When the Boardman Team Carbon was under a grand the debate was pretty much closed. I bought it on the C2W scheme intending to keep it as my commuter / winter bike. However, it was that good that I ended up flogging a far more expensive carbon race bike, as I knew it just wasn’t going to get used any more.
Downsides?
– Watch the sizing – they come up a little on the large side (medium has a 55cm effective TT)
– Wheels are a bit of a drag: aero, but heavy. Apart from that most of the equipment is very good.
– You’ll invariably get comments from bike snobs about riding a Halfords bike.
It’s now £1200, which means it’s not quite the same value it was, but still a very, very good buy.
For under a grand, the Planet X SL Pro is the best value for money at the moment.
Seeing as you say ‘about a grand’ rather than ‘under a grand’, I’d go with the Boardman, but both will offer you a great ride with plenty of potential to upgrade in the future.