I got a dhb one from Wiggle that seems to do the job.
I'd go for a 'flap at the back' one over one with a zip all the way round. A friend we ride with had a zip all the way round one & the zip failed (presumably because of the weight constantly pulling on it) & he lost his car key from it. Luckily we found the key, but he was panicking for a while!
With the 'flap at the back' ones, there is no load on the zip, apart from keeping the flap shut.
I think you'd have to be pretty unlucky for either of them to fail, but I'd rather not risk it & go for what I see is the safer option.