I have HI persimmon for dawn, dusk and overcast wintery days (the HI doesn't stop it sometimes clearing up and being "too" bright, but is excellent for cutting out the glare if it's wet, for example), clear for night riding, blk irid for daytime stuff. Want a really dark, polarised lens too for high summer, but $$ at the moment doesn't allow.
yellow you can get away with for night riding too, which means you don't have to stop and change the lens, but if you are getting options that may not matter to you.
Personally, I think the persimmon will be "too" close to the one you have, so go yellow (and clear if you can!)