First Ride Review | Shimano Deore XT M8100 1×12 Drivetrain & Brakes

by 1

Wil gets a first ride review on the brand new Shimano Deore XT M8100 groupset 

Last year Shimano unveiled its first 12-speed mountain bike groupset; also known as XTR M9100. With two new brake systems, the choice of 1×11, 1×12 and 2×12 drivetrain options, a huge 10-51t cassette, and the introduction of the Micro Spline freehub body standard, the new groupset packed a few hefty punches in Shimano’s ongoing battle with SRAM in the mountain bike drivetrain market.

Fast-forward 12 months, and despite a bumpy road with delivering XTR to market, Shimano says it’s ready to trickle down those XTR-pioneered technologies not just to the XT level, but also to SLX too.

shimano deore xt m8100 cassette 10-51t
For 2019 Shimano is taking XT up to 12-speed.

To summarise, there will be 1×12 and 2×12 drivetrain options, 10-45t & 10-51t cassettes, a new crankset with direct-mount chainrings, and both Race and Enduro brake options.

For all of the specs, prices, and weights of the two groupsets though, make sure you check out the full tech feature here.

XTR Inspired Performance, Workhorse Approach

Whereas XTR is 100% focussed on racing, Shimano’s XT components take a more workhorse approach. With a few changes to materials and construction techniques, Shimano has been able to whittle down manufacturing costs, bringing an XT 1×12 drivetrain to basically half the cost of XTR.

With less exotic materials, there’s of course more weight. According to Shimano, an XT groupset packs an extra 365g over XTR. Most of this weight difference is attributed to the cranks and cassette.

shimano deore xt m8100 crankset chainring 1x12
The XT cranks still use hollow alloy arms, but they now get a direct-mount chainring.

Whereas XTR features a one-piece alloy chainring and crank arms are made from two heavily-machined clamshells that are then bonded together, XT uses a hybrid alloy/steel chainring and a single forged construction to create the hollow alloy crank arms. This adds over 100g to the XT crankset (620g vs 511g for 175mm crank arms w/32t chainring).

Likewise, there’s over a 100g weight difference in the XT cassette. Skipping the titanium sprockets of XTR (and only using alloy for the two largest sprockets) it comes in at a claimed 460g for the 10-51t ratio compared to 367g for XTR. As a consequence, the XT cassette is likely to be more durable in the long run though – an important attribute for those of us who aren’t sponsored pros.

shimano deore xt m8100 cassette 10-51t
Only the two largest sprockets are alloy, while the rest are steel.

Short & Sweet

As part of the XT & SLX launch, I was invited out to Girona in Spain to test out the new groupsets on some fabulous trails that criss-cross the Montseny mountain range.

We had three days of riding in total, with Shimano cobbling together an array of different test bikes for us journos from Orbea, Cube and Scott.

I rode an Orbea Rallon on the first day, which was outfitted with a 1×12 drivetrain and the 4-piston Enduro brakes. I then jumped on an Oiz full suspension XC bike on the third day to test out the same drivetrain setup, but with the 2-piston Race brakes.

orbea oiz
For the XC ride, I jumped aboard an Orbea Oiz outfitted with a 1×12 XT drivetrain and 2-piston Race brakes.

Of note is that there were no functional 2x drivetrains on any of the test bikes, so sadly I was unable to satisfy my curiosity around the new Mono Lever front shifter. I bet the front shifting is amazing too, even if the market for it is shrinking every week.

For me, riding the new groupsets couldn’t have come at a better time. I’d just come off the back of the Pivot Mach 4 SL launch, where I’d been using Shimano’s XTR M9100 1×12 drivetrain and 2-piston Race brakes. As such, I was in a good position to make a comparison with the new XT components.

shimano deore xt m8100 cassette chain 10-51t
Hyperglide+ shift profiling on the XT cassette is designed to perform under power.

Hyping Up Hyperglide+

Straight-up, there is very little difference in the shift quality between XT and XTR. Well, at least from what I could perceive anyway.

The Shimano Deore XT M8100 1×12 drivetrain is very slick indeed, and the Hyperglide+ technology in particular is properly impressive. This is tech that Shimano has worked into its new wide-range cassettes (starting with XTR M9100), and it’s all about letting the chain glide up and down the cassette as rapidly as possible, whether you’re on or off the gas.

wil girona spain orbea oiz
Forget everything you were not meant to do when shifting – the XT 1×12 drivetrain can take it.

To test this, I tried to shift as badly as I possibly could. Full power, out-of-the-saddle mashing, dumping gears in both directions without letting any pressure off the pedals – basically everything you’re taught not to do when you get your first bike with gears. Despite my bullish shifting, the XT mech clicked up and down the cassette with minimal hesitation, laughing at my piss-poor efforts to defeat it.

Despite being abused under pressure, the cassette delivers shock-less shifting that is fast and crisp. Even when multi-downshifting, there is next to no lag, helping to maintain cadence. It really is quite marvellous.

wil orbea oiz spain
I was glad for the low-range gearing on the 25% gradients we clipped during the XC ride day.

Lo-Fi Low-Range

Up front our test bikes were all fitted with 30t chainrings, which I initially thought was a bit low given the enormous 10-51t cassette. Within the first 10 minutes of the XC ride though, I was happy to have the low range, as we ground our way steep 25% singletrack climbs. You can go lower too, with Shimano offering XT chainrings down to 28t.

The chainring gets a narrow/wide tooth profile, which Shimano calls Dynamic Chain Engagement+ technology. This provides secure chain retention, and not one journo dropped a chain throughout the three days of riding.

shimano deore xt m8100 orbea oiz
The narrow-wide tooth profile connects seamlessly with the new XT 12-speed chain.

The other part of the equation is the new 12-speed chain, which features extended and bevelled inner plates that are designed to increase contact with the chainring teeth. This creates a very snug and slop-free interface that also feels really smooth too.

Wider Q-Factor

With the new XT and SLX cranksets, Shimano will be offering up three different chainlines for different rear hub widths. There’s a 52mm chainline (non-Boost & Boost), 55mm (Boost), 56.5mm (Super Boost Plus).

The cranks also sit wider, which is to maximise clearance and compatibility with more frames – especially as modern trail bikes aim to fit wider and wider tyres. It does mean that the Q-Factors are broader though. Compared to the narrower 162mm & 168mm Q-Factor options of XTR, XT starts at 172mm and goes up to a very broad 181mm.

orbea oiz wil
The XT cranks sit a bit wider than XTR – good for stability, but something to consider for slim-hipped riders and racers.

For slender riders with narrow hips, this may be something worth bearing in mind. But for bigger riders and those who prefer a wider stance on the bike though, the wider XT cranks will be ideal.

Chunky, Punchy Shifting

In the past Shimano’s trigger shifters were known for their smooth, effortless shifting feel, which was a direct hand-me-down quality from the world of Dura-Ace and Ultegra. That’s no longer the case though, with the latest XTR and XT shifters offering a much punchier and positive shift feel.

shimano deore xt m8100 shifter
The new XT shifter offers a punchy, audible shift action.

Compared to a SRAM Eagle shifter, the Shimano Deore XT M8100 trigger has a chunkier action – particularly on the smaller up-shift paddle. There’s a real audible quality to each shift, which comes in handy when you’re banging down shouty descents. I also really like the ability to up-shift two gears in one throw, something the XT shifter shares with XTR. You can also down-shift up to four gears in one throw, but my little thumbs could only ever get three.

Both paddles are textured, with the big paddle getting a rubber panel that feels wonderful on bare thumbs, and usefully grippy with gloves.

Our test bikes had the direct-mount I-SPEC EV bracket, which bolts the shifter directly to the brake lever clamp. A hidden 3mm hex bolt affords 14mm of lateral adjustment and 20° angular adjustment for getting the paddles in exactly the right spot.

shimano deore xt m8100 i-spec ev shifter brake lever
With the I-Spec EV option, the shifter bolts to the brake lever clamp for a neat setup.

Shimano Deore XT M8100 Brakes

While we’re up at the bars, it’s worth talking about the new master cylinder design for the XT M8100 brakes.

Like XTR, the XT lever puts the split bar clamp in the middle of the body, while the end is braces up neatly against the bar. Shimano says this design is friendly on carbon bars, though of course you’ll always want to use a torque wrench for the main clamping bolt. The split clamp still has that little safety pin, which you have to depress before the clamp flips open.

shimano deore xt m8100 brake lever
Dimpled lever blade with tool-free reach adjustment.

The new lever is used for both the XC (2-piston) and Enduro (4-piston) brakes. There’s a tool-free reach adjustment, the slightly useless Free Stroke adjuster, and a lovely alloy lever blade that is dimpled for your braking pleasure.

My Orbea Oiz was outfitted with the XT Race brakes, which actually use the same 2-piston callipers and pads as the previous M8000 brakes. With the new master cylinder though, the braking feel is a touch smoother. The bite point is still rock solid – that is unchanged over previous Shimano hydraulic disc brakes. But there’s a touch less of the on/off digital brake feel that the M8000 XT brakes had, with a little more modulation early on.

shimano deore xt m8100 brake rotor freeza
The 2-piston callipers carry over for the XT Race brakes.

Quad-Piston Power

That said, I still preferred the 4-piston Enduro brakes. Despite having more power (Shimano says they’re 22% more powerful), the 4-piston callipers seem to deliver better control when the pads first contact the rotor. There’s a really nice usable zone of control that allows you to really feather the power while on steeper and skittish surfaces.

The only downside of the Enduro brakes is with the finned brake pads, which rattle about in the calliper. This is an issue I’ve experienced before with the XTR Enduro brakes, and it appears to be present at both the XT and SLX level too. From what I could deduce at the launch, it seemed specific to the finned pads. You can get the pads to sit tighter in there by physically opening up the spring, but it would be really nice for them not to rattle in the first place. Annoyance levels may vary, but if you’re bothered by such things, consider going for the non-finned pads.

Speaking of pads, the shape is the same as the XTR 4-piston brakes. Which is to say that they’re different to Zee/Saint brake pads.

shimano deore xt m8100 brake 4-piston
The 4-piston Enduro calliper is all new though, with the same pad shape as the new XTR Enduro brakes.

Shimano Deore XT M8100 Hubs & Micro Spline

As part of the full XT groupset, Shimano will be offering complete wheels in both Race and Enduro variants. Unfortunately due to Spanish customs though, there were no complete wheels at the launch. Instead, our test bikes had custom carbon wheels built around the new XT hubs.

Inside the rear hub is essentially the same helically-driven ratchet mechanism featured in the XTR Scylence hub, except it’s sort-of-not-quite silent. I’d say it’s one of the quietest freewheeling hubs I’ve ridden though, with a nice lo-fi buzz that kinda sounds like a stealthy cross between a DT Swiss and Chris King hub. Pickup is quick, with a suitably fast 7° engagement.

shimano deore xt m8100 hub micro spline
The XT rear hub can be had in 142, 148 and 157mm spacing options.

With our test bikes featuring prototype hubs, I found the buzzing sound on my bike was somewhat inconsistent. When freewheeling at speed, the buzz would occasionally stutter like an old lawnmower on start-up. Mind you, I couldn’t really hear this on the trail – only when spinning the rear wheel in the workstand.

This is apparently due to the way the helical drive disconnects from the drive ratchet. In some cases it can disconnect completely, which creates a brief moment of silence (or Scylence). It had no effect on function though, since as soon as you step on the pedals, the helical drive pulls the drive ring down and locks the two ratchets together. According to the Shimano technicians, this issue will be rectified with production models.

orbea oiz wil spain girona
We’re excited about the new XT groupset, but we’ll have to wait and see if Shimano can follow through with production.

First Impressions

Sorry, but the rest of this article is for members only. If you have an account, please Login here. If not, you can get access by registering here for free.

Members get access to exclusive content like this but they also get..

  • Fewer ads
  • Post comments to stories
  • Join in forum discussions
  • Sell unwanted kit for free in our Classifieds
  • Automatic shop discount on Singletrack merchandise
  • Access more members only content

Premier members get more

  • Magazine content in print 6x/year post free
  • App access to every new issue of Singletrack
  • Ad free website
  • Big discounts on shop merchandise
  • Access downloads like GPX files, PDFs and even iBooks
  • Full mag archive access to all Singletrack back issues

Premier membership starts at just £2.50

FREE TRIAL OFFER

Sign up for any of our membership plans and we won’t take payment from your account for 7 days. Try out the ad free website and access our magazine archive for free for 7 days. Cancel your account within the 7 days and no payment will be taken. Free Trial provides access to digital features only and does not include printed copies. Excludes gift subscriptions.

Why do you ask for registration to view some articles?

We get asked this a lot. The simple reason is that content is increasingly expensive to commission, create and publish and where once the cost of this process was mostly covered by advertising revenues, now that’s no longer the case. We increasingly rely on our paying members to keep Singletrack going and we’d love you to become one of our supporters. however, that’s not we are asking right now. You can read the rest of this feature simply by registering an account on our site.

How does being a free, registered user help you?

It’s NOT so we can sell your email details, or even to send you newsletters. Our last newsletter was sent out in early 2018 – we really should send out a few. It’s not so we can show you more ads either – in fact when you register we show you fewer ads. The reason is actually because registered users come back and look at more of our content. They start interacting with us and posting comments of their own and joining in forum discussion. That level of interaction is what eventually feeds our new subscriber numbers and so for us the journey to gaining new subscribers is to start by encouraging you to simply register an account. We hope that the benefits that will bring to you will be the first step in you joining us as a Singletrack Premier supporter.

Disclaimer

Wil’s flights and accommodation for the XT/SLX launch were covered by Shimano.


Premier member gallery extra

Sorry but this content is only available to our Premier Members.

Premier membership plans start at just £2.50.

Summer Sale!
£5 Off First Payment*
Use this code – stsum5-19

Select your membership option below an enter this code on the next screen – *Excludes monthly memberships

Review Info

Brand:Shimano
Product:Deore XT M8100 Groupset
From:bike.shimano.com
Price:1x12 drivetrain from £535, Race brakes from £129 per end, Enduro brakes from £169 per end
Tested:by Wil Barrett for 3 days

Comments (1)

    Whats the deal on chainline? There’s a 52mm chainline (non-Boost & Boost), 55mm (Boost), 56.5mm (Super Boost Plus).

    A boost 55mm ? Surely the chainline would be out on a boost rear which would be 49 to 52? I confess that after 30 years mtbing this 1x chainline saga has got to be the biggest standard cock. ‍♂️

Leave a Reply