Still torn between keeping my 26″ mk2 alloy Nomad going or getting a mk3 and having to go 650b. Either way I need new wheels though as wrecked the ones on the mk2, but I still rather like the old mk2 and the mk3 still seems a bit OTT for me, but does look gorgeous.
having recently upgraded from a MK2 carbon nomad to a MK3 nomad, I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it, especially if your upgrading wheels anyhow (although you will also need new forks. if you like the MK2 you’ll love the Mk3, especially in the increased stiffness / strength of moving to carbon and I wouldn’t say it’s OTT compared to the MK2 after riding it for a few months – same type of bike intended for the same purpose. not night and day different, just incrementally and noticeably better in in nearly every facet
originally I’d planned to go for a MK2 Bronson, being more similar to the MK2 nomad on paper (and like you thinking the nomad ight be a bit OTT), but got the chance for a cheap second hand MK3 nomad frame, went for it and very pleased I did