I also ran a Thudbuster in my old hardtail and thought it was great. Really took the harshness out of the ride. Yes they are a bit fugly but that really doesn't bother me.
I'm trying to get it to fit my current hardtail but i'm having nightmares trying to shim it in (i 'futureproofed' by going for the 27.2 version so i'd fit other bikes). Worked great in my trek but just won't stay still on my spesh or kona (unless i use another fugly double clamp rather than the qr).
If you are unsure then try and borrow one if you can. If you were local to me i'd probably let you have a punt with mine (i'm just south of Brum).