So my mate and I ended up riding the Kinder Loop clockwise, starting at Edale, then up onto Rushop Edge (brilliant descent, but put a hole in my High Rollers which I was running tubeless and the hole was too big for the gloop to plug so I had to put a DH tube in), then down into Roych Clough and oh my word what a descent that is; huge great slabs, drops and plenty of places to really launch the bike either over gap steps or of the nicely built up drainage gaps.
The climb out of Roych wasn't too bad making me think that it wouldn't make as good a descent as the other way around although it's good to see that the smooth groomed grading they put down back in 2004 is now starting to break up a little. The drop down Mt Famine was excellent once you get off the open trail and onto the enclosed double track with big catch bermed turns so you can absolutely pin them. Again, lots of water bars with nicely built up ramps so you can jump then quite cleanly.
The little gem on the ride is the drop into Hayfield down Coldwell Clough. That was always a favourite but I'd really forgotten how sweet it is.
The climb back up to Edale Cross had too much on it that would have been a bit pedestrian although the second section in the now fenced off field is certainly more interesting than it used to be.
The rocky section up to Edale Cross would be great in reverse but there were sections where you might find yourself loosing some speed because the gradient isn't so steep.
The drop down from Edale Cross was just brilliant. Back in the day we rode this on our £300 fully rigid CroMo specials and it was never that much fun because it was a trail just crying out for full suspension. I'm so glad we have bikes like this now; Jacobs Ladder may have been tamed but it's still pretty challenging to ride it fast, i.e. OFF THE BRAKES all the way down!
I think it's a great route either way, but if you want each descent to be the best it can be, then I think clockwise is the way to do it.