Club all the way, hundreds of members means hundreds of possible new ideas.
We’re a road club that does everything including mountain biking. We even purchased local permits as a club, which saves the off roaders £50 a year if they had to buy them. Free from us.
Our road rides are in three groups every Sunday. These are led by a ride leader and put on Facebook in advance so people can select an appropriate group. Then download it.
The club ride is very disciplined an people like that. Egos are given no quarter. If they want to show off they can, but the ride won’t respond. And repeat offenders will have to be told. The rides will often include some of our top racers, newcomers like this inclusiveness and it puts the egos in place. Racers never give it the big I am on social rides.
When we train we either do it as individuals or with like minded members. Training/stravaing is frowned upon on club runs, or rather using the club run to achieve your personal goals is if you know what I mean.
We race just about everything. Audax is popular. Off road of course. We’ll ride mainland Europe quite a lot, hitting the hotspots like the Alps, Pyrenees, Flanders and Spanish suncamps.
But being in a club doesn’t mean you have to ride with them all the time. Just bugger off alone or pm a mate.
Never seen the problem.