Forum menu
DH orientated jerseys don't usually have pockets in them
So wear a road or XC jersey
Superficial - MemberBecause it flaps around and is uncomfortable, and I wouldn't trust even tight roadie jerseys to securely hold my stuff when I'm smashing down a rocky bridleway.
I've never lost anything from one. Or found them uncomfortable*.
Like the Specialized glove box it's an image thing, it's no better than taping a spare tube to the saddle rails or a pump attached to the bottle cage, it's just that #ENDURO fashionista trendsetters have decided that they have to be hidden. Ditto jerseys, there is no valid reason to wear a DH jersey, but that's what people wear, then put the pockets on the shorts.
*the shame of my belly not being hidden aside.
[quote=legend ]Even race fit roadie tops don't hold kit as well as the SWAT bibs. The difference is that the pockets are suspended from the top and below, so there's no way they can bounce up/down or twist around the side.
In terms of comfort there's no difference, it's in holding things still that they differ massively
If you're carrying enough for that to be an issue then you're carrying too much - and would be better off with a camelbak/backpack or (dare I suggest it?) a seatpack on your bike.
[quote=Superficial ]That RaceFace thing is intriguing. It'd be nice to have it already loaded up and ready to go to minimise pre-ride faff, something you can't really do with jersey pockets.
What exactly is the problem with using a seatpack anyway? That's something where a seatpack also wins - I have one permanently on my bike, so don't have to think about picking up the right tubes etc. (also a much smaller one with just a couple of tubes in permanently attached to the road bike).
Like the Specialized glove box it's an image thing, it's no better than taping a spare tube to the saddle rails or a pump attached to the bottle cage, it's just that #ENDURO fashionista trendsetters have decided that they have to be hidden. Ditto jerseys, there is no valid reason to wear a DH jersey, but that's what people wear, then put the pockets on the shorts.
I'm not a fashionista, but I don't want to be one of 'those' people riding round my local woods (or anywhere else to be honest) in lycra, looking like i've gone off course from an XC race.
Baggy shorts & a tech tee is fine. I hate wearing a bag, so some form of thin, minimal base layer I can chuck a few little bits in is ideal.
What exactly is the problem with using a seatpack anyway? That's something where a seatpack also wins - I have one permanently on my bike, so don't have to think about picking up the right tubes etc. (also a much smaller one with just a couple of tubes in permanently attached to the road bike).
They don't work with dropper posts? Usually they need to be attached to the seatpost too.
Do people really need to carry multitools? Can't it go in a shorts pocket or one in the group carries one?
What's this crazy 'must have every option on me' mentality?
Tyre lever*2
One tube
Water
Spare money/change
Small pump
That's it.
If need be you can tape something to the frame.
[quote=Hob Nob ]I'm not a fashionista, but I don't want to be one of 'those' people riding round my local woods (or anywhere else to be honest) in lycra, looking like i've gone off course from an XC race.
Hmm, so not a fashionista, but more worried about image than practicality? FWIW I often wear baggies when riding nowadays, but with bibs underneath and paired with a roadie/XC top - you really don't look all that geeky wearing that, you are after all a grown man riding bikes for fun, so whatever your expectations you don't look normal whatever you're wearing.
They don't work with dropper posts? Usually they need to be attached to the seatpost too.
Not necessarily no - I have ones which just attach to saddle rails.
Do people really need to carry multitools?
Yes. It's better than having to walk home because of a small mechanical.
They don't work with dropper posts? Usually they need to be attached to the seatpost too.
A lot of small ones just have a solid plastic clip to the saddle rails.
Missing the point though, velco straps to the seatube, electrical tape to the stem, triathlon top tube bags. All valid options, but like lycra and jerseys with pockets don't fit the 'image'.
Right - I'm off to make my fortune with my new enduro range of seatpacks and close fitting jerseys with pockets then. Who should I sponsor to use my products?
This thread needs to be renamed "the 101 reasons why I'll make live with discomfort and impracticality because I think it doesn't look good" - subtitled no mudguards, seatpacks or roadie-inferred content 🙄
What's uncomfortable about wearing a pair of baggy riding shorts and a fitted technical t-shirt?
I can count on a small hand how many mechanicals that I've had out on the trail. If it's serious enough its a walk home anyway. Nipping up nuts and things should be predone weekly before a ride. If a chain shats itself the small chain tool and one set of power links should suffice. Wrapped of course.
As for mobile- I wouldn't trust those side pockets. Plus rain, hummidty from sweat etc can't be great for a fancy phone. At this end of the day though- just wrap your small multitool in something. Neopreen or abit of bubblewrap. Bizarre seeing riders with packs, the full cyclist uniform etc.
with a couple of different sized ratchet attachments to get my back wheel out pretty much describes the multi tool I was carrying.small chain tool
Far more use than tyre levers. They're only used by people with "office hands" 😛
Was also in a stickypod neoprene case and believe me it does nothing to protect you.just wrap your small multitool in something. Neopreen or abit of bubblewrap.
[quote=Hob Nob ]What's uncomfortable about wearing a pair of baggy riding shorts and a fitted technical t-shirt?
He did also say "impracticality" - and it appears you need to wear a roadie top underneath in order to make it practical...
Though now you mention your technical t being fitted, I'm wondering what the advantage of that is over just wearing a bike top with pockets.
Not actually what the OP wanted, but what about smaller top tube only frame bag.
I have a Revelate Tangle, goes between bikes and i can still fit two bottles in frame, really good size to carry rain jacket, tools, tube and a bit to eat, centred on bike and waterproof. Nice to get weight off of back.
But......never had anything drop out of jersey pockets except a gilet whcih i'd stuffed in badly
Any avid readers in the house? Has the mag done a test or review on these things or waist packs whilst we're here?
If you're carrying enough for that to be an issue then you're carrying too much - and would be better off with a camelbak/backpack or (dare I suggest it?) a seatpack on your bike.
If anything roadie tops are worse when you don't have that much in them, packing out the pockets (no, not so they are bulging) gives less room for things to jump around.
Standard SWAT carry: snacks and phone in left pocket, drink in middle, repair kit and tiny pump in right pocket. Hardly a wild setup. If going out all day then a hucksack gets worn. Spare tube lives under the top tube and the ride is far more enjoyable as I'm not wearing a bag