing.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:07 pm
Posts: 2432
Free Member
 

Add a bottle opener and I'm sure that it will sell very well to hipsters looking for something to hang keys on the beltloops of their sister's jeans.

Oh, change the name of it to something quirky/genitalia related.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:07 pm
 5lab
Posts: 7926
Free Member
 

when I've leaned my bike up against something, I always find I'm in need of something to get stones out of horses hooves. with a little thought could this be the perfect tool?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:09 pm
 Twin
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I would find it more useful if it incorporated nunchucks. Or a bowstaff. Then you could use it to hunt wolverine when not leaning your bike.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:14 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

what, nobody's mentioned the Range Rover Sport yet?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:19 pm
Posts: 9
Free Member
 

Ok, im interested. Can I have your projected sales for the next 3 years, your manufacturing price and your proposed RRP? How many to date have you actually sold? will you ever actually pay for the website setup from selling these? I seriously doubt it.

Oh and while you're at it, have you ever heard of velcro straps or reusable zip ties?

Im sorry but it's just over engineered, bulky, and probably more expensive than a free velcro strap.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:20 pm
 toab
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I think I need this a little less than Harry Hill needs a comb.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:22 pm
Posts: 8177
Free Member
 

change the name of it to something quirky/genitalia related.

Good idea - call it the MooseKnuckle 🙂


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:24 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I still can't get over the idea of a "warehouse and distribution centre in Nottinghamshire".
Does it look like this ?

[img] [/img]


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:24 pm
Posts: 18
Free Member
 

I [b]LOVE[/b] the "Attempting to knock bicycle over once Bike-Lean is attached" video. It so nearly goes over and scratches the Range Rover Sport (damn!)
http://bikelean.webs.com/videos.htm


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:25 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

And the "Administration, Sales & Marketing office in Berkshire" ?

[img] [/img]


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:26 pm
Posts: 13291
Free Member
 

Is this a student project on a Product Design course ?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:27 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Interesting, would I ever use such a thing, no, but I can see there may be a market.

I'd imagine if you could get to a price so it's almost a novelty sale (say £3ish). If you can get cheaper then perhaps you could find volume as a magazine freebie.

From a design and design for manufacture point of view I doubt you could get down to very low costs to support above. I'd probably look at a much smaller design, composite and that you could rapid prototype initially before moving to tooling a blow/injection/whatever moulding.

HTH


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:28 pm
Posts: 91157
Free Member
 

Its a bit like spending £100's of pounds for a seat post that drops when you can just undo a leaver that does the same thing

Yeah, except in that case you actually have to stop and get off to change the saddle - with a gravity dropper, you don't.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:29 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I reckon I could knock it over.

The photos of the contraption make it look like it's massive, only looks smaller in the video (in which it looks like the car was most likely scratched).

I think you should design something like a portable bike stand made out of button mushrooms instead


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:29 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

A removable kick-stand/bicycle pump thingy woudl give the same result and avoid the need to lean the bike on a wall?

A pump which doubles as a kick stand would be a cool idea.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:31 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Oh dear - FAIL 🙄 Nice try but I am ooooot!


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:31 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Administration, Sales & Marketing office in Berkshire

I think I know who it is
[img] [/img]


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:31 pm
 aP
Posts: 681
Free Member
 

The nice picture of cyclisters on your home page is reversed.
Do I understand that basically you wedge it round the brake lever and the bars? I don't quite see how it adapts to working with lots of different manufacturer's styles of brake lever?
Doesn't an old toe strap do the same job? (or an elastic band).


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:31 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Forum Rules:

No Trade or business advertising – except bona fide retailers may respond to genuine enquiries from potential customers.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:32 pm
Posts: 16137
Free Member
 

buzz - yeah but this isnt a business is it 🙂


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:33 pm
 5lab
Posts: 7926
Free Member
 

on a serious note, how does it cope with the fact bikers run different bite points on their brakes due to personal preferance? I run mine so close to the lever that with 2 fingers you can get the lever to touch the grip. Some of my mates run their levers so far out you need to be stretch armstrong to use them. This obviously wouldn't work for both of us


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:33 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

buzz - yeah but this isnt a business is it

LOL

on a serious note, how does it cope with the fact bikers run different bite points on their brakes due to personal preferance?

My thoughts exactly!


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:34 pm
Posts: 251
Full Member
 

these are good

[img] [/img]

dual purpose, adjustable, room to print company names so they can be given away as freebies, fit all bars and brakes etc etc.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:34 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I like it and I'd pay up to 7 quid for one.

I have a big ding in my car caused by exactly that. I don't usually carry rubber bands and stuff and most of my fettling is with the bike against the fence, would also be useful when cleaning the thing and so on and storing it in a hallway etc as it wouldn't move at the slighest touch.

A handrake for bikes good call.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:35 pm
Posts: 91157
Free Member
 

Also on a proper serious note - I've never wished for one of these, and would not use it if it was lying on the floor next to my car. I just prop up my bike against the car resting on saddle and bars, and when I am messing with it I rest it against my body.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:35 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

What I really need is some kind of sweet compartment on my handlebars to put my haribo in.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:35 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

What I really need is some kind of sweet compartment on my handlebars to put my "haribo" in.

you're going to store your drugs in it aren't you... i know your sort! 😈


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:37 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

The simple hassle free answer is to lean your bike up against [b]someone else's car[/b] 😈


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:37 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

on a serious note, how does it cope with the fact bikers run different bite points on their brakes due to personal preferance?

The bit that holds the brake lever has 3 differnt points at which it holds the lever. Looks a well designed product to me just does not fulfill a function for me


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:38 pm
 R979
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Do you mean a sweet compartment on your handlebars, as in: "Dude, I've got this totally sweet compartment on my handlebars!" Or is it just a compartment for sweets?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:39 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Poor bugger's taken a hammering. I take it there's no serious buyers on here then. How much is it anyway..?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:42 pm
Posts: 5938
Free Member
 

I don't get the compass at all. well designed apart from that, and has a sort of use, but I wouldn't buy. also, its specific to MTBs / flat barred bikes, what about road bikes?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:54 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:54 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

[url=


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 3:55 pm
Posts: 4954
Free Member
 

Prime Innovations catalogue material.

Sorry.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:01 pm
Posts: 10333
Full Member
 

As others have said, I can't imagine I would ever have a need for such a thing as there are so many other ways to solve that problem. If you want suggestions though:

- Open up the ring end otherwise it would be a pain to use with bar ends
- Put your videos on YouTube rather than 'FlowPlayer' for SEO reasons
- Rewrite your website for the customer rather than for you. It takes too long to work out what it does


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:02 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

shocking website. took me an age to find out what it actually does. and when i did, it seemed rather pointless. been riding 15years and never felt the need for it. now ive seen it, i still dont.

thats why i wont be investing, im out!


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:03 pm
Posts: 1
Free Member
 

I like that in the video the bike is leant against a blingly looking Rangey Sport, such is the confidence that the bike will not fall over and scratch the car.

But I would never bother using one. I was advised from an eary age to always lean a bike on a wall/car/tree/lamp post by resting the back wheel only on it: friction between wheel, ground and vertical surface acts as a brake of sorts and my bikes all have a back wheel already.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:12 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

no point putting multitool kit on this gizmo if the bloody thing is already being used to keep the bike upright!

How about attaching a bucket and sponge and calling it bikeklean?

....

damn, there goes my patent. 😯


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:19 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

ha ha ha ha ha

( That's all I have to say )


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:27 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

When I first read the thread title I thought it was going to be about some revolutionary new stabilisers for kid's bikes. All a bit of a let down really.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:27 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

What it really needs is one of those things for getting stones out of horses feet


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:29 pm
Posts: 14064
Full Member
 

Lakeland have proven that people will buy useless tat by the bucketload!!

Perhaps you need to market this to them!?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:30 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I'm going to offer to take part in the focus group development for 1st class rail travel expenses & two nights 5* accomodation before & after the focus group. That'll be the first years profits gone for a focus group of one person.
It's a none happening problem IMHO, with cheaper solutions.

the-muffin-man - Member
Lakeland have proven that people will buy useless tat by the bucketload!!

Perhaps you need to market this to them!?

Too niche for Lakeland, but might be worth a shot - I have a really stupid idea that I want to pitch to them!!


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:34 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Talk to the people who sold millions of "power balance bands", they know how to sell useless crap to gullible people.

http://www.powerbalance.com/contacts


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:34 pm
Posts: 16
Free Member
 

Who's kelean? Does he or she know they've been outed as bi on the internet?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:35 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

"Ken and Brian have realised, nobody wants to stomp kittens. there is no market for their Kitten Stomper, whatsoever".

as many others have said, if this was a problem a free elastic band courtesy of your lazy littering local postie is the solution.

edit; would the 2 business centres mentioned be your house and your parents house?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:41 pm
Posts: 30656
Free Member
 

I like the fact there must already be a user named bikelean on STW.....


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:50 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

@joolsburger

A handrake for bikes good call.

Dont be silly, everyone knows that handbrakes are for canoes.

Its ashtrays for bikes!


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 4:57 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

I wanted this to be a slimming product like slimfast or jeycore lite..


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 5:01 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Isn't this what livestrong bands were designed for? And they're easy to carry around with you 😉


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 5:02 pm
Posts: 2261
Full Member
 

If the bike in the video was a Ti framed fully rigid s/s 29er, leaning against a Skoda Octavia estate, lots of posters on here would be saying what a great product it was, & be falling over themselves to buy one.....

😉


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 5:36 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

A few things Gary;

Constructive critism on STW? - obviously not been on here much

The bike stil had reflectors on the wheels, that plasticy thing between the cassette and spokes, and what were you thinking about with the gear ratio it was in??

And that doesn't look like a trail centre car park either, thats a major flaw in your campaign. Just show it at Glentress with a bunch of [s]muppets[/s] kids about, jaw dropped in awe, and there X5 parents will be snapping them up.

Thanks me later


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 5:53 pm
Posts: 3443
Free Member
 

I'd think the market for this would be virtually non-existant, I'm afraid. The only people I could imagine buying it are non-cyclists who stumble across it and buy it as a stocking filler or something for the cyclist in their life, who would probably look at it blankly.

Also, I went to the website, and after clicking through 3 links I still don't know what it does really. I read the pitch but couldn't really visualise it, probably because I'm not really sure what the problem it's supposed to be solving actually is. Why not have a photo of it actually in use on the front page?

EDIT: I see what it does now, and sorry if it sounds harsh but this is the very definition of a solution in search of a problem.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 6:21 pm
Posts: 9332
Full Member
 

Well done for taking an idea and actually doing something with it. But...

This isn't a sales technique. I'm just looking for advice from the cycling community

but you have a website, warehouse and distribution centre in Nottinghamshire and an Administration, Sales & Marketing office in Berkshire. Sounds very much like you are not lokking for advice but instead some freebie promotion from a well read forum

With the country’s cycling success in the 2008 Olympics, and also the recession, the country is now being driven into an even more bike 'GREEN TRAVEL' tax break scheme crazy world

What does that actually mean?

Bike Lean Ltd manufactures the handy device to prevent your bike falling over during repairs, whilst cleaning, and whilst at rest.

No it doesn't. It locks the brake to stop it rolling forward or back, it does not prevent it falling over.

I'm not even slightly worried about laying my bike down on the ground whilst I'm not using it! It is a mountain bike and it will not get damaged on the ground.

I wouldn't use it if it was a magazine freebe, let alone pay for one.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 6:27 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

Yeah, but it does double as a helmet attachment point too.

💡 Oh, you could hang your helmet over the bars anyway, I guess.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 6:30 pm
Posts: 0
Free Member
 

It's quite an interesting idea, but as noted above, unfortunately solves a non-problem.

It looks nicely made and works well, from the video.

How about incorporating a wall bracket? some sort of hinged bracket for leaning your bike up outside when you're washing it?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 8:39 pm
Posts: 15433
Full Member
 

I'd say an "Andy stand" comes closer to solving this non-problem. Your website, marketing tactics and frankly crap product suggest Student design project thats gotten out of hand to me.

Nice try but don't quit the day job just yet.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 9:09 pm
Posts: 13433
Full Member
 

Bunch of suckers!

My guess is this is an A level project. Coursework deadlines will be the first day back after the Easter break and all A level Design students across the country are feverishly getting some evaluation into their portfolios. Feedback from "experts" or "potential consumers" is encouraged. For projects that have relatively minimal manufacturing skills demonstrated students are often encouraged to write a business plan or marketing/presentation material for the design - hence the website.

My take - nicely executed but bit of a fail I'm afraid. Task analysis has not really identified a real problem and the outcome adds little to the rider experience. If you had designed and made a small kit of parts that could be kept in a bag that applied the brakes and locked the steering so that a very light prop stand could hold the bike securely enough for "robust" cleaning or maintenance you might have produced a product with a purpose.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 9:32 pm
Posts: 8396
Full Member
 

No, I don't want one either. Yes, ditch the compass, but as well as the tyre lever could you have a wheelnut spanner for fixie crowd, with bottle opener and emergency gear hanger too.

Don't know about the weight, but if it were suitably robust could you use it for installing Superstar Components bottom brackets?


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 9:34 pm
Posts: 2
Free Member
 

Might be useful, if you store a bike in a house/flat. I used to store a bike in a flat in london. Pretty sure I knocked it over several times. Well there were black marks on the wall when I left.

This may have actually be useful then.


 
Posted : 11/04/2011 9:37 pm
Page 1 / 2