New Car Dilemma « Singletrack Forum

Chat Forum

[closed]

New Car Dilemma

73 posts & 38 voices | Started 2 years ago by algarvebairn | Latest reply from Black

Tags:

No tags yet.

Pages: 12 3 Next »

algarvebairn - Member

I'm getting shot of my BMW 6 series. Its a nice car but its getting harder to justify the cost and tbh if feel like a bit of a dick in it. I've always been a hot hatch sort of a guy and the cars before the BMW were Golf GTi, Alfa 147, Golf Gti, Golf GTi.

So I'm thinking Golf, Scirocco, Alfa Brera, Focus ST, Mini Cooper S and I've got £15k to spend so Scirocco is probably out. No bike duties as I have a Pickup. There is the daily school run to contend with but as far as practicality goes I just need 4/5 seats.

Can anyone inspire me?

Posted 2 years ago #
b r - Member

How about a 'little' BMW 130i?

Posted 2 years ago #
algarvebairn - Member

b r, meant also to say i'm no great fan of RWD cars. I only ever felt confident in the BMW on a totally dry surface although I freely admit that this may be down to my driving ability asw opposed to the car.

Posted 2 years ago #
mike-at-dialledbikes - Member

I'd go for a Golf GTI (not the current version, but the previous one) or an Audi TT.

Posted 2 years ago #
algarvebairn - Member

Bump.

Come on guys the stw hordes normally love a car thread.

Posted 2 years ago #
flip - Member

I've just had a VW Tiguan, totally love it give me new respect for German cars.

Posted 2 years ago #
flip - Member

Oh i test drove a Cooper s a few mths ago and while fun and nippy the rear space was truly poo.

Posted 2 years ago #
Gingerbloke - Member

Pure fun, I would go for an Imported Honda Integra Type-R, 220bhp rev monster!!!!

But the Civic can take a couple of bikes as well as having loads of space for kids!!

Posted 2 years ago #
PeteG55 - Member

Focus ST, should get a nice one for your budget and a bit newer than a golf for the same money. General consensus suggests the Focus a better handling machine too.

Posted 2 years ago #
CaptainFlashheart - Member

4 door A3 with a lunatic turbo-diesel and quattro. Yum.

Posted 2 years ago #
Hairychested - Member

How about an Astra SRi?

Posted 2 years ago #
Edukator - Member

Lupo or C1

Posted 2 years ago #
CaptainFlashheart - Member

Lupo or C1

as far as practicality goes I just need 4/5 seats.

Rules out the Lupo, IMO. Don't know about the C1

Posted 2 years ago #
dooosuk - Member

Sounds like you'd be happiest back with a Golf GTI to me.

Or how about an R32?

Focus ST would be a good shout it you want a change of marque.

How's the depreciation on the Alfa?

Posted 2 years ago #
parkesie - Member

2nd hand brera q4 dribble

Posted 2 years ago #
algarvebairn - Member

Dooosok. Don't really fancy another golf. Having had mark 1,2 and 4 I thought they were getting progressively worse.

Flip, the lack of space will rule out the cooper.

Gingerbloke, forgot about civic type r. Good shout.

I quite like the focus but I'm 37 and don't know if I'm a bit old.

Maybe a crazy-ass a3 as the cap'n suggests may be the shout.

Posted 2 years ago #
Jimbo - Member

The Brera is NOT practical! No room in the back whatsoever, despite what the rear "seats" would otherwise suggest.

Posted 2 years ago #
scottyjohn - Member

Get an audi a4 3tdi quattro avant s-line, amazing cars with amazing fuel economy

Posted 2 years ago #
Jase - Member

Your 37, get the new Volvo hot hatch then

Posted 2 years ago #
markenduro - Member

Passatt r32?

Posted 2 years ago #
GJP - Member

A3 Sportback 2.0T FSI Quattro - understated, stunning engine and the real Audi 4WD experience.

Nothing wrong with what scottyjohn says either but I would avoid the 2.0TDi (tractors) other than the new common rail ones

Posted 2 years ago #
netgoose - Member

save the planet, get fit, save money, get one of these...

Posted 2 years ago #
DickBarton - Member

Alfa

Posted 2 years ago #
b r - Member

b r, meant also to say i'm no great fan of RWD cars. I only ever felt confident in the BMW on a totally dry surface although I freely admit that this may be down to my driving ability asw opposed to the car.

Ok, then spend some money learning to drive one. I'd recommend the Jonathan Palmer outfit over in Bedford - I've been a couple of times on sponsored/corporate days and drove everything karts, Caterhams, Clios, 911's, Formula Audi, 3/4scale Le Mans, Nissan 350's. Plus did wet weather stuff, electronics on (and off) training etc.

On my second trip I even got the 'Driver of the Day' trophy - which really pissed off the BMW/Audi/Merc sales-manager contingent.

Posted 2 years ago #
Marin_Maketh_The_Man - Member

Try a Mk V golf GTI. Worlds apart from any earlier models in terms of power delivery, grip and handling. Sadly had to hand mine back at the end of its 4 year lease 2 weeks ago after 115,000 smiley miles.

Posted 2 years ago #
algarvebairn - Member

Veering towards focus. I'd go and test drive one if it wasn't snowing again!

Posted 2 years ago #
bruk - Member

Slightly off topic maybe but what about a Skoda Superb V6. Was nosying around for STW favourite car ie Octavia and noticed the prices of those things drops very quickly. Ugly but q-car material.

Posted 2 years ago #
Black - Member

Alfa 147 will be replaced this year, so dinnae buy that.

New Renaultsport Megane?

Which model 6 series are you getting shot of?

Posted 2 years ago #
PeteG55 - Member

GJP - Member
A3 Sportback 2.0T FSI Quattro - understated, stunning engine and the real Audi 4WD experience.

Nothing wrong with what scottyjohn says either but I would avoid the 2.0TDi (tractors) other than the new common rail ones

Now I could well be wrong on everything I say, but as far as I'm aware....
A3 is a Golf and will have the VW 4Motion drivtrain (transverse mounted engine) not the longditudinal setup of a real Audi Quattro. I'm not sure what 'the real Audi 4WD experience' is, but if the quattros I've driven are anything to go by, conventional FWD Golf/Audi is a better drive, with better performance and economy. Audi Quattros have always been front wheel drive bias with nose heavy handling.
The 2.0TDi's are all common rail where as the 1.9 before it wasn't. Some of the 1.9s were a conventional diesel distributor pump and could be described as adequate, but later PD 1.9s were a different beast and generally a good engine. There was 130bhp versions of this engine and I'm pretty sure there was also a 150bhp version in a VW car too.

Posted 2 years ago #
molgrips - Member

There's also a diesel TT.

TBH tho all those cars you mentioned will make you look like a dick. If you mean Golf as in GTI.

If you like to drive fast then I'd definitely avoid the old PD engines - they are the one with all the torque low down. The new CR engines are way better to drive, they keep on pulling faster to the red line. Also the 140bhp 2.0 TDI workhorse goes to 200bhp with a simple remap.

Posted 2 years ago #
mastiles_fanylion - Member

or an Audi TT.

They are a lovely car (although not good in a fight against a Landy 110 as I have just found out )

I have the 2wd 2.0l petrol turbo and it is very quick with amazing low end torque. But after driving my cousin's RS4 I would seriously consider the Quattro next time simply because there is too much power to put down on a front wheel drive car in anything other than perfect dry conditions.

Posted 2 years ago #
algarvebairn - Member

Black,

The 147 is being replace by th enew Guilleta, right?

The BMW is a 635 diesel.

Posted 2 years ago #
molgrips - Member

There is also a 4wd diesel TT.

Posted 2 years ago #
mike-at-dialledbikes - Member

Mastiles Fanylion, what's the TT like for bike carrying duties?

Posted 2 years ago #
mastiles_fanylion - Member

It can get one in with the back seat down and a wheel off. It does have a surprisingly big boot (as in length and width), it is not very deep though.

I reckon at a push I could get two in with both wheels off.

Posted 2 years ago #