best mountain bike saddles

Best Mountain Bike Saddles: Are You Sitting Comfortably?

by 4

What’s the best mountain bike saddle? Why does my bum hurt when I’m riding? Saddle pain can affect both new and experienced riders. Here’s our guide to getting comfortable on a bike.

Saddle pain can affect both new and experienced riders: so here’s our guide to saddle comfort.

There are many things that can cause saddle discomfort. If you are struggling with pain or chafing, work through these steps to try and eliminate the issue. It may be that there is a combination of small changes that you can make that will make your rides more comfortable.

Bear in mind that your ride position will affect the position of your hips – this can explain why you might have been comfortably riding around on one saddle in an upright position on a hybrid, but that same saddle become torture when you switch to a mountain bike or bike with drop bars.

You are aiming to have your sit bones on the body of the saddle, so that your weight is on this most supportive part of your bottom. You want to keep your soft and sensitive tissue up front away from any weight bearing, and also free from rubbing. While these steps are written from the perspective of women’s saddle comfort, men may find some of them helpful to consider too.

These checks can be applied to the saddle you have now

  • Saddle height – you should be able to reach your pedals without stretching.
  • Fore/aft position of your saddle – are your sit bones on the body of the saddle?
  • Tilt of your saddle – flat or slightly tilted forwards will help keep your labia clear of pressing into the nose of the saddle.

Small alterations can make a big difference, so make tiny and iterative changes until you feel you’ve found the right position.

Features to look for when buying a saddle

  • Saddle width – saddles come in different widths, and you should try and match these to your sit bones. You can measure your sit bones at home: put a piece of tinfoil on the bottom stair, sit on and lift your feet off the floor so your weight goes through your sit bones. When you stand up, you will see two dimples where your sit bones are. Measure the distance between the centre of the two dimples, and then look for a saddle designed for that width of sit bones.
  • Saddle profile – If a saddle is too curved it may fit up between your legs and push into your soft tissue, rather than keeping a space between there and the saddle. A flatter profile may well be helpful.
  • Cut out – a cut out or recess in the centre of the saddle may help keep your soft tissue from pressing into the saddle. Look for one that is long enough to create that space even as your hips roll forward as you reach out to the bars.
  • Finish – you don’t want anything that is too slippery, or with raised seams that might cause pressure points, or with anything that might catch on your shorts just as you go for that tricky drop.

If you do buy a new saddle, remember to go back and check the position of it when you fit it, and make alternations if needed.

Why does my bum hurt when I’m riding?

If it’s your sit bones that hurt, make sure they’re supported on the body of your saddle. Make sure your saddle isn’t too high. Try a chamois short and chamois cream.

Why do I get chafing and blisters?

If you’re getting chafing and blisters, something is rubbing. Is your saddle supporting your sit bones? If they’re hanging off the edge because your saddle is too narrow, your sit bones may rub. If your saddle is too wide, the edges may be rubbing your inner thighs.

Do I just need to toughen up?

If it is your soft tissue – perineum and labia – that are hurting, definitely no! You should look to make sure you’re not supporting your weight on this area, and consider a chamois short and chamois cream to reduce chafing.

The next issue to look at is clothing

For longer rides – perhaps anything more than half an hour long, especially if you’re not in an upright position – you will probably feel the benefit of a cycling specific chamois lined short. Here are some features to look for.

Saddle comfort best saddle chamois
A quality chamois that fits well can improve comfort.
  • Seams and stitching – a higher quality short will have neater seams, and fewer potential points of chafing on the edge of the chamois. It’s worth investing in a decent chamois, rather than relying on one which came free with a pair of outer shorts.
  • Chamois fit – you want the chamois to fit snugly, with not so much bulk that it is folding or moving between your legs. It may provide a bit of padding around your sit bones, but up front you want it to provide a stable layer that doesn’t rub, rather than cushioning.
  • Chamois shape – a women’s specific chamois is moire likely to have padding in the right places – it’s likely you want something that is thinner up front, and thicker by your sit bones. Some have grooves or contours in the chamois – these may be comfortable for you, but they may provide tough spots in the chamois that chafe your labia.
  • Go commando – your skin should be against the chamois. Don’t wear underwear with you chamois shorts. Change and wash your chamois daily – don’t reuse it – just as you would underwear, and try to get out of it quickly after your ride to maintain good hygiene down there.

The last thing to look at is chamois cream

Particularly if you’re struggling with chafing, a chamois cream can help a lot. You need to choose something that is going to suit your skin, as it’s important that you smear it everywhere down there! Don’t just put it onto the skin on you bum cheeks – you need to put it all over your labia and anywhere that you’re find gets chafed. The chamois cream will help lubricate the area and stop things rubbing together.

A few final (intimate) points

Don’t be shy about having a bit of a rearrangement of what’s down there. Once you’ve got your chamois on, and your chamois cream, tuck that bit of labia in if it feels like it’s out of place. Arrange things so you’re not sitting on a fold – guys aren’t shy about rearranging their balls!

Whatever method of hair removal you use, it will likely affect your comfort. Try to avoid doing any hair removal or trimming the day before a long ride and you’ll help avoid any extra sensitivity issues.

You may well find that your body changes with your menstrual cycle, and sometimes it’s all but impossible to get comfy. Take extra care in getting ready for rides at those times – pick your favourite shorts, take a bit of extra time to get the chamois cream everywhere, tuck the tampon string out the way, and don’t try to ride for any distance with a sanitary towel.

Now get comfortable

Saddle comfort best saddle
Ride off in comfort and have fun!

It’s all down to your body and your ride position as to what you’ll find comfortable. Just as one pair of shoes can seem great to you and killer to a friend, saddles are a very personal choice. You need to find the perfect combination for you, but hopefully the pointers above will help guide you to a smooth ride.

Our personal choice of best mountain bike saddles (and the ‘worst’)

Their is no overarching ‘best’ or ‘worst’ when it comes to saddles. It entirely depends on your body and your riding position and bike setup.

All we can do it list the saddles that work for us (and some that definitely do not). Hopefully by looking at what saddles we do – and do not – like, you can draw up a shortlist of likely candidates.

Amanda’s saddle list

  • Specialized Power Pro Mimic – YES
  • Specialized Phenom Mimic – YES
  • Nukeproof Sam Hill – YES
  • Charge Spoon – NO
  • Most Fiziks – NO
  • Anything without a channel – NO

Benji”s saddle list

  • WTB Volt – YES
  • WTB SL8 – YES
  • Decathlon 30° Light Cycling – YES
  • Boardman MTR – YES
  • Charge Spoon – NO
  • Nukeproof Horizon – NO
  • Fizik Gravita Alpaca – NO

Charlie’s saddle list

  • Brooks Cambium C17 – YES
  • Fizik Vitesse Women’s – YES

Chipps’ saddle list

  • SDG Bel Air 3.0 – YES
  • Fizik Arione – YES
  • Fizik Aliante – YES

Hannah’s saddle list

  • Fizik Luna X5 Alloy Women’s – YES
  • Fizik Gravita Alpaca – NO

Mark’s saddle list

  • Charge Spoon – YES
  • Most WTB – YES
  • Most Specialized – NO

Join our mailing list to receive Singletrack editorial wisdom directly in your inbox.

Each newsletter is headed up by an exclusive editorial from our team and includes stories and news you don’t want to miss.

Signing up to our mailing list is not only a great way to keep up-to-date on all things Singletrack but it is also a great, free way to support us.

Sign up to receive awesome editorial content from Hannah every week.

We appreciate how handing over your email address is a mark of your trust in us. Check your inbox for our confirmation email and click the link to activate your newsletter.
We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Check out a previous newsletter here

While you’re here…

Discover more from Singletrack World Magazine

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Author Profile Picture
Hannah Dobson

Managing Editor

I came to Singletrack having decided there must be more to life than meetings. I like all bikes, but especially unusual ones. More than bikes, I like what bikes do. I think that they link people and places; that cycling creates a connection between us and our environment; bikes create communities; deliver freedom; bring joy; and improve fitness. They're environmentally friendly and create friendly environments. I try to write about all these things in the hope that others might discover the joy of bikes too.

More posts from Hannah

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Best Mountain Bike Saddles: Are You Sitting Comfortably?
  • qwerty
    Free Member

    “Measure the distance between the centre of the two dimples, and then look for a saddle designed for that width of sit bones.”

    I thought you were supposed to then add 2-4cm depending on cycling discipline?

    My sit bones are 10cm apart, centre to centre, there are no saddles that narrow.

    I’m interested in this as seeking out comfort over long rides.


    Full Member

    @qwerty Different manufacturers seem to deal with it in slightly different ways, but if you start with your actual sit bone width each saddle should have a recommended sit bone size range. Some have an online saddle finder which might help you once you’ve taken your measurements.

    Full Member

    Change you undercrackerz every day ?
    An excessively decadent lifestyle indeed.

    Free Member

    I’ve been nappyless for nearly 2 years now on my Chromag Trailmaster Ltd. It’s expensive but it fits my butt.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

The topic ‘Best Mountain Bike Saddles: Are You Sitting Comfortably?’ is closed to new replies.