I have one of the slightly odd Columbia Outdry jackets. The looks may not be to everyones taste but in terms of waterproofness it’s the best I’ve had, also breathes well. Apparently, the waterproofing won’t wear off either as its the membrane on the outside as opposed to inside with a DWR treatment on the outer face. It’s a wee bit crinkly sounding and looks like something a sailor may wear but you know, I’m ok with that. Also you can find em cheap on sportpursuit from time to time
Got an Altura Attack 360 for what looked like a wet weekend in Scotland. It did rain enough for me to put it on, but not really enough to determine how waterproof it actually was. I did keep it on for the rest of the day though and was impressed with how un-sweaty I was by the end of it despite doing boat loads of climbing, the pit zips work really well. Seems very nicely made, fabric is slightly stretchy which means it feels less “plastic bag” when wearing it.