The sigmasport guy said… (with a 50t front)
I normally like as tight a cassette as possible when I am riding; a 12-25 is my default ratio and I’ll only change to something bigger when travelling to mountainous areas. Needless to say, the idea of an 10-36 cassette on a road bike seemed ludicrously wide and I was sure that I would be constantly shifting up and down in a vain attempt to find the right cadence, but to my surprise, I was much less bothered by it than I expected to be.
Which I read as being “it wasn’t as crap as I expected it to be, but it was still a bit crap”.
I can’t remember which review it was in but someone also made a good point about group rides (and same would apply to riding to a zone). That if you need to ride at some specific speed and that’s between gears for a preferred cadence then you’ll be spinning or grinding. Not having the right gear would annoy me.